Save prompt when switching between configurations?

Hello everyone, first post here so be gentle!  Been using SW for a while now and have run into this problem before, but have always been able to get around it.

In the previous versions I have used (2006 & 2009) I could load up my files with multiple configurations and just cycle through them and save.  Then I could reload the parts and cycle through all configurations without a save prompt being thrown.

In 2012 no matter how I try I cannot get my files to not prompt for a save when switching configurations!  I load my models and cycle through each configuration, ctrl+q on each one, and save at the end.  Next time I load, they load without a save prompt but then once I switch to any other configuration it throws the save prompt!  To make things interesting, when I change the configurations of the exact same parts in an assembly it doesn't flag those parts for a save!  I must be missing something simple, like some sort of automatic rebuild only on the part level that is causing this headache for me.  Can anyone shed some light on this?

I have checked and 'verification on rebuild' is off just in case that was the issue, not sure where else to go from here...

Thanks for any help that can be given...

Brian

SolidworksConfigurations design Tables
Answers 9
DG
DG 2011-12-13 Best Answer

Welcome to SolidWorks forums Brian.

Not sure if this will work but go to Tools > Options > External References and set Update out-of-date linked design tables to Model.

BTW does it happens with all files? Can you share one example? What is your SP and OS?

You might also find this post helpful for your future reference


BS
BS 2011-12-13

Thanks for the welcome Deepak, I tried out the option you suggested but unfortunately it does not resolve the issue.  I also took a look at your helpful post for newbs, thanks for that.  Tried to search around for my answer first but no luck!  I think I have all the info you need below.

This does happen with all files, files that have multiple design configurations as well as sheet metal files with only a derived flat pattern configuration.  It seems no file is safe.

I am attaching a file in a native SW2012 format that is a clear example of this for me.  Let me know if it is the same for you!  If you load the file attached it loads without a save prompt asterisk but as soon as you switch to an alternate configuration it throws the save asterisk.

I am using SW 2012, sp1.0 on a Windows 7 Pro OS workstation.

Thanks,

Brian

BS
BS 2011-12-13

I just talked with our local VAR and was informed that this is actually normal behavior for SW?  It does not strike me as normal since versions 2006 & 2009 did not have this 'issue.'  In both of those I could load a file with multiple configurations and cycle through them all day and so long as I did not force regen or edit a feature it would not ask me to save when closing.  I will accept it if it is deemed 'normal' but would still love for others to comment on it if they can.

Thanks!

DG
DG 2011-12-14

I don't see anything like that on SW 2012, sp1.0 on a Windows 7 Pro here so must be some setting.

BS
BS 2011-12-14

Deepak, thanks for the info and the video showing the process is great.

I noticed when I was talking with the VAR that I may have misspoke or mis-represented the problem.  When I say there is a 'save prompt' I do not actually mean that there is a message box that pops up, but rather that the 'save asterisk' appears next to the file name up top.  In your video I cannot see the top of your screen so I cannot tell if you are getting that asterisk or not!

Even though there is no physical change to the part (no features or dimensions are changing), when the configurations are cycled as you did in the video the software sees the part as 'changed' and therfore needing to be saved.  This was not the case in both 2006 & 2009 and I am thinking it still should not be the case in 2012.

Is that what you were checking or were you showing that there was no 'save prompt' popping up?

Sorry for the confusion and thanks for all of the help so far!

Brian

DG
DG 2011-12-14

Yes I thought you are saying 'save prompt' popping up' and that's what I was checking. Yes I too see the asterisk when I switch configurations.

BS
BS 2011-12-14

Thanks again for the help.  I think what is happening is that somewhere between SW2009 and SW2012 this functionality became 'normal' and I am maybe just not used to it?  Because of that, it comes across as 'wrong' to me so I just wanted to see if anyone had any insight as to why this was happening.

Maybe it is just that way?

If you create a part with multiple configurations and switch in between them does it put the asterisk on it for you too?

DG
DG 2012-01-06
JS
JS 2012-01-06

Good morning Brian,

Or this one; https://forum.solidworks.com/message/267751#267751

There is a macro listed that you could down load,

Later,

John