I want to modify this part to change the structure shown in the screen shot. If modifying portion is on the X axis it is easy to modify. But seed is coming on X axis instances are not. Is it possible to bring one of the instances on the X axis? I tried with move/copy command and change orientation command but it didn’t work.

..just cut one off 1 of 3 and add/replace with the vertical couplers?
In addition to this, you'll find that the delete face tool has a window of what it can accomplish in one feature. Sometimes you can stick your hand into a cookie jar and grab all of the cookies, but this is rare. You'll find you can grab 1-3 cookies at a time until you're reached your goal. The same applies for the delete face tool. You'll need to use it in phases depending on what your end goal is with each feature having the same intent towards removing fillet(s), then the next tool to remove other type of geometry.
That makes a lot of sense to me now. Thank you.
This was where I got this drawing but I don't like this method. I am looking for easiest way to do modification.
I don't know what the original intent of the change was, but my assumption was the seed was the geometry that needed to be "rotated 90 degrees to vertical" and it needed to stay in the same relative location so proposed the approach I showed. Another approach to accomplish that exact thing would be to edit the pattern to change the number of instances to 2 instead of 3. Then use Move/Copy to rotate the solid 120 degrees so the empty space of the pattern is where the seed used to be. Then you can add the plane and 3 new features.
But, since this is an example model for model mania, my other assumption was to do it in the absolute quickest method possible (since that is the goal in model mania). Plus, on a model like this, the geometry regeneration is so quick, using delete and patch to accomplish it likely has the same or faster regeneration and keeps the same exact, clean geometry so is a perfectly valid modeling approach.
In reality, I just looked back at the part that Maha attached and the tab that need to be rotated 90 degrees IS NOT the seed as was labeled in the original post (I never even checked the features to see). So, the two patterns could be edited to have only 2 instances (and flip the direction on each) but then to have a clean model, fillets also need to be edited to take out the removed fillet references from the 3rd instance that is now gone. Then finally, the plane and 3 new features can be created. This would take MUCH longer in a model mania situation to get the resulting geometry, so I would STILL go with the delete and patch approach.
-Jim
Interesting that there is so many varying answers.
My approach, (given that I only looked at the picture & drawing & not the model), would be to eliminate the circular pattern, do a mirror of the 120 degree slot & horizontal tabs, then create the vertical tabs.
I feel like creating a feature, then deleting parts of it is messy. But I'm open to hearing why it's better.
For delete and patch to work, the surrounding faces have to be able to be trimmed/extended to reform the solid. In your case on he left, if you remove the flat face with the red X on it, there is no face left between the two half cylinder faces to patch back in. Whereas on the right case, since you have not selected that flat face for deleting, it will trim that flat face back to the very large cylindrical face to patch it back up.
-Jim
I have confusion over using “Delete and Patch” option. I only do it by trial and error procedure. For example if I want to Delete and Patch this feature I used to select faces making this feature but it didn’t work. What is the reason for that?
For example if you select bottom face “Delete and Patch” option popups with error message.
If I want to Delete and Patch a feature what are faces I have to select.
Thank you very much for the explanation. This idea is very helpful.
I disagree that it would be easier to rotate the existing instance even if there were commands to allow you to do it (which there aren't to do it cleanly; not sure any solid modeler has tools to do that well). There are just too many differences in the geometry like angled side faces, extra fillets, hole size, slot geometry, etc.
But, instead of cutting off the existing geometry, I would probably use the Delete Face feature to remove the existing geometry with the Fill and Patch option which will remove it completely like in the image below:
Then it is just a boss extrusion from the side with the hole built into it:
a cut extrusion for the slot from the top:
and a fillet (on 2 edges):
Note that after I added the Delete Face feature, I rolled back before that feature to turn on temporary axes and add Plane1 to be used for the two extrude features. Also note that I don't know exact sizes, so I just eyeballed it and added no dimensions on the sketches.
This is a good example where the "direct edit" tools like delete face in SOLIDWORKS can be very useful. In my mind, they really aren't intended to be a separate kind of modeling technique to history based modeling like in some other modelers, but to be used integrated with other history based modeling techniques to achieve design intent.
-Jim
Hi Maha,
May be I don't understand the problem, but I would change sketch 1 to give you the right shape and use the symmetry.
Edit,
Sorry, I get it, it's supposed to be direct editing of a featureless part.
Here is your solution....
SolidWorks Tutorial Model Mania Part 2 - YouTube
But I prefer the answer.
May I ask something...this 2D drawing is a correct for almost the users here?
I think it is easier to modify one of the non horizontal instances rather than above mentioned method.
Hello,
Pick one of the 3 slots and cut it off to the main OD as Mr. Salvador suggests.
Make a midplane plane in the remaining slot.
Convert entities on the slot perimeter.
Extrude midplane to infill to the top and bottom slot face.
Continue with an extrude but using Mr. Salvador's sketch above.
Kevin