What's wrong?

Anyone encountered the case where your route is showing errors (red and/or yellow), but you are not able to figure out where and what is the problem? When i was still new to routing i thought that clicking "What's wrong?" would help me.... but of course, it doesn't.

My question would be is - How to determine where is the problem, when no relations are dangling or undefined, and "What's Wrong?" gives you some vague answer (something like - Rounting fittings could not be created for some segments. examine the properties of the connection point at each ends of the segments, and specify the same properties for both points)

Any word on whether "What's wrong?" option will be improved in the neasr future to actually show us where the problem is?

Cheers

SolidworksRouting
Answers 3
PV
PV 2014-05-07 Best Answer

Mladen,

It's been that way since I start using Routing back in 2009 and I don't really expect much to chance anytime soon concerning that.

The only reason I click the 'what's wrong" anymore in routing is ...euh....because euh.... well actual it's mostly useless. I have even mentioned it to my VAR and someone from SW Routing that having the "what's wrong" telling you that something somewhere is wrong because of some reason without actually pin-pointing what or where is not helpfull at all.

Having a route going from being perfectly fine to full christmas tree as I call it (red and yellow lights afterall) and then getting the "examine the properties of the connection point at each ends of the segments" on a route will lots of turns, flanges, T's and such is not only not helpfull but it wants me to pick my computer and throw it through the window.

The only way I have found to nail down one of those elusive errors that don't show any relations being dangling or over- or undefined is by using the method of elimination. In other words, start deleting parts of the route until you can narrow down where it goes wrong, being carefull not to save and any point. After you figure out roughly where it happens you can start zeroing in on that area and repeating the process until you figured out exactly what the culprit is. No guarantee though. I have it happen that even then, spending better part of an hour on it,  I couldn't find what and where something went wrong. I then rebooted my computer, opened the route again and...... there was nothing wrong.

Sometimes, it just uses it's own logic. E.g.: I have it happen that a route was OVER-defined, I added an additional relation and it promptly became under-defined. *shrug*

The best advise I can offer you is keep your routing ASM's short. It's very tempting to make a 1 pipe_asm route from start to finish but in the long run it will save you time and trouble (not to mention keeping your bloodpressure down) if you make the 1 route with several pipe_asm's, for instance each time you have a flange connection make it a new pipe_asm. That way, if something goes wrong it will only be a small part and not an entire route.

Have a nice one

Peter

MP
MP 2014-05-07

Thanks Peter.

I know that i should keep the ASMs short, but sometimes i just have to make a complicated route. For example, this is the route that prompted me to start this topic.

The route itself is not too complicated, but there are a lot of parts to it. Every flange set has gaskets.. id adds up, but i have to do it this way, since we do not fabricate our own stuff, so i need to be sure that my dimensions match the real product. cannot "fake" it in any way.

And what i have found so far, is that, if you model most complex route you can image, from scratch, you will most likely be OK. IF you save it and go back to edit the route and add a part you will run into problems. But if you take some piping part/fiiting out, you're screwed. Easier to delete the route and start from the beggining again

Anyway,

did i forgot to mention that i do not have any errors after restarting the program in the morning??

Cheers

comment imagecomment image
MC
MC 2014-05-07

Mladen,

I have errors that show up where the route feature in the FMT is red but the 3Dsketch inside is not red. The way I solve this is by deleting 1 dimension and then re-add the dimension. This works with any dimension you want I typically use 1 thats a remove pipe then I just remove pipe again. Attached is an example of the size of routes that we typical design.