I have a mate question

I have drawn a five gore sheet metal elbow, but now I need tomate the five parts.

Unlike a saw cut through structural pipe, the edges are not flatsurfaces, because sheet metal in the real world will pucker on oneedge and draw in on the opposite.

Did I explain that right???

Now my problem is how do I mate these gores? I have a .010 seam ineach and I can mate two corners and that looks really good untilyou zoom in or check the final angle of the elbow and that leaves agap on the inside radius of the elbow, so now my 90 deg. angle issomewhere less than that.

What should I do???

DanSolidworksSheet Metal
Answers 15
JA
JA 2009-02-14 Best Answer
"Hey Doc, my shoulder hurts when I raise my arm over my head"
Doc, "Don't raise your arm over your head"

Don't zoom way in...
SF
SF 2009-02-14

Jay Andrews wrote:

 

"Hey Doc, my shoulder hurts when I raise my arm over my head"

Doc, "Don't raise your arm over your head"



Don't way in...

Excuse Me? Whats that suppose to mean?
JA
JA 2009-02-14
Just a little Friday afternoon joke...

...and you're excused.
SF
SF 2009-02-14

Jay Andrews wrote:

 

Just a little Friday afternoon joke...



...and you're excused.

Got it... Jay seeing that you don't have a clue on how toanswer my question, find something else to do and quit wasting mytime by responding.
JA
JA 2009-02-14
touchy touchy...
SF
SF 2009-02-14
Only with trolls who have nothing better to do.
KL
KL 2009-02-14
How are the parts assembled in the real world? Are the edgesdressed to allow flush fitting? Are the parts welded?

Can you create a circular pattern of the part?
AW
AW 2009-02-14
Dan,

Can you zip up your file and upload it here? Can you post a screenshot of the assembly you are trying to achieve? A hand sketch willdo.

I am having trouble envisioning what you have to be able to helpyou develop your pattern or mate scheme. I am sure there is a way,once we see your part.

Cheers,

SF
SF 2009-02-16
Good morning Anna and Kelvin, yes I will try and zip theassy. so you can see what I mean. To answer your question Kelvini'm not quite sure how one would dress the edges so I could matethe faces, I just don't know and yes it will be a welded assy.

Thank you for your help, I will get a zip file shortly.

Dan
KL
KL 2009-02-16
Dan, By dressing the edges, I meant in the real world ...with a grinder or similar metal removal device.
SF
SF 2009-02-16
Kelvin,
Yes I will have no problem putting the parts together on the bench,my problem is I have to send it to a customer for approval and Iwant it to look right.

You will see in my zip file that I have them mated at the seamcorners of the gores, but that just makes them hinge about thosemates.

This elbow shoud be 90 deg. looking at the front plane and thesquare flange should be tilted 9 deg.

Dan
JB
JB 2009-02-16
Since your parts have no mateable surfaces you will have touse reference geometry to mate them. Try a layout type sketch inthe assembly.

By the way, your edges are not out-of-flat due to "pucker" and"draw", they are out-of-flat due to the way SW calculatedtransforming your cut into sheet metal. A sheet metal cut edge hasto be perpendicular to the two faces at all points.
KL
KL 2009-02-16
I agree with Josh. Instead of the sketches use planes to makethe cuts. The planes can then be used to mate the parts.
SF
SF 2009-02-16

Kelvin Lamport wrote:

 

I agree with Josh. Instead of the sketches use planes to makethe cuts. The planes can then be used to mate the parts.

How do you use a plane to make a cut?
KL
KL 2009-02-17
Use theCut with surface tool using the plane as the'surface'.