Graphics shuts off when opening or switching parts

I have frequent system lockups that require a hard reboot.  It seems to only occur when opening or switching parts.  The screens just go black as the video signal goes away.  The CPU still seems to be running, but the keyboard does not appear to respond (hard to tell with no graphics).  The only way I have found to work is a hard power button for 5 seconds reboot.

I have a Dell Precision 6500 with a dual-core i7 CPU with 8 Gbytes RAM.  The graphics is Nvidia Quadro FX 2800M.  I am running 64-bit XP.  I use a docking station with two screens at work, and the laptop by itself at home.  The problem happens both places, possibly worse at home.  We have other people using the same V11 SW on the same hardware with no problem.  My machine only appears to crash when running SolidWorks, and then only when opening or switching parts.  It is hard to believe it is hardware related, but possible I suppose.

Is anyone else having this issue?  This is a serious issue, causing as many as 6 crashes a day.

SolidworksAssemblies
Answers 43
SF
SF 2011-09-20 Best Answer
WD
WD 2011-10-24

I am having the same issue. I am using a Dell Precision M6500 also with 64-bit XP. It seems to be getting worse. I am using two screens and both screens go black. It only happens when I am doing something in SolidWorks. The CPU is still running because I could still hear music coming from my headphones. I have tried upgrading and downgrading drivers. I installed the latest 5.0 SP, undocking, running only laptop screen. I have ran out of ideas and I am starting to think it is a problem with the PC itself. It only happens while running SolidWorks, so I am a little hesitant to blame the PC.

TG
TG 2011-10-24

I looked at the other posts concerning Black Death, but I have not resolved my issue either.  I did not try wiping everything clean, but I did reload my video driver.  I am still on SP4.  My crashing is managable for the most part.  Sometimes it goes two days, sometimes two hours.  I did complete a large project recently, and did seem to find that if I had a drawing open, and switching parts to and from the drawing, I had no problem.  The project had about 120 details, and I don't think it ever occurred switching to and from the drawing.  I am not sure it ever occurred with a drawing open, but I won't swear to that.

I have had it happen a couple of times when only using the laptop, with SW running but in the background.  I don't remember what was in the foreground, probably Outlook or Internet Explorer.  I did use the PC for nearly a day without SW running, and had no crash, but that is not statistically significant.  I use SW so much that I cannot really test that.  It certainly seems to be triggered by opening or switching parts in SW.

I also am starting to think it is hardware.  I am waiting for enough time to call my hardware support people since that will likely cause me to be without the computer for a while.

SF
SF 2011-10-24

Hmm graphics card most likely. It is a really good card, but if you updated the graphics card recently it may be an issue. you can rollback the graphics card and see if it helps.

TG
TG 2011-10-24

I am using the original graphics driver.  I only reloaded the same driver to try to avoid this issue.

KL
KL 2011-10-24

The original driver loaded by Dell may not be suitable for SW.  Is it the 6.14.12.5729 driver as recommended on the SW site?


http://www.solidworks.com/downloads/videocarddriver/dell/nVidia_multi-device_XP64_257.29_R283418.exe

TG
TG 2011-10-24

Yes, I have 6.14.12.5729.  I was thrilled when my new laptop was delivered with the recommended video driver back in January.  It worked fine with SW2010.  The problem started a few months ago after I upgraded to 2011sp4.

WD
WD 2011-10-24

I also have 6.14.12.5729 and I believe my problem started after installing 2011sp4. That was why I was hoping that sp5 would fix the problem, but it did not. I am stumped on this one.

KL
KL 2011-10-25

Have you tried the latest driver from the nVidia site?

WD
WD 2011-10-25

I did try the latest from the nVidia site (6.14.12.6658), but when it did not help my problem I went back to the SW suggested driver 6.14.12.5729.

RN
RN 2011-11-03

Same exact problem here.

Multiple systems with no issues and two that seam to get worse every day (one being mine!).

Driver is 6.14.12.5729

WD
WD 2011-11-07

My issue seems to be very sporadic. I can go (2) days without an issue, then all of a sudden (9) times in a day.

TG
TG 2011-11-07

Very similar for me.  Last week, I think I had 3 days with no issue, 1 one day, 2 another day.  I am not positive, but having a drawing open and switching from drawing to part and back, I don't think it has ever happened for me.

I truly think this is probably an interaction between defective hardware and specific software commands in SW.  It seems limited to a few people with specific hardware, but only a small subset of those people, and it only happens at specific moments in the program.

WD
WD 2011-11-23

Has anyone found a fix for this? It seems to be getting worse now on my machine. It is happening 6-10 times a day.

AW
AW 2011-11-24

Is your system over heating?  When was the last time you cleaned out the fans in your laptop?

I am thinking faulty or over heating gpu.

Get the Dell techs to check out your system.

Cheers,

Anna

WD
WD 2011-11-28

I have tried blowing it out with air which did not seem to help anything. It has done it right after booting up first thing in the morning, so I have ruled out the heating issue. My last resort is to turn my laptop over to our IT department, but I know I will be without a machine for 3-5 days. We have a very small IT department for such a big company. Since it only does it when I am running Solidworks, I was hoping someone else on this site might have figured out how to fix it.

SF
SF 2011-11-28

I have a M6500 with a FX 3800M Graphics Card. I have been plagued also by the same issues.

Without doubt, it is the graphics card, and you need to get it replaced. You'll have to call Dell and get them to give you a replacement graphics card. Fingers crossed you'll get a new (not refurb) graphics card, and that'll sort it.

Dell have been out to me over a dozen times. After the first series of callouts by Dell, I got a replacement (refurb!) graphics card, which worked ok. That was on Vista x64. In SW2012 the Ambient Occlusion crashed the graphics immediately. I moved to Win 7 x64, where the Ambient Occlusion crashed the graphics again. However, it also started to crash when I was browsing the web on IE8. I got a replacement card there a month ago, and it was ok, until last week, where it started black screening again ;-(

I could write a book with the problems I've had.

The only solution is to get a new graphics card from Dell. This is a hardware issue with the graphics card.

P.S. its not heat related. I ran a fur benchmark for days and it didn't crash. It appears to be specific hardware acceleration commands (from SW, IE8, Windows 7 and other programs that use the hardware graphics) that knock the graphics out. PPS. lights on keyboard will stay on, and you may be able to ping the computer and do remote desktop.

WD
WD 2011-12-05

Update: This problem only occurs when I am running on A/C power. It never happens when I am running on battery only. So, at least I have kind of a work around for now.

SF
SF 2011-12-05

Kudos Wade. I have just confirmed your workaround.  ->  When running on battery, the graphics does not black out.

When running on A/C, the graphics black out. I can test and replicate this by using RealView and Ambient Occlusion.

I tried on A/C with the battery removed from the M6500, but the graphics blacked out.

Now to see if there is some power setting.

WD
WD 2011-12-05

I have been researching this issue online this morning and there were quite a few people who are saying there issue was fixed by doing the following steps:

1. UNPLUG THE POWER

2. REMOVE BATTERY

3. HOLD POWER BUTTON FOR 30/60 SECONDS (THIS REMOVES THE EXCESS POWER FROM THE MACHINE)

4. REATTACH POWER AND START THE LAPTOP

5. SHUT BACK DOWN

6. PUT IN THE BATTERY

7. THATS IT

I have not had a chance to try this yet to confirms this works, but I will get around to it sometime today.

SF
SF 2011-12-05

No dice. Tried the above steps exactly, holding down power button to remove excess power.

I also tried a 120W power adapter (from an old M90), and while the system booted ok (albeit warning me about the wrong power, which should be a 220W), the graphics went blank. I remove the battery, and just used the 120W power adapter, and it still crashed.

I also tried setting power options in Windows 7 for PCIexpress to be maximum power savings when plugged in. Graphics still crashed.

I tried setting Standard charge instead of rapid charge in the Bios. No effect.

The only method which works is removing the A/C and the graphics works ok, with no crash.

WD
WD 2011-12-05

From what I remember reading about this, a larger power adapter is what dell gives for fixing this problem. I read that it was a design mistake with the wrong amount of power alloted for each core and instead of fixing the machines, dell is sending a larger power adapter to fix the problem. This is only what I read in an internet thread, so take it with a grain of salt.

So far I have not had a crash with the a/c plugged in after performing the following steps:

  1. I shut down the laptop and pulled the battery out.
  2. I then held down the power button for a good 60-90 seconds.
  3. I put the battery in and started up with battery only.
  4. I then did a hard shut down by holding the power button down. (again for around 60 seconds)
  5. I then hooked the A/C adapter back up and rebooted.

I have been running for about an hour on A/C power without a crash, but I am not feeling too confident about this working.

I will let you know if/when I crash.

TG
TG 2011-12-05

I am skeptical because I am pretty sure I have had the black screen on battery power at least once.  I have also just run the procedure, and will let you know the results.

SF
SF 2011-12-05

Well I can easily reproduce the graphics hang by:

New Part. Extrude Simple Block. Change material to brass. Turn on Ambient Occlusion. Rotate a little. Graphics crash.

On Battery only, I can't crash the graphics.

@Wade: Very interesting to hear about the new A/C. I know I have the slimline power adapter for the M6500 here.

Thanks for the feedback and input from everyone here

WD
WD 2011-12-05

The procedure of holding the power button down to drain the power did not work.

The only fix for me is to work on battery power only. I would like to get a hold of another power adapter.

AW
AW 2011-12-05

Guys,

Bummer about the graphics.....  But it is good to hear you have found the cause of it.

I wonder if you could adjust some Power settings in the Windows Control Panel to help.  Maybe turn down the power the cpu's can use when AC powered.

Cheers,

Anna

RN
RN 2011-12-05

I took note of my card temp as 75 degrees C (plugged in). Note sure if this was hot, so I tried battery only. The result was a temp of 65 degrees C. I was able to work for several hours in this mode. Great! Well not so Great, got the Black Screen again.

Exchanged my laptop for a new one with a Quadro FX 2800M, problem resolved. Temp is at 51 C.

Find card temp in:

NVIDIA Control Panel>Workstation>View system topology (then select "more" in the right column)

TG
TG 2011-12-05

For the record, my graphics is the Nvidia Quadro FX 2800M.  My current temp is 56C.

SF
SF 2011-12-05

Right...I've gotten somewhere.

I've installed NVidia PowerMizer, downloaded from http://somemorebytes.com/wp/index.php/software/nvpmmanager/

(I tried an older PowerMizer app which didn't work)

Follow the instructions as on the second post on:

http://en.community.dell.com/support-forums/laptop/f/3518/t/19336090.aspx?PageIndex=34

See attached screenshot of the settings I have.

It didn't crash after my typical test cases (RV and AO). Now, for a full test day tomorrow. /me crosses fingers

comment imagecomment image
TG
TG 2011-12-05

I performed the power down/remove battery sequence above this morning.  I worked for a while with no trouble.  I tried the sure-fire crash method of Mr. Burke, but I did not crash.  I opened some more files, and was beginning to get some work done, and the graphics locked up again (black screen, no video on either screen).

I am pretty uncomfortable installing the PowerMizer Manager stuff.  Is this safe?  Will it accomplish anything?

BTW, my power supply is the Dell 210W lump that come with the computer or docking station.  DA210PE1-00

SF
SF 2011-12-05

@Tim:

It appears that the PowerMizer Manager exe just adds entries to the registry. It gives a list of all registry changes it makes. I'll know more tomorrow if it fully worked, but I am confident.

If you are very paranoid, you could run a process monitor (http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/bb896645) to log exactly what the PowerMizer program does.

As for my power supply, I've attached an image.

@Wade: I'd be interested to know what new Power supply you have received. Did you get it off Dell for this graphics issue? If so, and if it fully resolves your issue, it might be worth me trying to get it off Dell.

comment imagecomment image
WD
WD 2011-12-06

Stephen, the power adapter in your picture is the original one I had. I got a big "brick" that is made by Dell from one of my coworkers. Anyway I thought it fixed my problem, but after 3 hours my graphics blacked out again.

i am thinking about installing the Powermizer software. I remember reading about it last week on an internet thread, but I was hesitant to download it. I am now thinking of installing it tomorrow morning. I noticed there were (3) different downloads on the powermizer site. Do I need to install all (3) or just the first one?

SF
SF 2011-12-06

@Wade: Sorry to hear the bigger power adapter didn't work. On a positive, my graphics has not crashed after running the powermizer (still some more testing to do, but its looking good). The standalone exe at: http://somemorebytes.com/wp/wp-content/plugins/download-monitor/download.php?id=1 will suffice.

Only for yourself spotting that it didn't crash on battery, I wouldn't have investigated this as much. So, thanks very much.

WD
WD 2011-12-07

Well thanks to you Stephen for getting involved with me on this issue.

So far so good on the powermizer fix. I created a system resore point and then did the install. I then tried to make my graphics crash the way I can always make it crash and it did not crash. I believe you and I were having the exact same problem. So lets keep our finger crossed and if you don't hear back from me you will know the problem has gone away.

TG
TG 2011-12-07

Well, I installed the PowerMizer Manager, and set the settings as suggested.  So far it has been 2 days without BSOD, which while not proof is good evidence.  BTW, graphics card is at 42C vs 56C before.

This is not a fix, but a work-around for an obviously defective graphics card.  To limit the graphics performance to cover the defect is a bit lame, but is sure beats the crashes.  Knock on wood...

Thanks for the tip.

AW
AW 2011-12-08

I would venture to guess it is not a defective graphics card, but a poor packaging of the chip on the motherboard by Dell.

It is not getting adequate cooling.  That is Dell's fault with their motherboard design.

FWIW,

Anna 

TG
TG 2011-12-13

Well, it has been a week of fairly heavy Solidworks use, and no black screens.  I guess the PowerMizer Manager did the trick.  My temperatures vary from low 40s up to about 53C.  It seems to work at 53C and crash at 56C.  I still don't like using unsupported software, and I don't like slowing down the graphics.

I had another problem that I think is related to the PowerMizer Manager.  I went to use the laptop away from the dock, and the screen was black.  In very bright light I could see that the desktop was visible, but the backlight did not come on. I tried several times with nothing. I could not coax any light at all. I thought my backlight was broken, and was going to get it fixed. One last time while in the dock, I got the laptop screen to come on using the Nvidia Control Panel.  I am guessing it is related to the PowerMizer Manager, but I don't know exactly how.  I did set the PowerMizer Manager to auto for battery power, since that did not seem to have an issue, and I thought it might affect the backlight when undocked.  So far, so good...

Thank you all for your help.  If we can conclude this, it seems that some Nvidia graphics chips run hot in the Dell Precision 6500s.  The design is marginal, and most are on the good side, but some get too hot.  The PowerMizer Manager allows setting the accelleration down to a level that keeps the marginal machines below the critical temperature.  The only true solution is to swap motherboards for one that is on the good side of marginal.

TG
TG 2012-02-09

Just an update. I used SolidWorks heavily for almost 2 months with no black screens. I did sometimes have some difficulty recognizing my two screens from the dock when re-docking, that sometimes required a reboot to fix. I suspect that the PowerMizer Manager is involved in that, but no proof. I turned off the PowerMizer Manager, going back to normal set-up, and got the black screen within 2 hours. My temp was back to about 56-57C. I turned it back on, and no black screen since.

PB
PB 2012-11-13

Just found this relatively old post while searching for black screen issues related to my Dell M6500.  Seems I am now having the same problems described here.  It is not related to SW, as I have had it happen while working in various applications.  It seems to always happen when I am working on the machine though (as opposed to hands off.)  I've had this M6500 for probably three years now and this is a relatively new issue.  I'm thinking hardware...

TG
TG 2012-11-13

Paul, sorry to hear you are having trouble.  I suggest you monitor the temperature of your graphics chip using the NVIDIA Control Panel (right-click on the desktop) under Workstation-View system topology-more.  Mine crashes when it gets above 54 degrees.  You may be doing some other activity that uses the graphics, causing it to warm up, or your chip is just more marginal.  Mine may have crashed once not using SolidWorks, but other hard use.  I think it is definitely hardware, as several of my colleagues do not have the problem with identical machines.

PB
PB 2012-11-13

Thanks for the tip.  I had downloaded Piriform Speccy to monitor temperatures (becasue I didn't know that you could do it through the NVIDIA control panel.)  Speccy is pretty nice at tracking all sorts of info.  I wish it would log tempertures though so I could review after a 'black screen event' occurred.  Otherwise, you have to just monitor the temp manually.  The problem happens infrequently enough that it is hard to do that.

I'll let you know if I come across any other info.

PB
PB 2012-11-13

I came across another tool called TechPowerUp GPU-Z, which does allow file logging of temperatures.  So I set it up and will wait for the next black screen. 

By the way, my NVIDIA Quadro FX2800M seems to be running between 58C and 61C, but I'm not using it heavily at the moment.     

TG
TG 2012-11-13

Sounds like you may have another problem causing the heat.  My office is pretty cool right now, and I am not using SW much (open but not in use right now), and my chip is 45 degrees.