I think I am rediscovering the wheel... Need your opinion

Trying to find a solution to the rustling noise of soft bagged baby wipes, I keep tinkering with the gravity holders and having to solve all kind of design problems.

So far, I have considered two possibilities:

https://youtu.be/nI9gDQICeAY?si=mx9E_1SvbAn7aFVe 

 

Which one would you prefer?

  1. The Hinged Holder with a Pressure Plate
  2. The Telescopic Holder

 

1. Hinged Holder with a Pressure Plate

 

 

2. Telescopic Holder