I am trying to fill the gap between these two parts. To the left is a blade and the right a hub. I have tried a variety of methods such as an extruded surface which I converted to a solid and then attempted to combine with the two other parts. This failed with the "zero thickness geometry error". Anything helps, thank you.

I am not very fluent in surface modelling, and I hate the 'Zero Thickness' error. (There is literally no need for it and anyone can easily demonstrate very clearly that SW is quite capable of creating zero thickness in multi-bodies and assemblies.) All that said, do I see you have done 'insert part into part'.? .. This is rarely the best workflow. (I only ever use it as a means of building brackets and frames around a fixed or non edittable purchased components.) Perhaps I'm not seeing the complexity, but you may find better results modelling the hub directly within the actual blade part. It would be a simple matter of creating a circular pattern of blades and then assuming the hub to be a simple solid revolve or extrude, which you should be able to merge with the blades.
I dont have this model but my advice is try some commands in "Direct editting" tab, this may solve ur situation
hard to see what the shape is exactly or how you want them blended. Give a try to Delete face with Patch option checked. You will need to select the faces inside this wedge shape and if it can it will extend the other faces up to each other. This is part of the direct edit tool group.