File Size and different features to accomplish the same thing??

Ok, we have Part files with any number of Configurations.

On each configuration there is a need for certain text to be shown on the part, replicating a stamping or engraving.

Is the a file size savings between having (25) Extrude Cuts for the different text required vs. (25) Wraps with the Scribe Option?

In each instance we would have a maximum of (3) characters per feature.

Would there be any noticible difference or would it basically be a wash?

Thank you in advance for your opinion.

Alan

SW2009 SP5.1 32x Windows XP

SolidworksParts And Features
Answers 10
GH
GH 2010-07-22 Best Answer

btw i like your tags..

Without testing i would say that the wrap feature would increase file size more.

CC
CC 2010-07-22

I am going to disagree with Greg.

Scribing text with the wrap tool should decrease file size (probably).

It will definitely decrease rebuild times.

Creating the edges of the extrude, as well as calculating the end conditions will take extra rebuild time. It also builds additional faces that have to be saved with the model, which will also increase file size. So that is what I would expect. Does the "wrap" tool in general take more space than extrudes? I don't know.

Another question though, why are you comparing extrude-cut vs wrap with scribe? Extrude-cut is for flat faces, while wrap is for cylindrical/conical. If you want to "scribe" onto a flat surface, use the Insert>Curve>Split line tool to create the engraving. If you want to extrude on a cylinder use the wrap>de-boss option.

SF
SF 2010-07-22

Charles,

Git 'er done attitude I suppose.

What I inherited vs. what I would have a tendency to do.

I am trying to gauge if it would be worth while to go back and touch the existing files that we re-use often to 'streamline" them for future use.

PM
PM 2010-07-22

I'd like to also add the fact that you should test out your wrap-scribe / split line options for your drawings (assuming you are going to do a drawing)  Sometimes I have had issues getting the "lines" to show up even with the Tangent Lines Visible option on.

Also, you should push to upgrade to 2010 as you can control your text with a custom property/DT with only one feature.

GH
GH 2010-07-22

i am hanging my head.......

PM
PM 2010-07-23

Alan,

  FWIW I just had to put markings on a part and looking at the feature stats for my text of two rows of numbers in the format:  ##-#####

Wrap Feature: 3.84 (s) (deboss 0.1 depth)

Cut Extrude:    1.13 (s) (0.1 depth)

I can't use split line or scribing because I need the text in my non-shaded drawing. But just to see what it would be I did them anyway:

my scribe option for wrap was 3.59 (s) and 1.49 (s) for a split line

so it looks like a Cut Extrude in this case wins for rebuild times.

SF
SF 2010-07-23

Charles,

Actually, Wrap is very useful for putting multiple profile shapes on to a flat face. Split Line won't do it with more than one profile.

It has always frustrated me that there is one tool, Split Line, that does a single profile on to multiple faces and another tool, Wrap that does multiple profiles on to a single face. What I really want is one tool that does multilple profiles on to multiple faces.

Jerry Steiger

SF
SF 2010-07-26

Paul,

Looking at feature statisics on a legacy part (Extrude Cut) and a "fresh" part (Wrap), I have to agree with your findings.

The Extrude Cut vs. the Wrap feature

Extrude Cut 42.47percent .09 sec               Wrap 39.49 percent .20 sec

Main Sketch 21.46 percent .05 sec             Main Sketch 18.09 percent .09 sec

______________________________            ______________________________

                    63.93 percent .14 sec                                57.58 percent .29 sec.

So the Exturde Cut in this case is a higher percent than the Wrap, it is also more than twice as quick. The Exturde Cut part has 61 features and a total rebuild time of .22 seconds, while the Wrap part has only 36 features and a rebuild time of .51 seconds.

Opposite of what I would have expected really.

Thank you all.

comment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment image
CC
CC 2010-07-26

Let me clarify my statement too. You both are comparing wrap+deboss with extrude-cut. I will agree that wrap+deboss will take longer to rebuild. My statement is that wrap+scribe will theoretically cause a much quicker rebuild. I suggest testing that on your actual part for a comparison.

SF
SF 2010-07-26

Charles,

The times shown in the stats above are a Wrap Scribe as stated in the initial post.

<p></p><p>Is the a file size savings between having (25) Extrude Cuts for the  different text required vs. (25) Wraps with the Scribe Option?</p>

Is there another way to test the rebuild time?

Wrap - Deboss times shown below.

comment imagecomment image