Practical Exercise 4-23Error of more than 1.5%

The PDF shows a volume of 59,433 and my result is 60,308.99 cubic millimeters, which means more than 1.5% error. I've checked the measurements and they are the same as in the exercise. Now I'm not sure if it's my mistake or an error in the PDF. If someone could verify it, it would be appreciated.

Answers 4
FN
FN 2026-02-17 Best Answer

Create a match of the center of the arc with this line.

comment imagecomment image
SD
SD 2026-02-17

My volume matches the PDF. 

comment imagecomment image
KC
KC 2026-02-17

EDIT: I agree with Mr. Dod. I can't readily and reliably assess where the R43 centers at, but it may be developed from tangency to its R10 neighbor.
Also, you've dimmed your drawing well, but I'm not seeing the value I circled in blue RED.

comment imagecomment image
GF
GF 2026-02-17

I still can't find the problem.

comment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment image