This has to be in the forum somewhere but I wasn't seeing exactly what I'm looking for. I need to make an extruded cut through this barrel such as that shown. I know what the distances from the top and front planes need to be to get the opening required. What I don't know is how to create the sketch so that when the cuts are projected on the surface they are where they should be.
This the cooking chamber for a smoker, eventually the part cut out will be replaced with material to serve as the door. Maybe this could be done all in one step by cut-extrude only an 1/8" all around and then creating a new part from the "door" that is left?

If it was me and for a personal (?) project like this I would do some slices longitudinally, generous radius in the corners and use a swept cut on a projected profile to create the cutout. Again assuming it's a personal project I would use some tabs to retain the cut part within the sheet while rolling. This would likely prevent kinks and assure you the door would match the surface. If you used a 1/16" wide cut a hacksaw blade that would help get he 'slug' out.
there are many ways to skin this cat!!
Providing you have drawn this in sheet metal, you can >unfold the part >cut you hole >unflatten your part
this will be your most ideal way to achieve what you require as it will not hinder your cut file.
you can do a revolve cut about the centre axis which will also allow you to export cut files without having to edit them
If youd like further assistance I could skype you or team view
hth
b
It is a personal project, both for end use and getting more experience in Solidworks best practices. When it's time to create the laser program my intent is exactly as you outline. Without doing manual calculations, which may end up being the best method, I don't know how to precisely locate those longitudinal cuts you mention. While this is a personal project and the precision doesn't need to be very high, knowing how to do this accurately when it is required is part of the goal.
In this case, the bottom of the opening needs to be 1" below the horizontal plane and 1/2" from the vertical plane. Some rather simple circle trig would give a good result that could then be done on the flat pattern (it is a sheetmetal part). On the other hand, I was scolded once before for suggesting the use of manual calculations in Solidworks! : )
I am not saying you should do manula calc within your sketches.
If you cut from a plane to achieve the desired cut , it should flatten unless you are cutting in to an elipse
you could always create a plane where you require then ,sketch in your cut profile and extrude verticly (constrained by distance) ?
Rob,
I'll give you a hint though I'm sure you've already considered this, don't think about a face or surface cut so much as looking at it from the end view. Sketch your cut on the center or mid-plane and bi-directionally cut extrude. Then add your corner radius.
Personally I stopped doing trig and many other manual calculations back in my AutoCAD days. I was able to make drawings and in precision sheet metal I used 1:1 drawings as a quick end view check by laying the part right on the drawings. How many times in the past have you done manual calculations and needed a drawing reflecting those anyway?
I applaud you for wanting to do it right. I have heard so many excuses over the years, "it's not important". I always ask, what will you do when it has to be right and you have no extras or spare material. Every bend is a practice bend to learn from.
I just made a plane. Made a sketch and wrapped it around the radius. Made a 1/16 gap. You can cut a 1/16 gap with a torch using a 000 cutting tip. I down loaded a picture of my pit I am designing. Not complete yet.
Let me know when it's done I got an awesome rib recipe lol
The one thing I noticed was your main smoke stack is centered in the unit, I would offset it from the center so you can add a rotisserie, otherwise SWEET
Pit radius is made from 12" pipe split into 3 pieces length wise. One piece on each side of the pit and one piece on the bottom of the firebox. A V shape fire box makes the wood fall to the middle. Can't fall to one side like a square box. Draft has a spring with a shoulder bolt. I make my hinges one long bar for perfect alignment.
I see one hinge blade lost a mate
Will you be putting a draft control on the lid or will you control at the smoke stack?
The plate on top of the stack screws up and down. I built a pit like this once but I gave it to my son. I might set this pit in a flagstone cradle to match my patio flagstone.
Bernie,
I did think of doing it as you mention, after trying to wrap it. Used a plane going through the length of the barrel and then re-created the door as a new component with an extruded offset from surface to get my 1/8" clearance. The laser program will tab the door and then be formed as one.
In my short career in CAD drafting one concept has remained firm in my mind; the model drives the job, if the model is garbage - you get garbage...