How to model this part in sw 2013

I know there are some sprs's about this error but some one has a solution to model the attached part and obtain correct flat pattern for each configuration.

The only solution that I found is to add smart dimension on edge sketch, but if the part has many edge flanges must add dimension on each one!!!

SolidworksSheet Metal
Answers 10
AP
AP 2013-08-29 Best Answer

No one is bothered by this sw 2013 sheet metal bug?! I'm the only one?

AP
AP 2013-08-29

No, it is about another bug. When you have a sheet metal part with 2 or more configuration and make a simple edge flange and we use outer virtual sharp (as measuring dimension o flange) you can not make different dimensions for each configuration. The part is not updating. I found two solution one is to add dimension on flange sketch and change this dimension for each configuration and the other one is to use tangent bends even the angle is 90 degrees.As I heard this bug is from 2012 sp05. In the attached part is an edge flange with with an angle smaller then 90 degrees so I can not use tangent bend I must dimension the sketch!

We just change the sw to 2013 and know I must explain to the designers that bought a new version but their work must be more complicated than in older one

RW
RW 2013-10-07

Welcome to the world of Solidworks. I know many more bugs/regressions from years

ago that also don't get fixed. You should test test and test before updating.

Bugs/regression can take years to fix. Sometimes they are called enhancerequests

after many years.

AP
AP 2013-10-08

I just received a message from SW KB related a SPR (about free version variable in EPDM). They "proudly" announced that is implemented but when in ... 2015 a1.

I don't know what to do to laugh or to be very angry.

Thanks a lot SW for your new features!

RW
RW 2013-10-08

I hope there will be a SW2015 and even then you will

have new discontinued basic functionalities.

We are still on SW2005,  I just tested SW2014 and again

we are dissappointed.

Why SW2005?

-option SW2005 "use last saved configuration" in standard

parts with configurations, this saves thousands mouseclicks a

day when using  a lot of standard part.

To change one standard part like a bearing that is used in several

subassemblies  is one mouseclick in SW2005.  In SW2014 you need

to search for every standard part and change it individually. This

was removed in SW2008 and I was told to submit an enhancerequest

at that time.

-No bugs in dimension edit menus not showing correctly when

Windows scaling is more than 155% on the latest hardware.

Yes, in SW2005 no bugs with the latest hardware while SW2014

has many problems on 2560x1440 and scaling > 155%.

-highlighting in SW2005 large assembly mode works very fast

and is configurable,  SW2014 is not and very slow. SW2014 causes

many misclicks because no highlighting in large assembly mode.

Apart from that when showing dimensions flat to screen since

SW2014 it needs about 3X more misclicks to edit a dimension,

selection just has a bug. I find myself having far too many

misclicks in SW2014, it just doesn't make sense.

-SW2005 is much faster on modern hardware, especially edit

part in large assemblies

-SW2005 colors of tree and background of tree configurable.

-SW2005 uses about 2-3 times less memory for the same assembly

after a couple of hours work. That also means that SW2005 stays

fast after a couple of hours while newer version need restarts of

Solidworks to keep it fast.

And many many more small things that suddenly work slower

or need more mouseclicks in newer versions. I am used to shortcuts

for almost every command so the S command doesn't help.

I know every new release was supposed to have a higher performance

and we carefully tested it but it almost never was faster. The fancy features

never were good enough to miss the basics that were better in SW2005.

We need the basics, not fancy features that look good in demonstrations.

All the lightweight and freeze options are useless in assemblies with

quite some in context features especially if the complete machine needs

to be shown.

It is true that SW2014 is faster but it is only faster than SW2013.

I consider SW2013 the slowest version ever.

We are seriously considering other option like Solid Edge, Inventor

Fusion, PTC Creo and even Ironcad. From what I have seen all have

their own advantages and disadvantages but they have all have

proper working direct modelling. I am sure feature based modelling

with history is necessairy next to explicit direct modelling, so Solid Edge,

Fusion and Ironcad are interesting for us.

We still have to see what this new direct modelling V6 from Dassault will bring. 

http://www.3ds.com/about-3ds/3dexperience-platform/

They are talking about "3D experience platform" all the time but I still

have to see what this experience will be for companies that don't design

airplanes or cars. We just have to finish a complex machine with as few

as possible time and mouseclicks in order to minimize the total cost

of CAD. They should think about the "Total cost of CAD" instead of "3D experience"

We don't need social media integrated in Cad, we just want

to spent as few time as possible on a Cad system.

I don't mind how nice these buttons look or what experience I will

have clicking that button. I just want to click on these buttons as

few as possible and never have commands that don't work anymore

after upgrading. It is all about the total cost of CAD and bugs that

take years to fix or discontinued basic functionality is an expensive

Cad system.  I don't mind if a Cad system costs 3 times as much

as Solidworks as long as the Total cost of CAD is less.

You have to realize that the cost of Solidworks is only about

50 hours of lost work because of inefficiencies. (80x50=4000)

If you can save 50 hours a year using a different CAD system

or even by using an older release that wasn't broken it is easy

to see that the price of a CAD program doesn't really matter as

long as it does what it is supposed to do. We think we can save

hundreds of hours in conceptual design using a direct modeller

that also has feature based modeling.

EK
EK 2013-10-21

Hello,

I just noticed that my templates don't show the multibody sheetmetal feature folder and the configurations do work properly (2013 file!!!!)

I will try to attach the file but can't find the attach button for some reason.

comment imagecomment image
DG
DG 2013-10-21
<p>I will try to attach the file but can't find the attach button for some reason.</p>

Please use "advanced editor" in case you want to attach any files. Click on reply and then click "use advanced editor".

comment imagecomment image
EK
EK 2013-10-21

Thanks Deepak,

Found it. Makes me wonder why the file attachment is hidden. The video and image attachment button are here by default but the file atttachment is advanced only. Who comes up with that. File attachment is as common as cereal breakfast!!?

GS
GS 2013-10-21

That's one of several changes made to the forum a while ago.  One of the others was having long discussions go to multiple pages, which makes them load much faster.  I assume the "Use advanced editor" change was for the same reason.