I have an imported ford chassis rail that I have done cuts and trims on before. Now I'm trying to trim an area for an accessibility ramp and I'm getting this error message "The trimmed pieces selected cannot be sewn together" and I cannot complete the trim. IDGAF if the pieces can be sewn together. Theres nothing to sew to in the first place... just me trim surface and the body to be trimmed. The trimming surface is just that, a trimming surface, nothing more, and will be hidden after I can get this to cooperate.
SolidworksParts And Features
can you attach a screenshot or part file.
Trying to trim away the small section, i've already trimmed the other side and it worked just fine
extend your trim surface past solid body and ensure that you are not tangent to the hole on the top face!
Are you using cut with surface ? Is the surface larger then the beam ? Can you hide all the surrounding bodies except the one you want to cut and post another image ?
I am trying to post the part file but when i hiut add reply it greys out and i stay on the reply message page
also no i am using trim surface
What about just put a sketch on the plane/surface and use plain cut extrude. If not can you upload a part with this body and surface and just get rid of the other bodies.
I think the key to this is in the message...."trimmed pieces". I wonder if the trim surface cuts through and makes multiple solid bodies. Since the trim sheet can only be used by one body the other body(ies) fail to sew.
see attached
at least you're getting some attention.
i tried moving the plane so it doesn't intersect any of the frame holes and still nothing. The forum won't let me attatch the part file for some reason
yes i know how to attatch but its not letting me. i attatch the file and click add reply and it greys out and im stuck on the reply message page
post to my thread!!!!!!
I'm still on 2015
you might be over complicating by using the surface.
try a simple extruded cut (using a rectangle) either up to surface OR blind and give the dimension.
can't use extruded cut, this is a surface body
can you save it out out as a step(214) file and post that?
Or a Parasolid file type..one of many.
yes
Yeah, this model is nothing but individual surfaces. Sew the surfaces together to get the members you need and then I'd use a split body function since all the geometry is non-parametric.
The framerail itself is one surface with many open faces. I think Im going to take this frame back to the drawing board. Re-import it differently and see if I can get a better result. I think that will be faster and more efficient than trying to find all of these open faces and patching them. Thank you guys for your help though.
That would probably be best. If your original file is stp/step file then make sure you turn on "stitch" or "sew" or "knit" option when importing. That way you may end up solid bodies instead of surfaces. The step file you provided has an open end/cap on the rail where you cut it once. This condition won't allow you to knit it together to form a solid. I'll try and see if I can get this sewn into something useful for you in another software. ;-)
yes this is much better, the file is bigger but I can deal with that
..just a FYI.
Parasolid = Native 3D format of SolidWorks (NO TRANSLATION REQUIRED = CLEAN and FAST)
STEP is NON native (DIRTY), the export is a translation of the clean native Parasolid data and the dirty import is translation back into Parasolid.
Yep. But in Shane's case he gets this supplied to him by Ford or someone else...in those cases you take what you can get. I'm not even sure what Ford uses these days for CAD..I'm sure it's a multiple systems. I remember the old days of getting PDGS data on tape and having to work on that system. Make changes in our data in UG (at the time) and then hop over to the PDGS terminal and make the changes again!
Ryan.. well.. if it's from Ford.. then I'm pretty sure they use UG/NX? (Parasolid).... but anyway, I was responding to Kenneth about the suggestion to export STEP from SolidWorks.
I did not know that about parasolids. I guess that will help me correlate with my vendors that have SW2015 still since for some DUMB reason I cant save to previous years file format like any other program I've used. Also when I asked Ford for native format files I got yelled at. Their rep told me "we only send surface information in .STEP format", you would figure exporting everything as .step would be harder and more time consuming than using parasolid.