Idea: select chain in weldment group similar to same in sweep

Title expresses the basic idea.

When I make a new weldment group, I would like to be able to select one entity in a chain of sketch entities, and populate the selections for that group by a Select Chain option in the same manner that this selection method is available in creation of a Sweep.

This would consistently make the creation of rigid tubing faster and easier for me. It would also enhance other common weldment applications, such as a box frame.

Do tell if this is available in 2019, or if I am missing an option to enable this input in 2018. Thank you.

SolidworksWeldments
Answers 5
CE
CE 2021-04-09 Best Answer

The following works in 2018:

1. Create your weldment sketch.

    But the sketch may only contain a single continuous chain of lines (construction lines are okay.)

2. Use the Structural Member Tool, but don't select any lines.

    Instead, select the sketch you made in step 1 from the tree.

TG
TG 2021-04-09

Yes it may, inconsistently. It did not work well at one time, and workarounds were standardized.

GS
GS 2021-04-09

Tom Gagnon wrote:

 

For example, I make all 1/2" suction tubing in one part. To carry through its needed length for purchasing, I filter select all sketch segments, measure, copy total length, and paste that value into custom property. I repeat this process for each different profile across separate components, so that 1/2" tube carries its purchase length and 1/4" tube carries its purchase length as separate BOM items.

Tom,

Won't the built-in TOTAL LENGTH property do that for you?

comment imagecomment image
TG
TG 2021-04-09

I do not create weldments in one part per piece (or group). I almost always have multiple groups. This idea of selecting the sketch instead is understood, not chosen, and does not satisfy me.

For example, I make all 1/2" suction tubing in one part. To carry through its needed length for purchasing, I filter select all sketch segments, measure, copy total length, and paste that value into custom property. I repeat this process for each different profile across separate components, so that 1/2" tube carries its purchase length and 1/4" tube carries its purchase length as separate BOM items.

GS
GS 2021-04-09

I use weldments on almost every project, and often with multiple line segments.  However, I rarely have  more line segments in any one sketch than I want to use in a single feature, so I use the method described by .  However, I can certainly see the benefit of having the "select chain" option.  Submit it this fall for the Top Ten Idea voting, or submit an ER.