Here's the situation:
I make a model.
I make a drawing from the model.
I dimension the drawing with ordinate dimensions.
When I change dimensions in the model, if they are rectangular, dimensioned to a midpoint on the drawing, they don't update.
Why might that be?
Have SW 2013
Win 7 (curse it!!)
SolidworksDrawings And Detailing
Welcome to the forum. I don't know why. It's just that way. In some cases when a dimension loses it's reference you can click and drag the little red box at the end of the extension line to re-attach it and sometimes you can't. When you can't you will need to delete the dimension and insert another one (or right-click and "Add to ordinate" for ordinate dimensions).
And I like Win7, but I have a laptop at home with Win8 on it. Don't get me started on that.
Mike,
Can you please check the view properties and the dimension type is "true" or "projected" (normally-projected)
Did you RMB click on the line and select "select midpoint". (just few thoughts)
I checked on Win7 SW2013 and it is working OK
John:
I don't know what you mean by "view properties" but the problem is happening in a drawing of the front view of the model not a projected one.
And I select the midpoint of whatever I'm dimensioning with the RMB allright. As for "Add To Ordinate" the only time I have to use that is if I've gone to the horizontal section of the dimensions from the vertical ones or vice versa. Or if I've just re-opened the drawing or something of that nature.
Glenn:
I have never seen a little red box at the end of an extension line.
Now, this updating of ordinate dimensions used to work just peachy. It worked in W 2009, 2010, 2011, and 2012. SW2013 seems to have some problems with midpoints in other places too but I'll save that one for another rant. Suffice to say I sent, through our "rep" I guess you'd call them, a recorded presentation of it happening and was soundly ignored.
I'm sorry about that. I just went back and re-read your original post and apparently I misunderstood. When you said that your dimension wasn't updating I assumed that it had lost it's reference and turned that ugly yellow-ish brown. When that happens you can click on it and get the red box.
So you're saying that the dimension doesn't change colors, but no longer gives the correct value?
That's exactly what I'm saying.
When I change the dimension/placement/position of a rectangular hole/punch on the model, the ordinate dimension that I have previously placed on the drawing does not update. It doesn't change color, it doesn't get dressed up in party clothes, it doesn't make funny noises, it doesn't visit my aunt Minnie, it doesn't get embarrassed and it doesn't move to where it should. That's it.
Mike,
Can you post an example sldprt and sddrw file that is not working for us to try?
Use the Advanced Editor link in the upper right of the dialog box to post your files.
Cheers,
Anna
See the picture below
This is the view properties and the dimension type
When the dimension type change to true, it can make a difference and wrong dimension
I'm sorry about the delay here. I managed to dig a tunnel out of this place and escape for a week.....they caught me.
I looked at some of my drawings that this has happened on and none of them say "true" in that box so that's out.
I'd like to send an example of it but don't really know how to go about it. The last couple of times it's happened, the change was subtle and, to tell you the truth, I didn't even know it had happened till I went in close and realized that the dimension on the drawing was not pointing to the midpoint of the rectangular hole I had moved in the model. It also seems to be happening with circular things too.
What I'd really like to know is if anyone else is having the same problem and, if not, it may very well be something unique to me.....gawd, I hope not.
You can use the Advanced Editor link in the upper right of the dialog box to post files.
Will not hurt for us to take a look. Or get with your SolidWorks reseller and have them take a look. If it is a bug then it can get logged with SW Hq to be looked at.
Cheers,
Anna
Yes. I tried going through our reseller about another problem I had some time back.
They had me go through a whole process involving video and documentation etc. etc. ad insanitum.
The result was that I never heard another thing and, from what I can tell, the SPR is still open and unresolved.
This does not encourage me to do the same thing again.
SW seems to be developing a lot of problems with this midpoint business; I have another one that has evolved that pertains to sketches made on a solid body. But that, I think, is for a separate thread. I'll do it one of these days.
I was just hoping somone else had the same problem and the only response so far is the first one who said, sometimes it happens, sometimes it doesn't. Not exactly a solution but, at least, a sort of fact.....shudder.
Have you tried creating centerlines of the rectangle and dimensioning to those?
No, I have not tried creating centerlines.
SW states that ordinate dimensions should update when the position (vertically or horizontally), is changed.
They don't do that....at least to the midpoints they don't.
That's the problem.
Creating a centerline on all the rectangular holes in a drawing just to get the program to do what it's supposed to do in the first place seems like and extra and unnecessary step. And what if the centerlines don't bother to move either?
Well, this thread appears to be going nowhere.
Time to think up another route to a solution of some kind.
Thank you all for taking the time to....ummm.....reply.
I just tried dimensioning to centerlines and it updates like it is supposed to.
I'm assuming you were using ordinate dimensions...I hope.
Then it would appear to be a problem unique to my machine/installation/karma.
Thanks for that.
I now have to go through the pain of trying to find out what to do about it.
i might have just figured something else out.
RMB on the offending dimension and check "Driven". There's a pop-up that somes up when I try to dimension to the midpoint that you might have told to not show up.
I think I know the difference between a driven and a driving dimension....although at this point, I'm not sure of anything.
The particular cut extrusions I'm referring to were dimensioned on the model using midpoints. I am gonna assume that these would then be driving dimensions. On the drawing, the text for the dimensions show up black which indicates driving dimensions.....I think.
I just had another one of the same things happen: my boss said he wanted those cut extrusions moved to the right 0.004. I did. When I went to look at the drawing, the dimensions had not updated to reflect that movement. Yes, I saved the model before going to the drawing.
I'm going to go stark raving in a bit here.