Improving and make Costing a better Product

Why is this not been made great yet? Solidworks, you have few years to make Costing a great product, but its hardly changed since its introduction... sigh??

I am finding that Costing in 2016 is not much different than 2015. I have been saying SW should really look at nesting software to improve the costing functionality and they are at least exploring the idea, but its still far from usable. in 2016 when you an 3x5x8 inch piece of 14 Gauge SS with a single bend in it, you can at least see a nested sheet of 102 bent SM parts, when I only need 3. It would nice to load up several SM SW parts into some sort of Interface that are of the same Gauge and have SW nest each of them per the specified sheet data provided. As for the costing it can be broken out per total of each part or as a whole.

I have been asking for information on setting up or someone to share an actual template, but no hitters yet. I asked one of our Sheet metal suppliers how they figure cost and when they are cutting it, its all about time to cut or how many pieces can be bent in an hour. SW costing does not figure any of that from what I have been reading.

I find it be a common practice for SW to introduce something cool and useful, and then never make it better until more than few thousand people want to actually use it. They should have a crew working on each area of the software to make it better and stop spending time on the UI alone, which is not good at all this year IMO.

SolidworksSolidworks 2016 Beta
Answers 3
SF
SF 2015-07-31 Best Answer

Hi Scott,

Thanks a lot for the feedback, I'm glad you are interested in the sheet metal bounding box nest functionality and I'm sure we can continue to expand on this as we get more input on the tool. Are you primarily interested in Costing for sheet metal parts? If this is the case, admittedly we have had more machining related enhancements in the last two releases due to its more complex nature, but you might have noticed that we have expanded the functionality a lot when it comes to castings, plastics, 3D printing, weldments, and assemblies so a lot of work was definitely put in to this tool.

The templates appear to be where we need to focus our energy. As you mention, we use cost per length in our sheet metal templates while we use cost per time in our machining templates, but we have heard that many sheet metal manufacturers have opted to using a time-based approach as well. If we can provide an easier template-creation experience do you think this would help, or would you rather have a plug-and-play approach where you don't need to worry about a template (but your estimate might not be as accurate to your specific vendor as a result)?

Cheers,

-Blake

SF
SF 2015-07-31
<p style="font-family: Verdana, 'Verdana Ref', Geneva, Tahoma, sans-serif; color: #333333;">Thanks a lot for the feedback, I'm glad you are interested in the sheet metal bounding box nest functionality and I'm sure we can continue to expand on this as we get more input on the tool. Are you primarily interested in Costing for sheet metal parts?</p>

No, I need to know about Cutting as well (utilizing a laser, & water jet mainly) for flat plate, & Structural members.

Nesting is something I spent 4 days this past month doing just to determine how many sheets of SS we need to build our entire machine. The only reason it took me 4 days is because we found some free nesting software. If I had to do manually in SW like I was doing it would have been more like weeks too figure it out.

<p style="font-family: Verdana, 'Verdana Ref', Geneva, Tahoma, sans-serif; color: #333333;">If this is the case, admittedly we have had more machining related enhancements in the last two releases due to its more complex nature, but you might have noticed that we have expanded the functionality a lot when it comes to castings, plastics, 3D printing, weldments, and assemblies so a lot of work was definitely put in to this tool.</p>

For me the 3D Printing, plastics don't do a lot for us, but i understand there are a lot of others it does benefit. For me the Weldment Download that we can get from the SW website is great, but I still find a lot of basic missing sizes that i can get from our supplier.

<p style="font-family: Verdana, 'Verdana Ref', Geneva, Tahoma, sans-serif; color: #333333;">The templates appear to be where we need to focus our energy.</p>

I agree, the templates are still very cumbersome and there really needs to be an import\export to Excel. It would make changing this template far easier than it currently is inside of SW. Copy and paste works part of the time and not at all in other areas... its to flaky and hard to understand what is going on.

<p style="font-family: Verdana, 'Verdana Ref', Geneva, Tahoma, sans-serif; color: #333333;">As you mention, we use cost per length in our sheet metal templates while we use cost per time in our machining templates, but we have heard that many sheet metal manufacturers have opted to using a time-based approach as well.</p>

i hate to say it, but having the ability to choose between timing and length might be the better choice. Not all companies do it the same.

<p style="font-family: Verdana, 'Verdana Ref', Geneva, Tahoma, sans-serif; color: #333333;">If we can provide an easier template-creation experience do you think this would help, or would you rather have a plug-and-play approach where you don't need to worry about a template (but your estimate might not be as accurate to your specific vendor as a result)?</p>

Yes, yes, yes... an easier template creation experience is a must. I would still like to have some pre-selections like cut methods, thickness, material type, etc... but let me build it. You should still have some basic pre-built templates, but allow users the ability to make their own.

The numbers I was getting from SW were no where close to what it actually cost, I played with the template to try and get something close, and when I did I would load up another file and then it was way off.

If you ever want to talk offline PM me and I will give you my cell.

I have attached a unique piece that we have in one of our machines

Thanks I hope to hear back from you on this.

Scott

SF
SF 2015-08-11

All very good info, thanks a lot Scott! I sent you a PM, let's definitely chat.

Cheers,

-Blake