hello,
i was wondering what kind of standard views you guys put on your sheet metal part drawings. i have attached two sheet metal drawings with our 'standard' views. what i have done is added a top view off to the side of my template, then i added section views to get the 'formed' views to show up like they do. the reason we do not use a normal side or top view is because if we have a return flange it could be covered by another flange. i was just wondering what everybody ells does.
SolidworksDrawings And Detailing
Kevin -
I love this topic. I think drawing standards are so important that everybody should have one. We probably won't ever settle on the same standard, though.
I've attached a PDF of your original and my version of the same drawing so others who haven't jumped into SW2010 might join in.
Your method does a nice job of making it easier to spot where the corner radii are. In my drawing, they are there, but the resolution of the hardcopy needs to be fine enough not to blur them out.
My hot buttons:
1) Isometric views must show tangent edges but not hidden lines.
2) Projected views must show hidden lines but not tangent edges (that keeps the press brake operators happy).
3) Add as many projected views and section views as needed, but maintain proper 3rd angle projection (yes this is USA centric, but that's where my parts get manufactured).
4) Flat layouts appear on their own sheet (they are mostly for use by the estimators with only a passing glance by other processes in the shop).
5) All parts must be marked showing the part number & rev and the drawing has to show where.
6) A revision should appear for both the drawing and the part (yes this is a pain in PDM but it is worth the pain)
7) Dimension the part so it is easy to inspect with calipers at the press brake (using edge-to-bend or bend-to-bend dimensions; dimension the other details with ordinate dimensions for QA to check with a CMM during setup (specifically for Turrets or Lasers).
8) Always dimension the material thickness (yes, this is redundant with the notes but helps goof proof the model/drawing revisions.
Probably the most important point is to make drawings that please your manufacturing shop. I use several subcontractors and this drawing scheme satisfies most (but not all).
As a former press brake operator, I think I'd prefer my drafting style. Section views require an extra neuron to process and I don't have any to spare when working on a time clock.
i have really wanted to go to a two page system with the flat pattern on page 2 since our laser & turret punch people are the only ones who pay any attention to it, but we still keep hard copies of all of our drawings here and that would be too much paper to store and keep track of. i really do like that concept though.
The problem we had was one of our section views (in the top view thats off the page) was in the an area where the return flange was notched out so the return flange wasnt in the section view and never got dimensioned. that drawing made it past the person that checked it (me!) and was released for production. one of our press break guys came to me and said "i think your missing a flange, why did SolidWorks miss a flange?"
Wow, SW didn't add the flange to the flat pattern?.... or maybe I didn't read the post right. If that's the case, maybe the flange was created using an extrude instead of the edge flange command....... or am I just grasping here.
I try to put the flat on the same page with my part unless it won't fit then I'll use a sheet 2. In any case I'm usually the one making the cut file for the CNC, so the flat is on a separate cut sheet anyway (non controlled dwg). In aerospace it's in no way a necessity for me to have a flat layout on the dwg for the DER's approval to submit to the FAA, but I want to make sure the guy on the floor building my parts makes them right the 1st time.
Gerald, a question about "6) A revision should appear for both the drawing and the part (yes this is a pain in PDM but it is worth the pain)" Are using a "Non-Revision Unified" approach to the models and their drawings? Meaning the final formed part could be a different revision that it's drawing. I'm just curious because every so often people want to go this direction.
Steve
Steve -
In my world all kinds of things happen, including decisions like allowing the part rev to hold still while drawing revs get bumpt to fix little things like missing dimensions and spelling errors (sometimes just due to ownership during check-in). The official policy is to synchronize the part and drawing revs for the "production drawings".
"My world" includes working solo on some projects and working collaboratively on others. It gets interesting when one crew is working on mechanical drafting and another is doing the modeling. Anything we can do to goof proof is a blessing.
The main advantage of the clutter of dual revisions is that it makes it easy to spot the dog (i.e. the component and the drawing need close scrutiny prior to synchronizing the revs).
The great disadvantage is that the subcontractors tend to mark the parts with GLD-001_REV_A-01-A-01 instead of GLD-001_REV_A.
wow that is excellent advise. these are the questions in wrestling with rn. thanks a ton