Hi all,
I found a Tree of Life pattern on the world wide web that I thought was pretty cool and want to pull it into solidworks so that I can have it made in metal or whatever. The problem is that is really wont extrude properly, or at all actually.
Normally I can pick the outedge and the face and it detects all the cutouts and works just fine. That method doesn't work at all on this, i am assuming because there are so many plines and arcs. I can manually select some of the cutout features and can extrude with just them but it wont let me select others. This actually seems to change a little bit everytime I import in the design. If you edit the boss-extrude feature, you will see how many features are not able to be selected by clicking in the middle of them.
My first guess was that some of these pline features aren't closed so I picked a couple that were working, a couple that werent working and then deleted all the rest in the autocad drawing and tried importing that and they all worked exactly as they should. So no I am thinking I have hit some sort of limit or perhaps my machine is just too old and slow and cant crunch the number fast enough or perhaps I am just dense and don't get something completely obvious. So I am shooting up to you guys to teach me a thing or two.
I am working in 2011 so if you post a file, please keep that in mind.
Included are the original dwg file and the part file that has as much extruded as it will allow me.
Thanks in advance and happy holidays/new years everyone.
SolidworksParts And Features
Rik,
That's a pretty intrusting design. One thing you can try is do a bunch of separate cuts. All the curves look closed and arcs and lines, I didn't see an splines on the ones looked at. You can also go thru and make stuff tangent, there seems to be a lot of stuff not tangent. It's gonna take you a while do all that.
What do you mean by doing separate cuts? I assume transfering parts of the design into a separate space. I know you can put stuff on different layers in autocad but is there a similar method in Solidworks? Separate sketches perhaps? I will look into that, probably before you can answer.
I am looking up what you mean by making stuff tangent.
Thanks.
And yes I like the design quite a bit. Lots of possibilities there.
I've never found layers all that useful in SoildWorks, you can't name them, AutoCAD has the layer thing down I was all over layers when I used AutoCAD.
But yea separate sketches and separate features for each cut. It would take a while and you'd have a ton of features in your model but it is one way to do it. Leave your base sketch alone, create new sketches on the same plane and just convert entities. You can then go back and play around with sketch relations to get the shape you want. All the while your original sketch is in the background untouched so if you mess you can always go back.
And yes, that would be time consuming. But if you're new to SolidWorks it might be a good exercise to help you learn sketch relations.
Better yet try this; delete your solid, select your sketch and do a surface-fill with "Fix-up Boundary' checked and wait. If it fills do a thicken and you're done.
I didn't think it was going to work when I wrote that last post because it took a while for my computer to figure it out. But like I said the other way might be useful in helping you practice sketch relations.
I will try it now. Yes, I am not really "new" but since this isn't my day job, I tend to learn stuff as needed to get the job done so I am missing a whole bunch of useful base information. Working with sketches is certainly a deficit I have noticed for a while now. I will get back to ya and see if this works.
Hey, that worked like a champ. My computer had to chug away for ever but the end result was spot on.
I am also going to go back to the autocad file and put different sections on different layers. On the import screen it gives the option to send layers to their own sketches. Will see if that gets me to a multiple sketch design and then will work with that. Mostly just to learn some stuff about sketch relations like you said.
Thanks for the help.
Alright glad it worked out for you.
And just keep practicing and when you have questions this is a good place to ask.
Happy modeling........