When it comes to computers, their components, and how they interact with Solidworks, I am not overly savvy. Looking for a little help from the professionals.
I have been given a budget by employer to purchase a new workstation. I do work with most Office programs, but the primary function of this computer will be Solidworks (2015 SP04 and newer versions as they are released).
I do basic modeling and drawings for tooling and replacement parts, but have been working more with the R&D team lately on project design with moderately sized assemblies (200-1000 parts). Renderings and motion studies have been a huge help pushing new ideas through upper management, and as we work more with the animations, we see the value in having a computer that can handle these tasks efficiently.
I made the mistake of jumping on my first offer without doing my homework in full, and ended up with this mobile workstation:
I have been working with this computer for the last two weeks, and though I notice the difference from my old workstation, it just doesn't seem all there. After researching more in-depth on the aspects of a computer that make a difference for the kind of work I do, I stumbled across this desktop workstation:
I realize that with the second option I lose the mobility of a laptop, but I am not beyond packing up a tower and taking it home for a weekend to work on a project. I would also have my old laptop available for small parts and assemblies, which it handles fine.
Would the added benefits of the desktop make that much of a difference? And though subjective, in your opinion, would the added benefits be worth losing the mobility of the ZBook? The budget I am working with is \\\$2500-3000, and I am limited to the CDW website by my employer. If you're bored and feel like navigating the CDW website, feel free to make any recommendations on a workstation I did not mention.
Thanks in advance!
SolidworksAdministration
It looks like you are not given the option to customize your selection. With that in mind, I like this machine:
HP Workstation Z440 - Xeon E5-1620V3 3.5 GHz - 16 GB - 256 GB - F1M46UT#ABA - Workstations - CDW.com
However, do you also need to buy a monitor? That would eat into your budget.
Anyway, the reasons I like this machine are listed below, which might help you in making a final decision:
- Speed - 3.5 Ghz - while not the fastest, it is near the top. I think the I7-4970k is a better processor, but is not offered in combination with the other options that are important to me for SolidWorks speed.
- Memory - 16 Gb is a decent amount for the size assemblies you are looking at. You could get by with 8, but might push that limit with larger assemblies.
- Graphics card K4600 - this card is much faster than the K620 and will help with with working with more parts on screen.
All that being said, I have more experience with the modelling side as opposed to rendering and motion studies. Maybe someone else will chime in with their 2-cents.
Thanks for your response David. I failed to mention in the original post that I do have a 30-day return deadline on the system that I have now, so time is of the essence.
I will be responsible for finding a monitor, but I wont make that an issue immediately. I have a spare at home I could use as a loaner until the budget allowed for the purchase of a new one.
I believe you are right in saying that 16 GB ram is sufficient, and a desktop will almost always allow room for expansion.
Thanks again for your input. Its getting to that point where I need to make a decision I can stick with.
Remote desktop access is something that I had completely overlooked until now. If I could take advantage a new desktop remotely from my old laptop, all questions would be answered and the solution would be simple.
Is anybody experienced in this? Can a mediocre client laptop run a host desktop workstation at it's full potential?
Travis
First and foremost I am no expert when it comes to selecting a Modeling Workstation the company issued me a loaded Dell Precision M4700 and it does pretty well when working with Solidworks and AutoCAD. However if it were my money I would get with this company. Mobile Workstations
They are experts.
I would stay away from HP but that is just me.
This strongly depends on your bandwidth. but, yes is the answer. That said, your "mediocre" laptop will probably handle solidworks better on it's own than it will via RDT.
The number one performance improvement you could make is to go from a HDD to a SSD. This will be night and day different. Also, solidworks thrives on a single core; the higher the clock speed the better. More cores are better for Renderings/simulation only (little to no effect on standard solidworks).
RAM is needed for complex parts or assemblies. I would say 16GB is good for what you're doing.
As for GPU... really the only place you'll notice this is in how smoothly the model rotates, zooms, pans and the fancy lighting effects. That and unapproved video cards do tend to crash more often. Again, this tends to play a bigger roll in complex assemblies.
Our engineering group has almost completely transitioned over to laptops. Mainly for the convenience of having meetings. We switched from midrange Dell Precision T5500/T5600 (from 2012) to custom Dell Latitudes e6440 ( from 2014). These were a nice upgrade for us. The solidworks benchmarks all improved from this upgrade. I should note that most of our assemblies do not exceed 100 unique parts.
We also have some higher end Dell Precision M4700 and to be honest the performance improvement is ever so minor over the Latitudes that's it's really not worth it if you are actually moving the laptop around a lot.
Personally strong to suggest that Don't Buy HP ZBook 14 G2 for 3D- CAD, Even it can be passed all kinds of verify tests(eg driver, SP, hardware etc). but it's useless. System always hang, crashed, Bluescreen, display flash, Colling fan unusual speed-up, shut-down etc even after re-install Windows or re-install Solidworks.
WY
Travis, the current level of RDP has no hardware OpenGL support, meaning the performance will not be hardware accelerated and running in software OpenGL mode(very slow rotate/pan/zoom performance).
The technology for remote is just coming online with folks like FRAME Cloud Platform· Run any software in a browser .
However, if you're seeing performance limitations with a HP Zbook17 g2, then that tells me you're pushing current technology pretty hard. It would help if you could elaborate on what exactly you're perceiving as 'slow' because that would tell you what your bottleneck is. Often spending 3k unnecessary if you know what is holding you back.
My comment is on the amount of ram. Solidworks had something out there about it. They said on a 64 bit computer HP Z440, the optimum would be 12GB. They said the speed from 12GB to 16GB would be minimal.