hey all! need help with my gears.

i calculted well the Modul of those two gears, but it still collision, how can i fix it?

thanks!

SolidworksParts And Features
Answers 8
TP
TP 2011-06-03 Best Answer

You forgot to post the gears

SF
SF 2011-06-03

yes, problem with the uploading.

SM
SM 2011-06-03

Ori,

You might want to be more specific.  Also check out some of the postings

under the "More like this"  section to the right and see if there are other

threads that help you.

SF
SF 2011-06-03

i'm trying to explain my problem in the most  accurate way which i can be.

which details i might add?

SF
SF 2011-06-03

Your explanation is good, from what I see you have two different teeth patterns and may even have a pitch issue.

My experience would dictate that both the large and small gear should have the same tooth pattern and pitch. The large gear has a smaller tip and fatter body then the small gears teeth, if both were the same then all you would have to do is make the pitch the same.

Fun part is getting the gear ratio to be what you need it to be after that. I find this to be easiest by using teeth count as opposed to fancy math. Find a pitch by using a common multiplier (say 20 on the small and 100 on the large, 100 is divided by 20, 5 20's make 100, 5:1 ratio)

All the fancy math does is give me a headache.....

Hope this helps.

RB
RB 2011-06-03

It may be an illusion generated by your image, but like Chris said, it looks like the gear profiles on the two gears are different.  If the profile is incorrect, it won't matter if you have your modulus correct.  How did you generate the shape of the gears and how important is it to have an accurate gear profile?  I have found generating gears from the toolbox works most of the time.  However, keep in mind that the gears in the toolbox aren't "correct" gear profiles and may still generate some collisions.  Last time I had to draw a true gear profile I calculated points in another program, plotted those points in a SW sketch and then connected the dots.  The equation driven curve feature might be able to draw a correct involute gear profile, but I haven't tried it.

SM
SM 2011-06-04

Ori,

You are fine now.  I posted that before you posted your image and what you said

without the image made it difficult to diagnose.  Have you looked into the interference

detection inside of Solidworks?


http://help.solidworks.com/2011/english/SolidWorks/sldworks/AllContent/SolidWorks/Core/Assemblies/HIDD_DVE_INTERFERENCE.htm

They also have the zebra stripes that sometimes help in detecting interferences.


http://help.solidworks.com/2011/English/SolidWorks/sldworks/LegacyHelp/Sldworks/Display/Zebra_Stripes_on_Boundaries.htm

It definately looks as though your gear teeth are different, which doesn't exactly mean they are wrong.

Where I used to work we had a designated gear design program that we did all of our gears on.

It did a pretty extensive job on them and would show the interferences similar to cosmos and would do

stress analysis on them.

Here is a  link to a free download if you want to check it out.


http://www.gearcalc.com/download.htmlhttp://www.gearcalc.com/download.html

SF
SF 2011-06-09

I've been using the attached model to "start" gears for a while.  Just tweaked a few things.  The gear tooth is controlled by custom properties.  Only 5 properties are used to define the entire gear tooth profile:

  1. Pitch Diameter
  2. Diametial Pitch
  3. Pressure Angle
  4. Number of teeth
  5. Backlash

Enter the desired parameters, click OK, and rebuild.

The tooth profile is NOT an involute.  It is a circular arc, but at the pitch circle, is correct.  The rest of the tooth profile deviates from actual, and you may still see some interferences due to that.  You have to put in values for custom propterties that are "meaningful".  I can have SW create a model with 4" pitch circle, 8 diametral pitch, and 100 teeth, but it is physically meaningless.  Also, the non-standard gears that this makes have thin cuts in addition to thin teeth.  Thin teeth only would be more accurate, to allow engagement to a standard mated gear.