Really??? No More Linked Values in 2012?

As per the usual, SolidWorks goes and reinvents the wheel and makes my job take longer to do in 2012...  Why do they see the need to reinvent the wheel in some area?  I swear, each release seems to improve some critical areas somewhat, ramp up the graphic bells and whistles, and slow me down drastically in one key area I always use.

For the past 6 years I've been using linked values for specific dimensions that are the same in various sketches where I can't just pick the geometry in a sketch and relate it as being equal to a piece of geo in another sketch.  This was an extremely handy tool where when the dialog box comes up to modify the value of a dimension, you could right click in the value and select "link dimension" to set the number to be linked to values of other dimensions in other sketches.  Change that dimension in one sketch, and it automatically changes it in all the others, saving tons of time.

Per SW Help:

<p>You can no longer create linked values (also referred to as shared values or linked dimensions) in SolidWorks 2012 and later. Instead, you use global variables for the same purpose. </p><p>In previous versions of SolidWorks, linked or shared values were used to link two or more dimensions without using equations or relations. Changing any one of the linked values would change the other to which it was linked. Existing linked values are still supported, but you cannot create new linked values in SolidWorks 2012 and later. Instead, you use global variables for the same purpose as linked values. Global variables are much easier to find, change, and manage than linked values. </p>

So now Linked Valued has been replaced with Global Variables to do the same thing, but it seems so far to take much longer.  The other part that sucks is a dimension with a Global Variable attached to it uses the same Equation icon as if it were an actual equation instead of a Global Variable.  This makes it tougher to decipher whther a dimension uses a math equation or if it's a Global Variable.  When you're rooting through your sketches and need to unlink a dimension momentarily while you transform a shape, it makes it much easier when you could separate a linked value from a math driven equation, now they use the same symbol, freakin great...

I dunno, maybe I'm just not used to it yet, just seems it was much simpler before.

[/rant]

SolidworksSketching
Answers 26
SF
SF 2011-10-26 Best Answer

Wow, this is going to create some problems for me I have alot of my dimensions linked my Design Tree. We are upgrading in 3 weeks there will be a lot of problems on my end :S.

FR
FR 2011-10-26

Hi Danny,

there have been a lot of discussions going on about removing linked dimensions.  Based on the thread: https://forum.solidworks.com/message/248891#248891 we have made the decission to bring back linked dimensions with SolidWorks 2012 SP1.  Even with the removed UI (as you see it in SP0) the linked dimensions are still working and legacy components won't be affected.

Perhaps you want to read through the above mentioned thread as it will give you a lot of answers why we initially made the decision and how the new functionality works.  Please feel free to ask any question just in case that you don't find the answers to your questions.

Regards

Frank

Product Definition Team

DS
DS 2011-10-26

Does that mean that we will have both linked dimensions and global variables?

I just clicked on the link and it says im forbidden from viewing...

AW
AW 2011-10-26

Frank,

The thread you linked to should be moved out of the Beta sub-forum, so everyone has access to it.  Maybe Greg Jankowski or Richard Doyle can help with that.

Cheers,

Anna

SF
SF 2011-10-27

I was on Inventor for a few years and now NX for the last two years. With either program, when you create a dim, there is always a "D" (Inventor D005 ect) or "P" (NX P05 ect) number next to your dim. As you continue to model, you put in the "D" or "P" number instead of a dim and you are done. That is very quick.

I do like the linked values and equations but it would be nice to add a third option of using "D" or "P" numbers.

FR
FR 2011-10-27

Hi David,

yes we will have both functionalities side by side.

Thanks

Frank

Product Definition Team

FR
FR 2011-10-27

Hi All,

we have moved the Beta thread to a public location.  So you should be able to follow the link:

https://forum.solidworks.com/message/248891#248891

If you are still experiencing problems with the link, please let me know.

Thanks

Frank

Product Defintion Team

AS
AS 2011-10-27

Excellent, i have to say i really like global variables, but it is pretty obvious people need linked values that can be driven per configuration, i can't beleive that is a limitation of global variables currently, especially given that we teach this exact procedure using linked values in the Essentials Course (lesson 10 - socket) it's mostly likely pretty widely used. If Global variables had all the functionality of Linked Dimensions it would be a great step forward, for now we are going to have to include some caveats in what we recommend

SF
SF 2011-10-27

hey frank i looked at the post you made in the other forum where you showed the linking pics from 12. got a question. on the options on the drop down box one said file properties, is that only for individual parts or can that be used to link deminsions to the weld list properties?

FR
FR 2011-10-27

Hi Brandon,

no, these are the properties you will get from Tools -> Mass Properties.

Regards

Frank

Product Definition Team

comment imagecomment image
SF
SF 2011-10-27

is there any way to link the cut list to a extracted part and vice versa? i only ask cause i deal with 4 and 5 hundred part weldment cutlists and have to key alot of information multible times. ive found a formula that works that will link the deminsions from a part back to the cutlist that i extracted it from, but soon as i close the part the link severs. here is a link to my thread ive wrote down a couple sample formulas that ive been working with

https://forum.solidworks.com/thread/49088?tstart=0

SF
SF 2011-10-27

for example i want my description to be listed as pl (plate) thickness x width, is there anyway to get that in the cutlist properties and link it thru to extracting it into a new part

SF
SF 2011-10-28

Awesome dude, thanks for the info.  Glad to see it's coming back.

While I do see Global Variables can perform sorta the same way, it seems much more cumbersome to try to set up a new global variable vs. just right clicking in the edit dimension dialog box and selecting link dimension, where you could create a new link, attach a dimension to an existing link, or unlink a dimension right there. 

If the various functionalities of global variables and linked dimensions were combined and ALL functionalities of both were still completely available with a new, single, "hybrid" way of performing either task, I think it would be a winner.  But I think losing some functionality of one or the other obviously causes problems as many people out there use these two things in many different ways to get their jobs done and come to depend heavily on them to save time and make sure their shape driving sketches stay tightly knit and perform flawlessly based on the way their parts may need to adjust.

I do however, LOVE what you guys did to create an equation, just hit the = and start punching in your equation.  Makes it easier to delete them too by just highlighting the existing equation and hitting backspace instead of going into a different box, having to find the equation, then delete it.  Don't take that away!!! 

SF
SF 2011-10-28

You can do this in a roundabout kind of way actually in SW.  Each dimension has a dimension number, for instance, "D21@Sketch1".  If you want a certain dimension in another sketch to always equal the value for that dimension, in the edit dimension dialog box, type ="D21@sketch1".  The drawbacks here are having to remember the number for each dimension every time you need to create and this equation, and it's value can only be modified at that original dimension that drives all the others that equal it, unlike linked values where you could pick any one of the dimensions that use the same linked value in any sketch, modify it there and it will update all the others.

FR
FR 2011-10-28

Hi All,

with the improvements we have made with 2012 equations, you actually don't have to remember the dimension name.  While you edit a dimension, you can type in an equal sign, double click on a different feature (depending on your Instant3D settings) and pick the dimension displayed on the screen.

By the way you can also rename the dimension name from the edit definition dialog.

Regards

Frank

Product Definition Team

comment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment image
FR
FR 2011-10-28

Hi Danny,

give the linking to a global variable a try.  It is bidirectional like linked dimensions and personally I don't perceive the new workflow to be "awkward".  There is a lot of power behind the new stuff...

Regards

Frank

Product Definition Team

KL
KL 2011-10-29

... and you could also rename the dimension to something logical.

SF
SF 2011-10-31

Yeah I do that when the equation I'm building is in the same sketch as the one that equation uses to derive it's answer, just click on the dimension and it gets thrown into the equation at the point where you select it.  However, there are cases where dimensions from another sketch are used to create an equation in a new sketch, hence where you have to either remember that dimension's name / use copy and paste.

SF
SF 2011-10-31

Cool man, I'll stick with it, (not like I have a choice anyway. )  Like I said though, maybe I'm just not used to it yet...

But what I do think is that global variables really need to use a different icon than equations.  That makes it a major pain in the a55 to root through your sketches as you adjust them and decipher whether a dimension is a global variable that you can adjust or if it's an equation based on another dimension that can't be adjusted.  Y'all need to put that little globe icon next to global variables instead of the "E" that is used for equations.  Luckily I build a lot of my sketches the same way and I know what I typically link and what typically uses equations, so it isn't too terrible.  But I imagine for some that being able to tell the difference between a global variable / linked value and equations just by looking at the icon probably saves a ton of time.

DS
DS 2011-10-31

All you have to do is go to the FM and double click the sketch you want a dimension from and they will be displayed.

SF
SF 2011-11-02

I like Global Variables now that I'm accustomed to them. The one feature I miss was being able to use the dimension selection filter to select a dozen or so dimensions. I could then right click, select "link values" and make everything the same.

Is there a way to edit multiple dimensions at the same time in 2012 so I can replicate this functionality?

TG
TG 2011-11-05

I agree, it would be awesome to have a 'visual' reference that differentiates between mere 'Global-Variable' Dim set-ups and Dims that are set to follow an full-on equeation with more than one 'argument'.

It's true that 'Linked-variables' always was a bi-directional basic 'equation' where your linked-variable name was in reality just a 'Global Variable' in the parlance of programmers.

But the idea of a mini 'globe' icon, or something else that woudl seperate those dimensions from other dimensions that have actual 'multi-argument' Equations would be most helpful.

Someone else also brought up a a really good point:   If you wanted to select 10 or 20 dimensions and set them to all equal one Global Variable, would it take longer and be more tedious with the new interface? (vs. the old Linked-Values method...)  If so, then that should be fixed.

Just my thoughts as a user of SW for over 10 years.  (and I teach it as well.)

But 2012sp1 should have functionality that allows the user to access the best of both methods at will.   That would be ideal, however they make that work...  [wasn't there a song by some young chick about "the best of both worlds..." lol ;-]

ST
ST 2011-11-14

Check out sp1.0!  You'll be happy to see what they brought back!

JP
JP 2011-12-08

Yes, and this has slowed down editing a simple dimension drastically

JP
JP 2011-12-08

Still slower then 2011 for simple editing dimensions

JP
JP 2011-12-08

Can I turn this off???