MAting springs and other parts

I seem to be spending way too much time trying to figure out how to mate odd shaped parts. I try all sorts of things to get things to stick together, and I was wondering why I am having so much trouble. The spring in the picture to me is impossible to mate to the little protrusion. The other part that would be on the left is invisible right now.

SolidworksAssemblies
Answers 15
JR
JR 2013-11-09 Best Answer

Use existing sketch entities and planes to mate the spring to that post. Or create sketch geometry, axis, planes, etc... that you feel would be needed to mate the parts together.

JS
JS 2013-11-09

Hi Andrew.

The simplest way to mate the spring to the protrusion may be as follows:   Beings your spring is round, and the protrusion is round, both will have a temporary axis. Display the temporary axes and mate the two together. Probably will mate automatically, but it should be a concentric mate. Then use the bottom plane of the spring, and mate to the flat face of the protrusion, using coincident, or distance mate. If you have no bottom plane, then make a slight flat spot on the bottom of the spring, like a ground end. Best wishes.

SF
SF 2013-11-09

Yes, axis. That's the one I usually try last, but forgot today. Jesse had a good idea about using sketches too. I'll put a sketch point in the middle of a square post in order to center it in a round hole for instance. Thanks guys! My head's pretty gone dissolving and reassembling subassemblies all day. It was amazing the SW was keeping track of everything, and nothing crashed and burned.

SB
SB 2013-11-09

Hi...Andrew...

Draw the temporary Center axis(OR)individualy draw center line's of both the Part's Spring&protrusion.OR Display the temporary axes and mate the two together. Probably will mate automatically, but it should be a coincident mate only if u want both are center. Then use the bottom plane of the spring, and mate to the flat face of the protrusion, using coincident mate

WM
WM 2018-03-27

Why does McMaster make parts in the most UN-intuitive ways? Good call on the axis or sketch-a-mate.

SC
SC 2018-03-27

For springs this is how I mate.

First I go into the spring model, add an axis. That's for a concentric mate.

I mate the axis concentric to that which it needs be.

If the spring is modeled statically (compressed or uncompressed), I mate one edge of the spring thickness tangentially to the surface it needs be.

     If it is modeled in motion (to be compressed or uncompressed) or has config control to adjust length I will additionally added a tangential mate to the other surface it would be constrained to.

WM
WM 2018-03-27

nice tip: Dude I gotta ask cause its been bothering me what is your icon? looks like a weed nugget LOL

DN
DN 2018-03-27
<p>William McFaul wrote:</p><p></p><p>Why does McMaster make parts in the most UN-intuitive ways? Good call on the axis or sketch-a-mate.</p>

They could start charging you to use them.

WM
WM 2018-03-27

they do, every time I buy the part. I don't download 'em to look at 'em.

DP
DP 2018-03-28
<p>S. Casale wrote:</p><p></p><p>For springs this is how I mate.</p><p style="min-height: 8pt; padding: 0px;"></p><p>First I go into the spring model, add an axis. That's for a concentric mate.</p><p>I mate the axis concentric to that which it needs be.</p><p>If the spring is modeled statically (compressed or uncompressed), I mate one edge of the spring thickness tangentially to the surface it needs be.</p><p> If it is modeled in motion (to be compressed or uncompressed) or has config control to adjust length I will additionally added a tangential mate to the other surface it would be constrained to.</p>

In addition to the axis, I also generally add 2 planes for robustness.  1 for each end of the spring, and just use those to mate to surfaces.   If the spring has configurations like extended or contracted, then the planes will update accordingly.

RB
RB 2018-03-28

I'm Design a spring ISO 10243 Standard with DT and I have one posible solution....not the better but it's works fine to me...

The solution was made a extruded cilinder and on this one add a automatic relation of position

When you add this one you only try to find any cilinder hole or wherever.....and thats all I will try to add a video file

comment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment image
SC
SC 2018-03-28
<p>Dan Pihlaja wrote:</p><p></p><blockquote class="jive-quote"><p>S. Casale wrote:</p><p style="min-height: 8pt; padding: 0px;"></p><p>For springs this is how I mate.</p><p style="min-height: 8pt; padding: 0px;"></p><p>First I go into the spring model, add an axis. That's for a concentric mate.</p><p>I mate the axis concentric to that which it needs be.</p><p>If the spring is modeled statically (compressed or uncompressed), I mate one edge of the spring thickness tangentially to the surface it needs be.</p><p> If it is modeled in motion (to be compressed or uncompressed) or has config control to adjust length I will additionally added a tangential mate to the other surface it would be constrained to.</p></blockquote><p>In addition to the axis, I also generally add 2 planes for robustness. 1 for each end of the spring, and just use those to mate to surfaces. If the spring has configurations like extended or contracted, then the planes will update accordingly.</p>

I don't add features that aren't necessary. If it fails which it does at times (depending on the person who made the model), I iwlll add planes.

Supefluous: admittedly, I really don't like the use of the word "robust," It's completely over used.

               I also can't stand the phrase added to the beginning or the end of any statement "at the end of the day." - Also completely overused.

DP
DP 2018-03-28

Looks like a geographical map of the West Canada Lake Wilderness.

SC
SC 2018-03-28

You're welcome.

Dude I gotta tell ya it's an image of a map of the Adirondack State Park.

WM
WM 2018-03-28

nice