Hello,
is there any possibility to prevent Dimensions within Drawings to be manually edited in Value, or to be colorized, when edited manually, respectively when Drawing dimension differs from model dimension.
We have some Users who sometimes edit Drawing dimensions manually, I think everyone here knows what Problems this entails. I am looking for a solution, as the Work-Instruction alone doesn't seem to be enough.
SolidworksDrawings And Detailing
The question has been asked here before, and I don't think anyone got a good answer. Someone may be able to write a macro that would go through all the dimensions in a Drawing and change the colors of all that were overridden.
As I've said on one or two of those other posts, you don't have a software problem, you've got a personnel problem.
Good point, Jim. I have seen it used for other purposes as well.
Yes, colors would be helpful.
I agree, an option is the way to go. Not sure if it should be a system option, or a document option. Also, I would like to have a local override option for each dimension for cases where I'm trying to do something else like mentioned.
I was a little hesitant about mentioning the design checker task in PDM. I haven't tried it yet and I don't know how it works. I expect there would be an output file somewhere that a user would have to read? I don't know, but it's a definite possibility.
Kill it with fire.
Fascist!
Although I support your cause.
Well then....here is a question:
Is there a process in place for the checking and approval of drawings?
If so, simply add the step that Design Checker be run on the drawing before it can be approved.
If not.....then you really have bigger problems.....(similar to here.....I have pushed for instituting a standard practice and even went so far as to write one.....however, getting anyone to use it is another story).
Looks like it isn't supported in PDM Standard, though...
Thanks Dan,
Looks like this is the way to catch it, automatically!
Javelin has a good bit of information on their website...
https://www.javelin-tech.com/blog/2019/03/solidworks-pdm-design-checker-task/
It looks like it can.
I completely agree and any change like this should always be an option not a system wide change that the user can't fix.
Part of the problem is that that Dimension Text box, in my mind should be two boxes. One for the dimension itself, and another for any additional information someone would want to provide...And, I'm not even suggesting that in certain circumstances it wouldn't be appropriate to override the dimension box.
Underlining the manually altered dimensions is better. You can't see a color change in a b&w pdf of the drawing. Honestly, this shouldn't even be a discussion. It's easy enough to change your features in a model. Just do it right in the first place. That way you don't have to worry about any goofy modifications that were done to the drawing. If your coworkers can't be trusted to make the changes properly, can you really trust them to underline the dimension or change it to a different color?
The 'Override' checkbox isn't just used for changing dimension values. It can be used to replace a value with something else, such as a letter on a tabulated drawing. I wouldn't want these underlined automatically:
I don't see any reason not to have some means of identifying these altered dimensions. My preference would be to have them as a different color (Tools>Options>Colors)...I like to set dangling dimensions to bright red, and I could see where others such as would really like those overridden dimensions to show up a bright color for quick easy identification. This seems that it would be trivial for the programmers to fix. Maybe could contact his VAR and have an SPR created on this.
The one thing I'd caution though is if underlining is the preference (which may be preferable, because in a printed drawing these dimensions would be much more readily identified than if they are a different color.) I'd recommend that it be implemented as an option, under either drawing or system options. I can see a lot of people being angry if all of the sudden their dimensions start showing up with underlines, when they are just adding comments and there's no way to get rid of the underline.
,
We don't have this problem, but if we did, I'd definitely look into making it part of the PDM workflow. Can Design Checker be made part of the PDM workflow? Maybe, when a drawing is checked in, it runs and will flag and possibly email someone the report? I'd guess it'd be possible through the API with EPDM, but we've just got PDM Standard here. But, I wonder if it could be done without programming?
The benefit of the above, is that now there's documentation of who is doing what and when.
ASME Y14.5 uses underlining to indicate a dimension that is not to scale - in SolidWorks case, it would be a manually overridden dimension. Maybe it would be cool if SolidWorks underlined these dimensions as soon as the user checked the "Override Value" box.
Design Checker. I was thinking the same thing, BUT...
you still need someone to remember to run the check/task and check the report. If they don't run it, they won't catch it.
Queue the appropriate Dilbert cartoon here.
Often the solution to incompetence is promotion.
...Move them out of a technical position before they do too much damage...
I was scrolling thru here to see if someone had mentioned this. This option with batch processing would be relatively easy. Just run every drawing by the offenders thru the checker and send them back to them to fix.
Let it go.
Do you wanna build a snow man?
WHY? i am not going to get dims of 50 purchased parts, and modify them to show an as built, and i am not going to modify the mates on every threaded connection, to do an as built. I will just do a save as on the drawing and detach it later if need be. Override dims, and let it go.
And that is why a lot of incompetent people are in management..... Watching how things operate here over the years, the guys that talk a lot, can worm their way into any situation, even if it doesn't concern them and then get control of an area that's either over their head or now with the added responsibility they can't keep up with it and if they screw up, they got the same perception, "Talk your way out of it"
We have two guys here in the office that actually take up to an hour explaining things from different angle that have nothing to do with the issue at hand, should have been a 5 minute explanation.....
Company "Workflow"
It will depend on management. Often they are right out of a Dilbert cartoon.
I've worked at places where management thought that the worst SolidWorks users were the best, simply because they were "team players" and worked lots of overtime.
The fact of the matter was they were working long overtime because it was necessary due to their incompetence. It simply took them way longer than necessary to get their jobs done, and had they bucked the system a bit by unlearning their bad habits and relearning how to properly use the software, then all of the overtime wouldn't be necessary.
Meanwhile, all the competent people that didn't cause any drama just seemed to fall under the radar.
This
Or Worse ???
Terminate with extreme prejudice.
Even then, making a configuration the way they built it is the way to go. Then make the drawing off of that.
Cure the problem quick fast and in a hurry, fire someone, and let everyone know why.
There was one place i worked where we used model dimensions for the parts and they would all come in black. any other dim would come in grey. Well one guy they hired to come in went threw all the trouble in the world to make a dim look like a driving dim on the drawing. I fought that thing for an hour when i had to go back and fix the problem that he did not fix.
The only time that i would say to OVER RIDE a dimension is when you are creating an as built drawing. your 3d model is what you want it to be, and the shop and other tolerances of the real parts have thrown some of the dimension off on the main assembly. I would not want to change the model, or even make a copy of it for that kind of update, so that would be the only reason i would ever consider over riding a dim.
I think everyone that's posted here understands the situation. Unfortunately, sometimes it is impossible to get people to see the light. I'll give an example from where I work...Here our structural group is still doing 2D CAD the same way as when I started 21 years ago, no references, 1 sheet per file, all annotations are on 1 layer. They are literally replicating what was done on the drafting board when the conversion was made to CAD before I started. I can explain until I'm blue in the face, but what they have is "working"...
I use that function often, but only to replace the dimension value with text; never to override the dimension.
Just found this.
You can use the Design checker to identify all dimensions with overridden values in a drawing:
2018 SOLIDWORKS Help - Dimension Checks
How to use the SOLIDWORKS Design Checker – Part 1 - Computer Aided Technology
It won't prevent it, but it is a way to find them relatively easily.
You can use a macro to highlight the dimension. A user can disable that.
You can add procedure for editing dimension.
Add note or Rev saying dimension is not to the model.
Edit PDF only and summit to design for update.
User can fail to follow that.
How many time could the user fail before getting fired?
& are correct. You need to get the supervisors on board with doing it right. Explain to them why this practice is dangerous, and get policy set. Is manually editing the dimension quicker? Sure. But changing the dim manually doesn't show any potential issues that may pop up because of that change. Then, if several dims are changed manually over several drawing revisions, you cannot be confident that the drawing accurately represents the part/assembly. Then when the parts are made, and they don't fit, the shop will say they were made to the print, and QA will verify that is so, and engineering will be standing there with egg of their faces, because they didn't do it right. This is bad enough in a shop where you're making consumer products, but if you're working on products that people's lives depend on, it's unacceptable. It amazes me that there isn't time to do things right, but somehow, there's time to fix it after it's become a problem.
In awareness of the "personnel problem" I already knew it was rather a rhetorical question, but as you might know, humans never give up to expect beeing positively surprised :-) But thanks for response. I just rememberred that in Creo/ProE there was a hidden config to show/highlight edited Dimensions, when they differed from Standardsettings, so I looked for a similar setting within Solidworks.
Unless the person "Over Rides" the dimension, which is what I think is referring to.. That is a disciplinary correction, not a SW responsibility issue... Overriding any "Dimension" should be removed from the Dimension Dialog Box, that is more of a problem then the "Drafts Persons"....
In that case a subtraction would be an addition..
John,
I do like the fact that it does change the colors of an edited dimension in the drawing when the model was modified. What Ricco was asking about is a color change if the dimension text was manually edited in the drawing & a different dimension text was put in. Almost like the 2d Autocad days when most users changed the dimension text rather than change the geometry to update the dimension. Really plays havoc with CNC programmers that rely on the models to program to. But like others have said that's a user problem that should be addressed. It's not that difficult to open a model & change things there like they should be.
I stand corrected, this may be a more correct answer than 's.
If it is explained in terms of the bottom line, the managers should get the message and correct their employees. Maybe some VAR training is in order...Or you could even get them involved to help support your case.
,
This is probably as close to a right answer as you are going to get. There are just so many circumstances that warrant adding text to dimensions, that you really don't want to "lock-down" dimensions to not be able to edit them.
You could have a policy of having model dimensions used as much as possible, and that could limit any editing...But, you're always going to need other dimensions added (it seems inevitable). But you could make model dimensions and reference dimensions different colors in your templates...That way suspect dimensions would stand out more.
Though, I agree with Glenn...My suggestions are band-aids, you really need to address the root problem.
I think that the simplest solution is some sort of disciplinary action for those people who are manually editing dimensions on the drawing. Or at the very least to pull a meeting with those people AND THEIR BOSSES and state the reasons that this is an unsafe practice and could cost the company a LOT of money.
Outside of that.....I got nothing for you other than to point your toward this thread:
It would be nice, but it's not possible to retain "Changed Dimensions" color.. That would be a great enhancement though
You can have the dimension colors set to show when they are changed, but they don't stay. It only shows up when you open the drawing right after a part dimension change has been made, but you can close the file and re-open and it's back to normal.