I thought I'd start a new thread regarding the proper way touse dual dimensions on drawing. First off, I strongly dislike dualdimensions, but the company I'm contracting for insists my drawingsconform to their company standard. My hands are tied, though I willquestion their decision for using them...
So, I understand now, though I had not previously given it anythought, how dual dimensions create contradictory specifications.Simple example- You have ".039/.035 [1/0.9]" on a drawing- the partcomes in at .0393", do you reject it? it's outside of the .039",but still inside of 1mm (which is approximately .03937"). Is thereany precedence for calling out the alternate units as reference?That would indicate that the inspector should inspect the parts tothe primary units, and ignore the tolerance on the alternate unit.
I can see why some companies use them. Most US CNC machines alloperate in inches. Most of the tooling available in the US is madein inches (end mills, drills, reams, etc..). So, if you give amachinist a drawing in mm, you are forcing them to convert unitswhich costs time (which = \\\$\\\$).
BM
SolidworksDrawings And Detailing
So, I understand now, though I had not previously given it anythought, how dual dimensions create contradictory specifications.Simple example- You have ".039/.035 [1/0.9]" on a drawing- the partcomes in at .0393", do you reject it? it's outside of the .039",but still inside of 1mm (which is approximately .03937"). Is thereany precedence for calling out the alternate units as reference?That would indicate that the inspector should inspect the parts tothe primary units, and ignore the tolerance on the alternate unit.
I can see why some companies use them. Most US CNC machines alloperate in inches. Most of the tooling available in the US is madein inches (end mills, drills, reams, etc..). So, if you give amachinist a drawing in mm, you are forcing them to convert unitswhich costs time (which = \\\$\\\$).
BM
SolidworksDrawings And Detailing

DIMENSIONS ARE IN INCHES [mm]
MILLIMETER UNITS FOR REF. ONLY
But soon you will get plenty of comments telling you what we do iswrong
I agree Charles,
Secondary units should be considered reference. Inspection shouldbe done to the primary units only. If there is a deviation toeither one of these statements, then a deviation would need to bespecified in the company procedure for Dual Dimensioning.
Barna,
As I suggested to you before, you need to get the company procedurefrom the company you are contracting for as there isn't anycommercial, industry or military specification to follow.
We can make all knids the suggestions but in the end, a companyprocedure is what you must follow and what we have to say may becontradicted.
We also put a note on the drawing stating the primary and secondarydimensions. Design is done in the primary dimensions.
"Most US CNC machines all operate in inches. Most of the toolingavailable in the US is made in inches (end mills, drills, reams,etc..). "
Actually most, (if not all), CNC machines are made overseas andall the machinist/programer has to do is flip to metric. They arejust more comfortable working in inches.
You can get virtually any tool in metric as they are all madeoverseas also.
Specific factory tooling is another matter all together, all ofour tooling here is designed in inches. As we produce more and moremetric product we are slowly switching in house tooling to metric.
we will be forced to go all metric in the not too distant future,YAY!
Regards,
B.B.
Tony,
When we convert we use this method also, the only problem is thatyour tolerance zone is smaller. It will always work but you losetolerance.
Bob,
You're right, on most machnes it is merely a flip of the switch.The bigger issue is tools, fixtures, gages, etc., that are allimperial. To duplicate your existing imperial tooling is a costlyrequirement.
We are going through that painful experience as we speak.
Best Regards
B. B.
I'm getting accustomed to thier way of doing things. Right now I'mstill working out how to make a drawing cluttered w/ dual dimensioncome out clean and understandable. It definately takes up a lot ofroom on the drawings.
I've seen some of thier older drawings and they were all in inchdimensinos. Maybe dual dimension is their baby step towards goingall metric. All (well, most) of their products are accessoried thatwill end up on other products that were all designed in metricunits, so it just makes sense.
BM
If anyone has ANSI or ISO standard to quote on the matter, it wouldbe helpful.
Meanwhile, I suggest a note like Mr. Culp uses.
Roland,
Thatis the problem, there isn't a current standard.
My last suggestion on the topic would be to go to the ASME or IHSwebsite and buy the last standard that covered Dual Dimensions,ASME Y14.5 1973 @ 50 bucks, it may be worth it.
Barna Madau wrote:
I can see why some companies use them. Most US CNC machines alloperate in inches. Most of the tooling available in the US is madein inches (end mills, drills, reams, etc..). So, if you give amachinist a drawing in mm, you are forcing them to convert unitswhich costs time (which = $$).
BM
The ASME 14.5M discourages the use of dual dimensioning by omitting it from the standard.
The ASME 14.100 4.30 states that brackets are for internal information such as processes.
A derived and rounded secondary dimension will, I believe, have to be indicated as reference. Solidworks, and other CAD, use brackets without a clear standard statement for guidance. There is no option for reference parenthesis on dual dimension display. People do create a parentheses enclosed dimension with a text line in the dimension edit area.
There may be an Enhancement Request for this. I will check.