mass won't change enven though I change the material

Hi guys,

Strange things happen to me. Mo mater how I assign the different material, but mass property report always tell me the same mass as steel density. from Mass Properties-> options I can see the density has been changed to the assigned material. but from the report, it still gives me the same density and the same mass.

How can I get the right mass?

SolidworksParts And Features
Answers 12
SF
SF 2013-10-26 Best Answer

Alyssa,

I have never seen anything like this. Does this happen just on one or a few parts, or is it every part that has the problem? Can you attach a part that has the problem so that other people can see if it fails on their systems?

Jerry S.

DG
DG 2013-10-27

Check if you've done what Alin has pointed here: https://forum.solidworks.com/message/296832#296832

SF
SF 2013-10-27

Please see the attachment.

SF
SF 2013-10-27

please see my model below. and my colleague looked at in his computer, it won't change either. so it is very strange.

JM
JM 2013-10-27

There appears to be some anomaly in the geometry.

First thing I noticed is that your sketches are not fully defined.

Then I noticed lack of symmetry where symmetry would be expected.

I then saved in STEP format and opened in another program and the anomaly switched sides of the model?

I can't figure out the purpose of Boss Extrude 2?

Sketch41 (for M3 Cleance Hole) does not appear to be in correct position?

I can't figure out the purpose of Boss Extrude 10?  (why not adjust ealier feature sketch?)

Fillet 2 doesn't make sense to me (on one edge and the mirror).

I recommend you add holes last.

The entire part could be significantly simplified doing most of the features with two simple Revolves, add the Ribs, Fillets and then the Holes.

I don't understand the Sweep.

comment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment image
JM
JM 2013-10-28

I might simplify some of the feature creation as in attached file.

I didn't really understand your rib features on close inspection.
I would add the holes last.

DG
DG 2013-10-28

As stated, you've material applied to the body which overwrite the material applied to the part. remove the material from the body and you should be fine.

SF
SF 2013-10-28

Thanks. This is only my premilinary concept design to see whether it works or not. So some features need to be simplified as you said. Ribs is to improve the strength.

SF
SF 2013-10-28

Hi Deepak,

Why I can't see what you show me? from the picture I showed you, I didn't find Solid Body( sweep2).

Even though I supress the sweep2 feature, it still doesn't change the density .

DG
DG 2013-10-28

Make sure solid bodies is set to how under Tools > Options > System Options > FeatureManager > Hide/Show Tree Items.

This will let you see the solid body folder and then you can expand that and remove the material.

SF
SF 2013-11-06

Thanks Deepak. I got it.

JM
JM 2013-11-06
<p>alyssa gao wrote:</p><p></p><p>..... Ribs is to improve the strength.</p>

I understood the purpose of the ribs, but not the logic of how you were trying to create them.

I recommend that on the re-design you take a close look at those features as well.

My best and fastest modelers also fully define as they are going along - no hard to find (and fix) anomalies 20 features up the tree.

I have not seen any evidence that preliminary concepts go any faster by ignoring robust modeling techniques, in fact, all of my experience has shown just the opposite.

I sometimes open a file I did a year, or month, or a week ago and shudder at my poor technique...