Hello,
This is my first time posting a question. I'm not sure if I am in the right place. Please advise if I need to ask it somewhere else.
I am trying to model a pillow. The geometry I have modeled is from an actual pillow, so I know the shape exists but I can't seem to recreate the surface. I don't know if I need more guide curves or a different approach. The pillow is of course completely smooth. Any suggestions for a better way to do this? Is Solidworks capable or do I need Rhino or something. Thank you.

You are in the correct place. Right of your title (right of "Answered") is a dropdown menu. On it, select Edit and drop in your part file for a direct examination.
I'm not seeing any relations, plus we need to know your workflow and the each surface's end conditions.
One suggestion: As the first surface, create and extruded surface from the left end spline, running leftward.
You can then use this surface for Tangent end condition for the adjacent edges. Afterward, you hide this surface and be sure not to stitch it to anything.
Also, is this a Makers part file?
you need either more guide curves or more profiles for your loft from the center of the pillow to the end that you can loft through to smooth out the hard transition your are getting from the diagonal constraint.
How about a single guide curve? Part made in SW2025.
The corner radii cause a disjoint in the curvature (and zebra) and this worsens with smaller values (.0625 shown, not your .25).
I also made the both ends of the quide curve tangent, but not with much improvement.
I tried a 3 loft approach (line to common point and 2 guides each), but it's still sharp.
Another approach would be to break each "triangle" section such that it's four-sided (the 4th side can be short and at the common point end). This would permit using a boundary surface which has greater edge control and 4 sides would eliminate the degenerate common point.
here you have very good tutorial on YT how you can achieve this shape
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbOVZciHHuw&t=183s