First, english isn't my first language, so sorry in advance for grammar and spelling.
We've just updatet our solidworks, from 2014 to 2020. This update was necessary, since we needed to shift from windows 7 to windows 10, in which solidworks 2014 isn't supportet. The reason for not being on the latest version of solidworks, the past few years, is that solidworks 2014 has worked perfectly for us, and for the type of work we do.
in approx. 80% of our designs, we use routing as the main design parameter and solidworks hasn't had any updates in routing, since i don't know when. Hence no reason for us to update untill now.
Now, in 2014 i created a routing library and several templates for the different materials. we use. F.ex. ABS, PVC, PE, PP, Steel etc. Which means if we start a route using the ABS template, the pipes and bends (90% and 45%) is pointing to the ABS elbows and pipes. The same goes for all the other materials. This has worked perfectly up untill now.
Now we receive an error when starting a new route. See attached screenshots. The error means nothing hence we can still do the route, after clicking "ok". But then when trying to fix the problem in the library manager, i get a new error message referring to the "Size" column. See attached screenshot.
How do we fix this problem? RX already sent to SolidWorks, but i'm currious to see if others has the same issue.
Best Regards,
SolidworksRouting
Hi,
i think, it's - as always - a localisation issue with the decimals. When i have a look at my routinglib.db there are a lot of size entries with values of 37000 instead of 0.375. So I've got the same error messages you've posted. It's always the same mix between dot and comma ...
When i copy the default routing.db to my individual routing folder and open it up in the Routing Library Manager - everything looks fine.
When i try to Import/Synch my routing database, SWX looks up. But it's worth a try to get this running again.
hahaha... Yeah, i know...
WELCOME to Piping and Tubing database.
but which property? I mean, which parameter? The "diameter" property on this part has neither , nor . so it makes no sence at all.
Correct, but i have elbows further down in the list with "0" value as well. Just me who was a little to busy to make a correct screenshot.
The size should be the diameter.
Seeing however that you can only assign elbows in the Route Template it means that it's of no consequence for T's, reducer, etc.
Yep, no wonder it isn't used much.
1. Hardly anyone knows about it. Users or VAR's
2. It barely works
3. They don't teach it or even mention it
4. I know for a fact that there's only been some work done on it the last 2 years
By the way i had a fun talk with the local VAR support today. He told me he never met anyone who used templates (we have 11 different templates with different materials/standards). :O
That tell me how little he knows about routing. It's essential that you can choose which materials you wanna use with a simple click, rather than browsing for the different files everytime you start a new route. And they don't even teach it, in the training course.
Hi Peter,
Yes i have excactly those numbers.
I even have some with no value... "0"
And i can't figure out which property, the "Size" value is in the parts??
Lars,
In other words, you can change the size of a pipe (route segment properties) without an issue but you can't change the type of pipe. Which tells you that it actually only looks at the library database when you want to start something new or alter the type of pipe. The 'existing template' doesn't get re-read and there for it works but a new one (PP stuk) is not known without the assembly and therefor it wants to pull the data from the database BUT because the database has an issue it gives you errors.
Just out of curiosity sake, please open up Routing Library Manager
go to the tab 'Piping and Tubing Database'
and scroll down the list and especially keep an eye on the column size.
I bet you'll see something like below
or else something like this
The fun thing is that editing a route, made in SW 2014 (Files updated to SW 2020) works well.
Even choosing "Route Segment Properties" is working without any errors.
Though changing the template, will resolve in the same error messages as in my OP.
Getting more and more confused....!
Hi Peter,
I will read you link for sure. I don't know if i have just been lucky the past 7 years with solidworks 2014 If it weren't for the mandatory update to windows 10 at my company, we would not have upgradet at all. There's nothing new for us in routing as far as we can tell. Sure there's improvements in other places of solidworks, but nothing that can justify the huge price we had to pay, to upgrade 2 licenses.
I'm just glad as you, that i'm not the only one facing problems. But then again, i have worked at the local solidworks VAR from 2006-2013 as a supporter, so i know how little attention, routing (piping) gets. In fact, this community seems to know more about routing, than our local VAR, who told me to record and RX that he could send directly to SolidWorks.
Hi Heiko,
Yes i've tried the same with the default, and it works well untill i press the import button. Then i get attached screenshot, which would indicate, i think, that there's no new parts to import.
If i press "select components" the library manager simply crashes.
I agree with Heiko that it's most likely due to the decimal localisation issue (comma or point to signify decimals) that has been a problem as long as I have been trying to get it to work.
I have been using routing since 2009 and have been changing to the new release ever since. I have posts on this forum that date back 8 years documented my struggle with 'Route Properties Template'. It took years before someone actually started listening at Solidworks, another couple of years before they figured out what the issue was and now after a decade it's still not fixed.
I got a work around of sorts to make it work and which by the way also shows that 'Piping and Tubing Database' feature is poorly thought out and even worse implemented.
(if you have half an hour to spare see : )
For the longest time I got to hear that no one else had the issue that I was facing. I did get to hear several times that it was going to be fixed in the next SP, the next yearly release or soon....
Perhaps now that there's more people experiencing the problem it will finally get fixed.
Congratulations by the way that you had it working for a few years.
For your information, there have been tweaks and improvements on Routing the last 6 years but alas almost all of them were for the electrical side of Routing and hardly anything for piping/tubing.