Hello,
I updated my installation to SW2009 SP5 yesterday, and it didn't take me long to find something that appears broken.
I constantly use the "Edit Referenced File Locations" dialog in the Open box. This allows me to copy an existing drawing which is similar to what I want, and just swap out the model it references. Easy.
When I open the dialog, normally all you have to do is double click on the old referenced assembly and/or part, and it brings up a browse window to pick the replacement. Now, nothing happens at all. When you double click on it, it just turns to a blue background.
I can use SW Explorer for this, but why? This is a much used function for me and most of my co-workers.
Has anywone else encountered this? Maybe something is broken in my install? Nothing out of the ordinary happened when I did it.
SolidworksGeneral
I just tried to manually enter the name of the replacement file I want. It does allow you to double click on the path in the right side.
This works, but it was much easier to just browse and click.
come on Kelvin whose side are you on
now they have no reason to provide a hot fix..or a 5.1
they can just say upgrade to 2010...
I'm on my side, ... and in this case Davids.
If the ref' problem doesn't get fixed with a '09-5.1, then at least by downloading 2010 SP0 now (and 1 if possible), David has an alternative to '09-4.1. If he leaves it till their subs' expires, he won't be able to download anything.
This is really annoying, but not a true show-stopper for me. I do use this alot, but my current (reluctant) workaround is to use SW Explorer.
We usually wait till at least SP2 of a new release to make the jump, so 2010 is a bit away for us.
I'm the only one on 5.0 for now (in house testing). If I unleashed this on my co-workers, I'd hear it for sure.
I just wanted to make sure it wasn't something I goofed up on my end.
Thanks for verifying guys.
Yes. The exact same error is in SW2010 SP1 (no pre-release, actual SP1 which was released last week).
At a minimum, we will have to wait a weeks before SP1.1.
This is frustrating and very annoying.
After the same problem was in SW2009 SP5, it was allowed to happen again in SW2010 SP1.
Hi Andy and others,
This behavior was changed to try to re-instate the ability to manually type a filename (which was present in an earlier version). However, in doing so, the ability to browse for a file was made more difficult. That behavior is still there if you hold the ctrl key and double click in the filename field (so, same behavior as before, but just hold the ctrl key when you double click).
Under SPR 528194 we are investigating making this easier for both browsing and manually typing the name.
We are sorry for the inconvenience,
Jim
Jim,
Thanks for the reply and clarification.
Dave H
So Jim,
We just need to use the Ctrl key with the double click to get the old behaviour..
I dont want to give SW people a hard time but really...aside from the strangeness of introducing a seemingly unnecessary change and in sp5, what are Release Notes for?
Worse, it takes SW two weeks to find out about this mod..what does that say about change control, internal documentation and communication?
Its no wonder the Help is behind the times..
Santa is looking very seriously at his diary at this time of year to see who have been the good little boys and girls..
Thanks very much for that Andrew. That SPR didn't have that information, about the CTRL key, yesterday!!!
I agree that this should have been added to the release notes
( http://files.solidworks.com/Supportfiles/Release_Notes/2010/English/relnotes.htm#Service_Pack_1_0 )
Jim,
Thanks for the update.
But I have to agree with Neil on the change. It's not very logical, especially since we've been used to just double clicking on it for how long now?
A pop-up balloon would have worked nice there if you tried to double click on it saying to "Hit Ctrl while Double-Clicking to browse". All we get is a blue field with a file name in it, doing nothing. It screams loudly of being a bug.
Instead, I've spent quite a bit of time working around this.
I'm glad you're reconsidering.
Jim,
Please rethink this strategy. Surely the introduction of the double-click-to-browse function was to eliminate the error-prone manual editing. Why re-introduce that?
Please ... Just fix the functions which need fixing ... leave the functions which work well, alone.
Just out of curiosity, what percentage of users manually type the file name in compared to browsing for the file. I don't believe I have ever typed a file name in when replacing a model or if I have it has only been once or twice in 10 years of using SW. This is just another one of those "enhancements" that someone didn't think all the way thru and then didnt even bother telling the users that this was a designed change and not a bug.
It costs me a few ours of work because of this BUG.
Luckily there is a solution, but you first have to search for it.
https://customerportal.solidworks.com/eservice_enu/start.swe?SWECmd=GotoView&SWEView=SW+KBase+Solution+View+%28eService%29&SWERF=1&SWEBU=1&SWEApplet0=SW+KBase+Solution+Form+Applet+%28eService%29&SWERowId0=1-O17HK7
This is the hotfix! (I haven't tried it yet..)
Hotfix applied. It doesn't work exactly as before, but it gets the job done.
If you doubleclick on the file name, it just turns blue, like it has since SP5/SP1(2010). If you doubleclick again it brings up the browse dialog.
The quickest way I found to bring up the proper dialog NOW is to double click on the icon instead of the file name.
Hope this helps.
After downloading and installing you are presented with this message.
EDIT: It doesn't appear to work for SW2010-SP1
I notice that too, but I figured this is most likely the LAST SP for 2009, I didn't need to worry.
I guess folks on 2010 do though.
Hi All,
This change in behavior (double clicking on the text not browsing without first selecting the cell/text) is due to enabling the manual edit ability. So, with the hot fix (which will also be part of normal SolidWorks 2010 SP02) both browsing and manually typing are available AND not only for the file, but also for the folder. For manual editing, you single click on the text you want to edit. For browsing you single click on it first and then double click. You can also just triple click without selecting first. In the case of the filename, you can double click on the document icon to browser as Andy points out.
We are sorry this wasn't implemented this way from the start. There are valid cases where manual editing is more efficient and it was available in a previous release, hence why a fix was put in. Obviously when it was fixed in SolidWorks 2009 SP05 and SolidWorks 2010 SP01, it should have been fixed as it is now (to enable both methods easily) and the change in behavior should have been documented. We are pursuing why this slipped through our review process to avoid such cases in the future.
Thanks,
Jim
Jim,
Thanks for being upfront and honest about what happened. It works fine now that we know what to expect.
As you said, springing these kinds of changes without letting us know can cause all kinds of trouble.
This was an area of the software that I believe worked perfecly prior to this change, and we all were scratching our heads wondering why it was even changed at all.
nevermind "A hot fix for SolidWorks 2009 SP5 is now available..." answers my question.. but brings up another... will there be a hot fix for those using 2010 made available as well?
Unbelievable! It's the same in SW2010-SP1. The hotfix has messed with the function even more.
Now we have to double-double-click triple-click the text field, or just double-click the icon ...which is a much smaller target.
... and the hotfix has to be uninstalled before updating to the next SP.
How many people requested the File > Open > References function be changed?
What was wrong with the original function?
Kelvin, I agree 100%.
If I had a say, I'd recommend that they simply revert back to the same behavior it was prior to 09SP5/10SP1 and be done with it.
If it ain't broke don't fix it!
oooooh! triple click!!!
just when you thought the UI enhancements had dried up a whole unexplored avenue for SW development comes along...and after that quad click!...
wow! they've been really humming in the useability section this year.
ok jokes aside why the hell couldnt we just go back to how it was before??? insane!
thank goodness the year is almost over and tired brains can have a holiday...
Jim,
based on what you and other SW employees have stated many times before, you are trying to make everything more "CONSISTENT"... I don't see this being consistent with how the Pack and Go window functions. In there I can double click to edit, but now in a similar window I have to tripple click (which I disagree with the change in the first place as I'm sure the majority of us do based on the overwhelming negative response)
Before you change the Pack and Go to use this NEW way to be consistent... please just figure out a different way to give those users who wish to type their keyboard off a way to do what they wish and let the rest of us keep our cheese where it was.
Thank you.
NOTICE: Xmas has been cancelled for Concord Ma.
All SW employees will report in combat fatigues at 0500hrs for a refresher course in reality.
Soggy brained chair warmers will need to shape up to have continued employment in the New Year.
love
Santa
ho ho ho...
Is this also why you removed the ability to manually type the file name when replacing a model while in an assembly. In previous versions if you RMB on a part or subassembly in the feature tree and picked REPLACE it would allow you to type a name there but now you can only browse. Sometimes I wonder what the reasoning behind some of these changes are but when I do that all I see is stuff spinning out of control with no end in sight.
The way that the REPLACE interface has changed is more confusing now than what it was before. Why is there a need to show the files that are open in the files to select box when you do a PART REPLACE. Yes it makes it more "consistant" with the assembly insert part but most of the time I don't want to replace a part with one I already have open.