Not able to extrusion after a corner feat

Good Morning

Very often I'm not able to remove material 'or extrusion boss' after the sheet have been closed corners (corner feat).

Basically, I have to raise the bar in the design tree, to make a recovery, before the corner feat, in order to do an operation outlined as simply as a circle. Otherwise I had simple message:

Construction error: "The operation to fail because of the geometry" or "The function could not cut the body"

I SolidWorks 2013, when I publish some room formerly designed, SW load with no problem, but if I publish a hill, creating upstream closed corners, he does not know rebuilt, although the dimensions are the same .

Do you know this? you know a solution?

thank you very much

SolidworksSheet Metal
Answers 18
JS
JS 2015-03-13 Best Answer

Charles -

Could you upload pictures or files

CR
CR 2015-03-13

Not working:

What i have to do to make it working:(see ate blue arrow and the left)

Thank you!

comment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment image
JS
JS 2015-03-13

Do not check this box

comment imagecomment image
DG
DG 2015-03-13

Simply change the direction of cut and it should work.

JS
JS 2015-03-13

The direction was Ok in the model, sometimes the normal cut - checked and un-checked makes a difference

DG
DG 2015-03-13

The model doesn't contains the errors he is showing in the pictures, so I think it could be related to direction of cut.

CR
CR 2015-03-13

Thanks but i ve already try this. Its because of the corner feat.

For example in this document, if i do "Ctrl+Q"  to rebuilt the model (and nothing else), all the feature who has been did after the corner feat, become red with red cross (error).

comment imagecomment image
IM
IM 2015-03-13

I opened the file in SW 2013 with no errors. I made new cuts everywhere I could think of in any way I could think of with no problems.

When I opened it in SW 2014/2015 I saw these errors exactly as you are showing them now, did a ctrl+q rebuild and  the errors went away. Also did  made new cuts everywhere I could think of in any way I Could think of with no problems.

CR
CR 2015-03-13

In the first picture, i dindt did a rebuild (so no error), and its a extrusion boss ( not remove material feature)

DG
DG 2015-03-13

Not for me. Edit the cut extrude features and make sure you've selected "Link to Thickness" and/or "Normal cut"

CR
CR 2015-03-13

Ok thank you,

so its coming from my computer, and i have already try to setup SW 2003 again! ^^

JS
JS 2015-03-13

It showed errors here but as soon as I changed the cut they went away, but I agree with Ingavar, where it could be more of a 2013 to 2015 issue and different SP's could have a bug somewhere. 

All good on this end, carry on

MM
MM 2015-03-16

Charles, on this type of part you choose to close the corners in two commands

in this case it caused a corner collision, where one command for the whole corner

did not, in p-01.jpeg you'll see what to delete, in p-02.jpeg you'll add your command

at the end, you can do all four at once. Then p-03.jpeg you'll see it unfolded.

Hope this helps, I'm on SW2015 so I can't send the file for you to use.

CR
CR 2015-03-16

Hi Mark,

Do you mean that i ve to add my comand at the end? yes i know, thats the problem.

In other document (who has been designed in the past, not by me), i can't put the corner features at the end, because some sketches downstream, are relies to this corner feature

thank you

MM
MM 2015-03-16

no I corrected what I wrote, what I wrote would have worked at where you did

the first partial close corner command.

CR
CR 2015-03-16

I never hear about "SP", what is it, or better: what can be the solution??

Thank you !

CR
CR 2015-03-16

Yea right! Its working as you said, i hope its working for other document too!

I just have to editing all the document

Thank you!

comment imagecomment image
SF
SF 2015-03-16

mmmmmmm, i´m not sure, but, tou are working with metal, so, why you don´t use hole wizard?

try with this tool, you can set the diameter dimension that you want. so please check and comment, good luck!!