Modifying Dumb Solids with Multiple Solidbodies

I downloaded a 3D model from a suppliers website and the length

of the rail I have modified by adding a cut to the one solidbody to get

it to the length we need it at.  Problem is as you will see when you open up my

part is the end cap is now detached.  This is a 2 part question.  First is the cut the

best method to shorten this or is there a better solution?  I need the rail shortened

with the end cap butted up to the rail.  Second if the cut is the way to go how do I

get the end rail to butt up to the rail?

I already tried using feature works and it didn't work properly.

Thanks for your help.

SolidworksParts And Features
Answers 9
SF
SF 2010-09-22 Best Answer

Shooting from the hip, without looking at the file.

Have you looked at the move face command?  In order to move a face across several holes, you might have to delete and patch those holes, but this will allow the rails to be shortened without a cut.

Is this really a better method? No, not really!! I would say the cut is likely a better method because it allows you to control the overall length vs. telling the software to shorten the rail by x amount.

How do you then move the caps in place? Move / Copy body using the mating style method.  Insert -> Feature -> Move / Copy Body.

Regards,

JPD

SM
SM 2010-09-22

This sounds like it could work.  It also sounds like I would do this instead of the cut, right?

KB
KB 2010-09-22

i would use the cut feature.

then use the move/copy body feature (mates) to re-align the end cap.

piece of cake

feature works is a waste of time.

SF
SF 2010-09-22

The easiest place to find the move face command is to right-click on the face, press the Down arrow at the bottom to expand the menu, and one of the options in the Face section should be "Move".

But I might still use the cut because, like I said, it gives more flexibility to incorperate design intent vs. the move face.

SM
SM 2010-09-22

Thanks for your help guys.  This excercise taught me 2 new commands.

I ended up like you suggested Ken keeping the cut and Moved\Copy the remaining solidbodies

and mating them to the new face.

LB
LB 2010-09-22
<p>Kenneth Barrentine wrote:</p><p></p><p>i would use the cut feature.</p><p>then use the move/copy body feature (mates) to re-align the end cap.</p><p>piece of cake</p><p></p><p>feature works is a waste of time.</p>

move face isn't feature works it is a feature command and it works great...!

KB
KB 2010-09-22

i think you might be reading something that isn't there.

;-)

LB
LB 2010-09-22

I guess if I would read the entire thread....I would have seen why you stated FeatureWorks is a waste of time...I thought you ment move face was a featureworks tool...sorry for the confusion.

featureworks is only for a single body part file anyway so thats why he had all thoughs issues with it.

SM
SM 2010-09-22

I too agree that Feature Works is a waste of time for the most part.

The move/copy face command worked perfectly for what I needed it for.