PDM check in - sub assembly update how does it work?

I having problems with my PDM check in and update.

Im not sure if it is working correctly or not.

If i open a top level assembly,  and then open a part that is within a sub assembly,  edit that part and then save it. then open the top level, rebuild it appears correct.

Now when i check in, what is the best/correct way to do it.

Currently, i check in from the top level Assembly drawing, (The part i changed has a Green arrow next to them) so on the check in screen i can add the drawing of them them to the Check in list)

Howeever, Unless i open the sub assembly it does not update. (only the Part and the top level update)

Is there no way i can check in the top level assembly it will update all references? or something, because within a large Assembly i can see there being problems/alot of time having to open all the assemblies that have parts that have changed (and remembering to do it). even trying to remember them. and then having to select there drawings in the check in box?

Im not sure if i have something set up wrong or my check in procedure is wrong.

or do i have to just make sure i open all the sub assemblies that have parts that have changed and save them?

SolidworksWorkgroup Pdm
Answers 12
SF
SF 2011-03-30 Best Answer

Joseph,

I don't understand what your problem is. It seems like you revised the part, not the subassembly, so it is appropriate that neither the subassembly or the top level assembly changed. You didn't change which parts were in the assembly or how they were mated, so the assembly didn't change; it doesn't need to update.

Jerry Steiger

SM
SM 2011-03-30

Joe,

In your scenario, if you have the top level assembly checked out of the vault that

means you and you alone have ownership of that assembly.  Not necessarily the

part you want to update or the sub assembly the part is assembled in.  If you take ownership

of just the part and update it, check it back into the vault.  if you have your vault settings

such that you grab the latest files from the vault then the changes you made to the

part will be reflected in the assemblies it is used in.

I hope this makes sense and I hope it helps you.

SF
SF 2011-03-30

The assembly will only update to show the changes in the part at the time of being opened in SW.   When you check in the part you and (and subsequent drawing) you are only checking in those items.  Unless you opened the higher level assembly AND saved it it will not be available for check in because in the eyes of PDMWorks nothing has changed.

So the proper sequence would be to open the higher level assemlby after you make the change to the part and save the assemlby.  Then do the the check in from the higher level assemlby and 1. the assembly, 2. the part and 3. any drawings that you opened to update should all be shown as available for checkin to the vault.

SF
SF 2011-03-31

I understand what you are saying - For me it would be great if the upper levels did not want  to be changed up "the part" that i changed does not update it the higher level. Ie if the assembly is opened by someone using explorer it shows the old part, Untill it is rebuilt in solidworks.

SF
SF 2011-03-31

HI Scott That is fine if all of our users were using solid works, As they would all update upon opening - But unless you open them with "latest revision" settings they will not update (iirc).

SF
SF 2011-03-31

Hi David

In your first paragraph you discribe the exact problem.  in the second paragraph is the perfect solution, if that Part/sub assembly are only used in the Higher level assembly. The problem really lies in if the Part is used in 400 different top level assemblies. Any user making a change would have to remember all the assemblies that the part was in and open them. and for each one of them do.

Top level assemlby

Sub assemblies

the part

drawings

for all 400?

Hope this is easy to understand im sure there is a simple solution!

SM
SM 2011-03-31

Joe,

Are you saying that not every user is using Solidworks?

Also, why is it so important that all 400 assemblies get updated

right away?  Can't they get updated on a need to use basis?

Where I used to work it wasn't a big deal when a part got updated

that all assemblies it was used on were updated right away.  We did

them when we had to make a must change on it.  Maybe where you work

is different.

Also, we use the "Most up to date" selection when er check out of the

vault.  You are sounding like that is not an option.

What was explained in David'd first paragraph is what I was trying to tell you.

I am sorry if I didn't quite explain it correctly.

SF
SF 2011-03-31

I understand what you are saying but to put it simply its just the nature of the parametric beast and not isolated to SW.  Assemblies are just files that house references to the parts used to create them so every time you open an assembly it goes and looks for all its refernece components (parts / assemblies) and brings in the latest iteration.

You can find where the part is used by selecting the part in the vault view and going to document information and then to where used.  You don't have to update all the other assemblies at that time unless its company policy because as described above it will automatically happen the next time someone opens that assembly so long as you have checked in the revised part to the vault.

SF
SF 2011-04-01

using "most up do date is fine" and works with solidworks users

The issue is People Viewing the PDM system Via Solidworks Explorer (Ie Shop floor or in purchasing)  In solidworks viewer the files do not seem to update.

So if somone makes a Change in solid works, unless they go though and update all the other drawings. the Viewer users will not be able to open the "most up to date"?

Sometimes in Viewer you get a message accross the screen saying "This File Is not up to date and needs rebuilding in solidworks"

SF
SF 2011-04-01

Hi david, The Automatically updating next time it is open is fine for solidworks users but, if the next time it is opened by a solidworks explorer user it does not update

maybe there is a way to get this to happen im not aware of it as of yet.

SM
SM 2011-04-01

Joe,

I understand now.  Makes sense.  Looks like you have a big job on your hand.

In answer to your original question the only way to update the assemblies after

the part is updated is to open each one.  Really stinks I know.

The only other way would be to write a macro but not sure how well that would work for you

either.  I wish I had a better answer for you.

SF
SF 2011-04-01

There is no way to update those other assemblies automatically. You can give a task to someone to sit down and open each assembly and save it back to vault. You can create a macro which can help in this process little bit. Bottom line, SW Explorer will not show changes done to parts if assembly is not updated and saved back to vault.