How do you add external threads that are not in the database

How do you add external threads that are not in the database.  Don't tell me Toolbox and create our own standard.  Those are for internal threads.

SolidworksGeneral
Answers 19
CC
CC 2011-02-08 Best Answer

Select the leading edge of the external thread.

Insert>Annotations>Cosmetic Thread

Then just fill in the details.

SF
SF 2011-02-08

Follow CBL's suggestion if you don't want to make you own new standard.  However, if you do want to add new options to your selection, you do have to add threads to the Toolbox hole wizard.  It's counter-intuitive, but it is the way to do it.

Matt Lorono

SF
SF 2011-02-08

That is for internal threads.  How does it distunguish between internal and external threads (ex. 2a or 2b) ?

SF
SF 2011-02-08

Since cosmetic threads rely on user inputted information, the user would have to determine what the callout would look like.  I've not used the thread callouts for external threads in SW.  But that is a good question.  Sounds like some experimenting is required unless someone regularly does this.

Matt Lorono

sw.fcsuper.com

SolidWorks Legion

Follow me on Twitter

SF
SF 2011-02-08

Kevin,

Just to be clear, the external threads options in the cosmetic thread command comes from the hole wizard.  Again, I know this is counter-intuitive.

Matt Lorono

sw.fcsuper.com

SolidWorks Legion

Follow me on Twitter

SF
SF 2011-02-08

Ok I get it about that.  But the data there is for internal threads.  If you review ASME B1.1  you will notice that the data for an internal thread is different than

the data for an external thread. So how can you create a external thread with internal data?

SF
SF 2011-02-09

After spending a few days looking for information like this myself, I found that SW is very limited in general. I could not find anything in reguarding adding anything new to external threads in the database. You just have to manually add them in the "none" specific area of what you want to call them. Pretty sad for what I though this program had everything and you can't add any other thread combinations. To bad our company's majority of the parts are external threads that are larger than 3 inches. ACHME, Butress etc. Manually doing them is what we have to do to even show them pretty sad.

SF
SF 2011-02-09

External cosmetic thread command does not create the external thread.  It only applies an annotation representation of the thread.  You still have to make the thread stud with a common extrude feature.  In this, no data about thread size (other than the root) is necessary.  Now, if the root diameter is wrong because it is based on the internal thread dimension, then that should be addressed.  However, it is still just an annotation, so just an approximation that isn't useful within the design anyway.

That said, I have been asking for an actual external thread feature in SolidWorks for years (two articles where I mention them):

External Threads in SoldWorks (where are they?)

Plug for enhancement requests

The issue got good attention during the SolidWorks World 2011 Top Ten voting, though I submitted it to late to get enough attention to be in the final top ten.

Matt Lorono

sw.fcsuper.com

SolidWorks Legion

Follow me on Twitter

SM
SM 2011-02-09

I like charles just created the hole and inputs the required thread data.

RW
RW 2011-02-09

I create another database under Options, Hole Wizard/Toolbox, Configure.  I added one for Fine Threads that some of our sensors have.

KL
KL 2011-03-25

Matt,

Have you added new thread sizes to the HW?

Do those new sizes show up in the external Cosmetic Thread dropdown list?

They don't in mine. 

KL
KL 2011-03-25

Never mind!

After multiple closing and re-openings of SW, and several reboots, SW finally decided to give in and show the new custom sizes in the dropdown list.

I guess, all I needed to do was send an email to my VAR asking them how to do it. As soon as I sent the email, the sizes appeared.

DG
DG 2011-03-26
<p>Kelvin Lamport wrote:</p><p></p><p>I guess, all I needed to do was send an email to my VAR asking them how to do it. As soon as I sent the email, the sizes appeared.</p><p></p><p><span __jive_emoticon_name="confused"></span></p>

Looks like the file got afraid of being operated on by your VAR

SM
SM 2011-03-26

Ralph,

That is an interesting approach.  Never thought about that one.  Thanks for the tip.

SF
SF 2011-08-25

No one really answered the question.  We are working around it.

DG
DG 2011-08-25

If you have searched, you would have found this: Re: Adding a custom thread type.

SF
SF 2012-04-25

Yes I believe that is the best approach yet.  I use ASME B1.1 information.

The Toolbox settings>>Customize your hardware>>Create a new Database>> And add information needed.

Just make sure you have accurate info if your parts are CMTR. 

SF
SF 2012-04-26

I was not satisfied with that brief information.

JK

RW
RW 2012-04-27

Kevin

I wrote a Step-by-Step Instruction for adding Custom Threads.  Deepak Gupta has given you the link above.  If there is something that you need explained, I will explain what you need.  This will add Internal and External Threads.