Converting Assembly to Part

In this video a gear is placed in void assembly file from the design library and converted it into part file. What is the reason for that?  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F2sKs0YmM_w

Time 0.53 – 4.16

SolidworksAssemblies
Answers 18
JM
JM 2017-01-03 Best Answer

His technique for divorcing a part from the Toolbox as a base solid.

MN
MN 2017-01-03

Why can’t place the gear from the design library straight away in the Part file?

One thing I noticed gear is mated with assembly origin plane before it is converted into part file. What is the reason for that?   

JM
JM 2017-01-03

Q1. If a part is mated to the assembly origin in an assembly - where is it in space?

Q2. If a part is not mated to the assembly origin in an assembly - where is it in space?

WP
WP 2017-01-04

I'm not sure if I remeber correctly (don't use toolbox parts) but I think you can only put toolbox parts into assembly, I don't think you can insert them straight into the part - which would explain why he did it this way.

CORRECTION

Just checked - you can insert part from toolbox directly to part but it makes derived part and in the process it doesn't give you an option to configure it's size, etc.

MN
MN 2017-01-04

Q1. If a part is mated to the assembly origin in an assembly - where is it in space?

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Part is on the assembly origin. Part origin coordinate and assembly origin coordinate is (0, 0, 0). Both are same.

Q2. If a part is not mated to the assembly origin in an assembly - where is it in space?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Part is at anywhere in space. Part origin coordinate is (X, Y, Z) with reference to assembly origin.

JM
JM 2017-01-04

Q3.  So is it better logic to know exactly where your part is relative to (0,0,0) (the BORN Technique) for ease in modeling and in assembly with other parts, or is it better logic to have the part floating around in space where perhaps extra workplanes or some other extra work might be needed to add shaft or other features to the gear or to constrain in the assembly (trick question)?

MN
MN 2017-01-05

I noticed part has symmetry with its origin plane if part file is created after mating with origin plane of the assembly file. And part does not have symmetry with its origin plane if part file is created without mating with origin plane of the assembly file.

But “symmetry” word was not mentioned in your post.

 

comment imagecomment imagecomment imagecomment image
JS
JS 2017-01-05

Trying to figure out the logic of why you want to pull a Toolbox part into another part, I know you're trying to learn and I think you are making great progress based on your other posts, you're learning and that's what counts, keep it up 

Are you trying to make a new part or are you trying to put together a piece of machinery?  

MN
MN 2017-01-05

I have seen many YouTube videos. In those videos toolbox part is placed in part file then it is convert into regular part file. But only in this video toolbox part is placed in void assembly file then it is converted into part file. What is the reason for that?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F2sKs0YmM_w

Time 0.53 – 4.16     

JS
JS 2017-01-05

I can't get into youtube from here, it settings........  I would ask the same question, why???

WP
WP 2017-01-05

As mentioned before, just looked on that video, I belive he is putting it into the assembly so he can configure it's size/module/etc (which u can't do inserting derived toolbox part into part).

But if he is doing an assembly of gearbox - still can't see why he needs to save the separately - it could all be in the assembly.

JS
JS 2017-01-05

Sometimes there are better ways to paddle a boat, but I question that one..  

MN
MN 2017-01-05

Only thing I can come to a conclusion is:

If toolbox part is placed in a void assembly file and mate with assembly origin plane and converted it into part file, then part has a symmetrical property with it's origin plane. Otherwise no.

I do not know whether I am correct. I want someone to confirm it. 

JS
JS 2017-01-05

I would say you are correct, but it makes no sense to me why it would be an advantage...

MN
MN 2017-01-05

If a part is symmetrical to it’s origin plane, no need to create a new plane when sketch needs symmetrical plane of the part. I have seen videos creating new planes to do a sketch.    

JM
JM 2017-01-05

I can only speculate, but in classroom environment we can run into issue where student edits Toolbox part and then comes in the next day and all work is lost.

It is my speculation that the author of that video has adopted the technique he is using to divorce the part from the Toolbox, this my earlier link to alternative technique discussion.

BS
BS 2017-01-05

/\ That makes the most sense. I've heard toolbox can forget the configuration occasionally.

MN
MN 2017-01-08

Answer from demonstrator.

comment imagecomment image