Open part in position / Insert Component

I am new to Solidworks, coming from Unigraphics so its likely I'm doing something wrong in my order of operations.

So I am working with an assembly and I want to open a few solids from it, modify them, save them with a new name, then insert them back into the assembly.  The problem I am encountering is when I go to Insert them back in, they are not coming back into the assemblys position.  I have done a test to see the difference of "open part" and "open part in positoin" and both are being re-inserted out of position.  What am I doing wrong?


Thanks In advace.  I really appreciate the help!

SolidworksAssemblies
Answers 7
GS
GS 2018-01-04 Best Answer

Hello Joe,

Welcome to the forum.  In SolidWorks Assemblies, if you click on a Part and choose "Open Part" it opens the Part in the position it was in when it was last saved (or the current position if it was already open).  If you choose "Open Part in Position" it will open it  in the same orientation relative to your screen that it currently exists in the Assembly.  That's the only difference, so after the Part is open any edits or saving will be the same for both options.

Why are you editing the Part, saving to a new Name, and then re-inserting, as opposed to just opening the Part, editing it, saving it, and then going back to the Assembly?  The answer to that should help us suggest an alternative workflow that will better accomplish your goal.  I'm about to leave for the day, but I'll try to check in in a few hours, or someone else will probably be able to help.

GS
GS 2018-01-05

I was thinking about this as I was driving home.   If you open a Part from an Assembly,  edit it,  and choose "Save as" you should get a pop-up asking if you want to replace the existing Part in the Assembly with the new one.  If you don't get that message you might check your dismissed messages at Tools > Options.

JH
JH 2018-01-05

Hi Glenn,

Thanks for the replies.

So I am trying to take a wire harness with some clips, take one clip with the wires and rotate it around an axis that I've placed in the main assembly.  There are a few of these I have to rotate so I've placed a few Axis's in the main assembly that I was hoping would be brought into the new part when I 'Open part' and edited.  So then I can bring back in with the same shared axis..  Some of them have a 'double hinge point' so I am trying to Mate them together so I can move them both at the same time, while also independently after I 'Fix' the one into place.  I dont know if that helps, its somewhat hard to explain.

JH
JH 2018-01-05

Also, for what it's worth - when I open the main part from the assembly and simple save it with a new name and insert it back into the assembly, it comes into a different location.

GS
GS 2018-01-05
<p>Joe Haglund wrote:</p><p></p><p>Hi Glenn,</p><p style="min-height: 8pt; padding: 0px;"></p><p>Thanks for the replies.</p><p style="min-height: 8pt; padding: 0px;"></p><p>So I am trying to take a wire harness with some clips, take one clip with the wires and rotate it around an axis that I've placed in the main assembly. There are a few of these I have to rotate so I've placed a few Axis's in the main assembly that I was hoping would be brought into the new part when I 'Open part' and edited. </p><p><em><strong style="color: #303030;">I'm afraid it doesn't work that way.  Assembly features don't carry over to a Part (unless it's an Assembly cut of some kind, and you've chosen to propagate it to the Part).</strong></em></p><p>So then I can bring back in with the same shared axis.. Some of them have a 'double hinge point' so I am trying to Mate them together so I can move them both at the same time, while also independently after I 'Fix' the one into place. I dont know if that helps, its somewhat hard to explain.</p><p><em><strong>​A screenshot might help.</strong></em></p>
DP
DP 2018-01-05

IF you share your assembly (pack and go to a zip file, then attach that), then we can show you some ways to do what you want.

Right now, it is hard to explain, because we don't know exactly what you have tried and not tried.

WS
WS 2018-01-05

The reason this could be happening is because when that main part was put into the original assembly it was not orientated on the orgin of the assembly file it was brought in to.  It sounds like it was drop out in space at no specific location.  Will talking about the first part(main part).