Tangency length for lofted surfaces

So I'm finally trying to learn surfacing for a project I havearound the corner, and it's not that hard with the exception of"tangency lengths" for start/ end conditions. Are these in units ofsomething?

I'm sure it's obvious... Can someone enlighten me?
SolidworksSurfacing
Answers 12
KQ
KQ 2009-06-03 Best Answer
Think of these as the influence the tanegncy has at the startand end. The higher the value, the greater the influence, so ahigher value will give the new surface more of a match to theexisting surface, whereas a lower one yuou will see the new surfacechange to suit the other side faster. Best way is to try it!
SF
SF 2009-06-03
There is no unit associated with them. Spline handles also donot have units. To make it confusing it appears both of theseunit-less influences use different scales. i.e. loft between 2parallel plates with tangency and make a 2D spline with the sametangency and the same end conditions. The spline will not coincidewith the loft. I hope this helps.

Rob Stupplebeen
SF
SF 2009-06-03
I just made the model to make sure.
A fully relaxed spline does match up with a loft with tangency 1. Ihowever do not like the idea of an dimensioned spline handle for mywork though. I hope this helps.

Rob Stupplebeen
SF
SF 2009-06-03
Thanks Charles, that was really helpful. My understanding (inthe simplest, probably inaccurate terms) is that it is thederivative of the polynomial function that makes up the firstsection of the spline.

Now if I could just understand how to control the number ofsections (it's greyed out) and the spacing of the sections, I mightfeel comfortable with the tool.
CC
CC 2009-06-03
You're going to have to go into more detail. What do you mean"control the number of sections" and spacing? Can you provide ascreenshot (save a .png and attach it)?
SF
SF 2009-06-03
Here is an example from the SolidWorks tutorial. (Attachingreally IS slow.)
CC
CC 2009-06-03
The "number of sections" that you see (in yellow) are notactually sections. They are just visual lines to help you see howthe surface flows. You cannot control them in the loft tool, but ifyou use the boundary surface tool you can control them with theinformation under "Display" and changing the "mes preview" data.But again, this is just a mesh preview, and they do not control theshape.

If you want to actually have more control to the surface as it goesfrom one to the other you need to create a spline for the surfaceto follow. You can use the same curvature constraints on a spline,and then add points in the middle (the fewer the better). Then youcan move the spline points, as well as control their handles, toget the desired shape you want.

The SW tutorials are great, except for surfacing. You might tryMark Biasotti's presentation at SWW2009.http://www.solidworks.com/page...ngs/presentations.html(it looks like the video isn't available yet, but you can downloadthe .ppt). You can see his presentation from 2008, which was verysimilar, here:http://solidmentor.com/modules...rticle.php?storyid=323
AW
AW 2009-06-03
Matt Lombard's book on Surfacing is also a great resource.

http://www.dezignstuff.com/blog/

See the bottom of the sidebar for the link.

Cheers,

Anna
KS
KS 2009-06-03
You can do this with surfaces or solids (SW2009), and thereare really two choices.

Loft and Boundary.
Despite them sharing no resemblance in name, they actually fulfillvery similar roles.
Boundary is like a Loft on steroids, more options and justgenerally an improved loft.

There's a good video Mark Biasotti did about boundary and othersurfacing features:
http://www.viddler.com/explore/behnt/videos/24/

It's a little tricky to get the hang of it, but that video shouldclear up a lot. I first really found out about Boundary throughthat video a few months ago so I'm kind of a newbie as well youcould say - what really helps is that I had to use it extensivelyfor a part model of a mould. That project you have around thecorner will absolutely definitely undeniably (should I go on?)help, you'll pick it up much faster than just casually fiddlingwith options in the feature(s).

Boundary (and loft as well) just give tremendous previewing, othersoftware you just pick your curves and only at the very end itwould show a preview - they're not all like that but most are.SolidWorks gives you a great idea how your boundary is evolving asyou add additional curves and guides.

Hope this helps!
SF
SF 2009-06-03
Thanks Anna, I would Love to read Matt's book soon. I amwatching the pennies until the new machine (and the work) comes in.The irony is that by then I won't have the time to read it

Thanks all, I think that really answers the question. I'm superimpressed with the knowledge on this board!
NL
NL 2009-06-04
hey I think I spotted a forum babe
I am too shy to award points though...

and I see Ozzy Osborne in the same thread...cool stuffman...definitely gonna keep reading here

participation is really going to surge with talent like this

makes you want to do something impulsive like fill out several usersurveys or somethin'...