STL Graphic Manipulation

I've imported an .stl file and it shows up simply as an "STL Graphic" in my design tree.  I would like to make some simple cuts in the part, but SW behaves as if there is no geometry there (e.g. I try and make a cut but the option to cut is unavailable).  Is there a way to make this file a solid so that I can manipulate its geoemtry?  I'm only doing very simple manipulations...a few cuts and maybe some protrusions.

SolidworksParts And Features
Answers 5
CC
CC 2010-04-27 Best Answer

Sorry,

Chances are you are out of luck. Depending on how complex the part is, the only way to import is to use ScanTo3D. If you have SolidWorks Premium, it is included. Read the SW help files on Scanto3D for help on that.

If you don't have SolidWorks Premium, you can still try to have the regular .stl importer import it. It is limited on the number of faces it can import, so only very simple parts can be easily imported. Go to File>Open... then select .stl as the file type. This will bring up an "Options..." button in the lower right. Click on that. Set the options for .stl so it imports as a model, not as a graphics body. Then try again.

The reason why you can't just import it easily is that .stl is a mesh based modeler, not a NURBS based modeler. Meshes are points in space that get filled in by approximation. NURBS are parametric curves in space that are filled mathematically. Math = good when dealing with manufactureable parts, approximation = bad. So you are dealing with two totally different types of data. You can easily export .stl because it is easy to calculate a point cloud based on the math, but it is not possible to build math around a point cloud. ScanTo3D is a tool that helps you take in that point cloud, and uses it as a reference to create the parametric curves around it.

SF
SF 2010-04-27

Agh, it has too many faces to import as a solid.  Thanks for the help, anyway.  Is there another CAD program you think could do this?  Proe, maybe?

AW
AW 2010-04-28

Look at Rhino... May do what you need.  You can get a free trial to check it out.

You will need to recreate base part geometry from the mesh.  But at least the mesh is selectable.

http://www.rhino3d.com/

There are other options that are very high  end.  Ten's of thousands of dollars. Such as http://www.rapidform.com/

Cheers,

Anna

SF
SF 2010-04-28

Materialize's Magics software is a good tool for STL file manipulation including hollowing and cuts, but it does cost money:

http://www.materialise.com/Magics

You may also want to try Netfabb, which has a free version that can section STL files:

http://www.netfabb.com/

Worse comes to worse, you may just have to remodel that STL file.

SF
SF 2010-04-28

Aaron,

I concur with Anna in that Rhino is an official partner of ours and has the ability to handle polygonal data. It also has an add-in to it called T-Splines which will allow you to convert the mesh to NURBS surface and then import into SW. This would be with limited success because this kind of conversion works best with "quads" and not triangles but in any case, depending on you STL could work.

Regards


Mark