At the training Advisory Panel, there was a discussion about the future of the 17 eCourses that are currently available for a 3 month subscription per class. As they have not sold very well, there is a proposal is to offer these eCourses as a bundle to be included with the My.Solidworks Professional subscription. What do you fellows think? I believe that it will directly compete with my live training class attendance for Sheet Metal, Weldments, Surfacing, and Mold Tools. It is currently hard enough to fill these classes on a regular basis.
I would also submit that it is not always up to the Engineering student on options for a training class, as some companies will likely go the cheapest route*(a ~\\\$300 subscription for 17 classes, which is cheaper then ONE of these classes LIVE); which is not going to necessarily be the best for the student. Obviously we already are competing with SolidProfessior, I.Get.It, and Lynda or LinkedIn Learning. Not to mention that it will most definitely compete with my own on-line training offerings.
The main issue that I see as being different is that the Solidworks eCourses follow the EXACT same book and training files that are directly offered by Solidworks Corporation, and will therefore have a much different impact then the other on-line competition. Again, I believe, that this training offering will be seen as being identical to VAR training. Obviously it will not be, but that is only obvious to anyone who has attended a live training session with our World Class Certified SOLIDWORKS Instructors.
Solidworks
Here is the eCourse plan. Starting soon, the eCourses will be available as a bundle as the MySolidWorks Professional offering. The price for MySolidWorks Professional remains the same as does its duration of 12 months. So soon, a user who buys MySolidWorks Professional will have access to all 17 eCourses for a year.
SOLIDWORKS still wants VARs to conduct as much live training as possible. I have said this repeatedly and believe in the message. It is good for your business and ours. It forms a bond between the customer and the VAR which helps at subscription renewal time. However, not all students will attend live training. Some live far away from a VARs office. Some cannot attend a 9am to 5pm class. Some prefer eLearning or video-based training because they re-watch or re-do tricky subjects. SOLIDWORKS started the eCourse program as a way for VARs to reach the students who need training but will not attend a live class. It is another tool in your toolkit to ensure customers are successfully using the software.
SOLIDWORKS eCourses have been available for more than 2 years now. They were launched at SOLIDWORKS World 2017. They were individually priced at roughly 50% of the price of the live class. VAR training has not suffered. Book sales have not plummeted.
We ran the Summer of eLearning promotion where we gave away ALL of the eCourses from June 21 to September 21, 2018. Book sales for that time period remained comparable to book sales from 2016 and 2017. Usage data and survey results from the Summer of eLearning clearly showed that learners want to purchase and consume eLearning as a bundled offering at a lower price point, prompting our change in the sales methodology of eCourses.
I hope your live business remains healthy and prosperous. And I hope you can find a way to look at eCourses as an additional tool to reach students, not as a threat to your business.
Best regards,
Joe Rousseau
SOLIDWORKS Training Manager
I understand Joe's conundrum: his team developed a very nice product, that, I imagine, was not cheap. No sales through VARs, but for a completely different reason.
Joe and I discussed this in the past: the revenue sharing between the VAR and SW did not make any sense for the sales people. There was absolutely nothing for them in selling these courses, considering the amount of potential commission.
I do not understand the SW's logic. You prefer to give these courses away, only to make the my.solidworks.com people happy, instead of getting a good stream of revenue by sharing better the income with the VARs.
A good marketing strategy would have been to ask the VARs what percentage would have been appealing to them in order to sell this product massively and then, do the math. The VARs actually told you that, without even being asked, but it got ignored.
Creating a product is great, selling it as equally important. It is interesting how a sales organization like SOLIDWORKS did not see that in regards to training.
So let me reiterate: I do not understand how is it better to give away this product essentially for free, for both VARs and SW.
It is not true that "the end goal is to put the VARs out of business".
Every time I talk to the VARs about eCourses, I share my sincere hope that you teach as many live classes as possible. I wrote that message earlier in this thread. Live classes increase the interactions with customers, which leads to increased customer satisfaction, more renewals, and more repeat sales.
The infomercial included with every eCourse starts off with, "We all know that learning in a classroom with an instructor is one of the best ways to learn SOLIDWORKS. But sometimes, it's not convenient to attend a live class. That's why we have created the self-paced eCourses which allow you to learn on your own schedule." I still believe in that message.
Best regards,
Joe Rousseau
SOLIDWORKS Training Manager
From this group I'm surprised that no one else voiced there concerns over this potential issue. I must be naive. And here I was hoping that was not the case. I admit, Rod, your answer really depressed me last week. But I can't find any errors with your logic. You do make the strong case that the end goal is to put the VAR's out of business. Initially I was simply worried that the classes that I really enjoy teaching*(Surfacing, Sheet Metal, Weldments, and Mold Tools) were likely to disappear from my schedule all together. As it was before any of these changes come to pass, these classes are regularly getting canceled due to low enrollment and interest. But obviously you have given me a lot more to think on and worry about then just that.
The situation build up goes something like this. Initially I remember that these specific classes which were chosen and developed as eCourses due to weak book sales. However now due to weak eCourse sales, the effort that went into development is getting bundled into My.Solidworks Professional. I believe that the real reason that the eCourses did not sell well to begin with is because we VAR's are trying to fill our own live classroom classes, or host our own on-line classes with these subjects. Which means that these eCourses were already in a somewhat competitive situation with us. It appears, unfortunately, that the eCourses will come out with the win as they can be sold for, as I stated before, less then ONE of these 17 classes taught LIVE*(unless we go to the bottom of the barrel as you noted before to under cut that, let's see here $350/17 is about $20.59 per class).
Supporting evidence for it being no problem for pushing these into the My.Solidworks Professional site was that the number of books sold was not impacted by the summer of learning, when it was free. I'm so confused, do we sell a lot of these books or not? In the end I hope that we will continue to sell these classes live either in classroom or on-line despite the My.Solidworks Professional offering. I wish to teach these more often then I already have a chance to, yet truthfully I DO want the students to learn Solidworks as much as they can, even if it is not from me. As when they become better users, they will become better customers.
Joseph:
I think you will find most (not all) VAR's are thinking the same thing you are. Joe R, no offense at all, but based on your data, how much more training could have been sold without giving it away for free? Without price increases, it's a race to the bottom of the barrel to eventually chip away at a profit center we VAR's have control of, one of which being training, the other being consulting. The advent of SAS based software that is being pushed heavily and sold on the cheap relative to SW is another route why training is so important to maintain profit.
Overall, we have voiced our (VAR) concerns and have gotten the same answer back every year since my.solidworks has begun. It's a difference of opinion that seemingly won't be swayed either direction. Maybe it would have been different if the content in my.solidworks started with something unique instead of just copying the books.
Rod
Joe,
Is it possible to exclude the 4 main classes that I'm most concerned with from the My.Solidworks Professional offering, and leave them as alacarte*(as they are now)? Specifically Surfacing, Sheet Metal, Weldments and Mold Tooling? Of the 17 classes, these are our 'biggest' sellers, that obviously requires both the Essentials and Advanced Part Modeling class Pre-requisites. And any students who have not met this requirement will likely not be successful with the eCourses anyway due to the lack of appropriate skills.
I must admit that I would not miss teaching Routing, as I have had the opportunity to present this topic only about a dozen*(12) times over 14 years of being an instructor*(Some classes being Piping, others just the Electrical, and a few Combo's). As every time we sell the class, I end up having to spend an enormous amount of time re-acclimating myself with every aspect of Routing as well as the training data set while testing it for *issues with the current version of Solidworks at the time of the class*(as well as learning all the 'What's New' of it). And of course transferring all of my notes from last year's book to make sure that I don't get hung up. As there is such a low amount of it that I see in tech support and the fact that it is sold so infrequently, it is a class that is definitely not fun to prepare for and teach. And obviously Routing has gotten a lot better over the years, however it is still very particular*(either that or it is operator error or something else but performing the same task 4 times results in 2 different outcomes?!).
This plea, keeping in mind, is from a Mechanical Drafting/CAD Instructor. Therefore, I do not teach the Simulation or Electrical courses. In which case, those instructors may wish to step forward and make your own plea to prevent those other 13 classes from becoming a part of the eCourses bundled into My.Solidworks Professional, essentially giving them away for free*(or at least cheaper then you can sell your training for).
Thanks,
Joseph
Regardless of how well it is marketed from Corporate, I currently help to get all of my students signed up for their My.Solidworks.com accounts while they are in my Essentials class, so that they can have access to the 'Guest' and 'Standard' learning paths. I show them where they can study for the CSWA and learn MBD, Visualize, or CAM. Not to mention the SW software downloads and access to the Knowledge-base and Forums. So if these classes are added to the My.Solidworks Professional, I find myself wondering if I should still promote the My.Solidworks.com. My fear of them 'Discovering' all of my Advanced Class topics that they would be able to purchase for a fraction of the price of my classes*(having identical content), would make me look BAD if I never mention the Value of the Professional subscription.
Right now it is not a problem, as the price is high enough for the eCourses*(at 50% of the live class price) that I don't think my students would consider the eCourses, after spending time in class with me. However, once the price drops as proposed, then I don't feel as confident that they would return. No matter how much they enjoyed or got out of my class, justifying the cost difference to their managers or company would be very difficult*(we are talking about a minimum 400%+ price difference after realizing that they could receive Sheet Metal, Weldments, Surfacing, and Mold Tools for the same price of one LIVE class from their training budget). So I would then be the potential cause of my own demise if I continue promoting My.Solidworks.com, as I'm already recommending it on a regular basis.
And in terms of e-learning not impacting LIVE training, I want to find out how many MBD classes anyone has taught considering the the free learning path SOLIDWORKS MBD | MySolidWorks Training ? I have only had the opportunity to teach two of them, both of which were customer exclusive classes*(one closed, one on-site). Or how about Solidworks Inspection classes? Again, like MBD I have had only two classes, both also were customer exclusive, again*(SOLIDWORKS Inspection | MySolidWorks Training ). Likewise has anyone had a chance to teach the new SW Visualize class SOLIDWORKS Visualize | MySolidWorks Training ? If the training for these topics are somewhat non-existent, then I could argue that it is due to these learning paths; which are not fully developed eCourses.
I mostly agree that the potential impact could be small and most customers recognize the value of a live instructor. I do a large percentage of training online, and most customers I talk to are hesitant about the concept until they hear it will be a live instructor.
Many students prefer in-classroom training, and the ones that don't are probably already being served by tools like Solid Professor, etc
HOWEVER, I think this could lead to some very awkward conversations with customers who have recently made a significant investment in training, and then learn that they could have received the same content for a small fraction of the price.
I see this as the greatest risk with the $300 subscription (I did not realize it was so inexpensive) which with an informed customer would place pressure on VARs to reduce/discount their training
Part of that risk is how heavily SOLIDWORKS will market it. Will their be monthly e-mail blasts? etc. or if this change will go largely unpromoted...
If it is marketed widespread then I would think it has a potential to erode the value of VAR training. I think it could still make sense as a subscription model but for a much greater annual fee
Hi joe,
Country like india, they dont want to spend more money for training. We should reduce the cost or else we should make single course price.That may get some impact.If they buy some ecourse one month or one week validity .Then that ecourse wontbe available for them.
This might workout for all over world
Tailoring the messaging is a somewhat slippery slope. If we say, thanks for attending our 'Sheet Metal Class' and to enhance your learning experience, we want to change you for a My.Solidworks Professional subscription. And then you can 'retake' the class you that already took with us. Hypothetically this could go one of three ways:
1) You did an awesome job in class, you know Solidworks well enough, but if your interested you can go through this class again on your own time, for a fee*(My.SolidWorks Professional).
2) We do not think that you got it, so we will charge you for this class again*(fee for My.SolidWorks Professional), and you have a year to review it.
3) Check out this entire class online that you could have had for less*(fee for My.SolidWorks Professional), you did not actually need to come to a live class in the first place to get the same material.
And once that occurs we may have the following reactions:
1) Why do I need this? I just spent 2 days with you in class? Was there a problem with what I got? Why are you charging me again?
2) Well, bummer, I guess I should just stick with these eCourses, as after I paid for the subscription to get Sheet Metal, I noticed that I can also take Weldments, Surfacing, and Mold Tooling as well. I guess I don't need to go back to my VAR for a live class, as I now have access to all these other topics.
3) This VAR did not offer this in the beginning, why not? I could have gotten all this training*(17 classes) for the cost of my Sheet Metal class. Perhaps this VAR did not have my best interest at heart in the beginning, now there is a TRUST issue.
I really want to believe that this wont impact LIVE training, but I'm still not yet convinced given this proposed form of offerings being considered. Any business owner counting the pennies to keep the lights on will scramble to get training for as cheaply as possible, and who am I to criticize? Most people price shop the Solidworks software and training already, and of course they will find and exploit the cheapest training options possible. Offering all these classes as a bundle on the cheap sounds great for someone who does not think that there is, as Chris stated above, any real 'Value' for these classes in the first place. Just who are we targeting here anyway? And any AE who shares a cubical with an Account Manager likely cringes when they here the word 'Discount' a dozen times a day understands this to be true. Sell Value NOT Price.
Perhaps this entire proposal can be reconsidered, and let us instead make these palatable to VAR's so that we can tack on a single 'eCourse' subscription to a single student that has attended the Live training for that topic for a nominal fee*(perhaps tied to the Book sales or an additional serial number for the specific eCourse inside of the training Book). This would have the desired impact and result for ensuring the student's success with out watering down our other training classes. This pricing could be different then the outright pricing for a single eCourse for a student who is 'unwilling' or 'unable' to attend a live training class.
'IF WE' truly want to strengthen the Customer VAR bond, then this would be a much better approach. The new message would be, *Thank you for attending our LIVE class, not only do you have the option of getting a Digital Copy of your Training Manual, but you also the opportunity to audit this same eCourse on this topic for a year. Which I really like that message, and believe in it, as it would definitely be a WIN/WIN across the board. That way the eCourses could be a reinforcement of the LIVE training class. As it is we already offer LIVE audits for a year, so it would not be that much different then the current message*(although the eCourse would obviously be much better for the Auditor, as they can take it after hours, and 'skip' around to the areas that they need to review only, with out spending the entire day with us again).
If the current proposal stands and we practically give them away, I want to know how we can ensure that the PREREQUISITE of Solidworks Essentials has been met before any of these Mechanical CAD eCourses can be attempted. I, again in my experience, am constantly getting students in my Advanced Parts and Assemblies classes that have NOT had Essentials. As such to make sure that my instruction is understood by everyone, I have to review Essentials material*(at least in part) to make sure that the Advanced concepts stick. If it could be possible to 'LOCK' all eCourses out until the VAR can approve that a specific user has actually attended a LIVE Essentials class*(or SW Simulation core class based on the eCourse category), in order to ensure success with the advanced topic. Otherwise we are doing a disservice to the students who are attending eCourse only, as they are not getting the full training experience that they need.
The primary issue is value. Is SW responding to real or anticipated market pressures? Is Autodesk, PTC, etc. giving away any of their training? Is there pressure from Lynda, SolidProfessor or YouTubers?
This issue is particularly troubling because we know that the eCourse content is exactly the same as live training, even though the average user will not know this beforehand unless we tell them.
There are quite a number of VARs offering Virtual/online training. Why not promote those offerings before creating an eCourse?
If a VAR does not have Virtual classes, they are incentivized to get into the Virtual space or else lose revenue to others that are.
But since the eCourse genie is out of the bottle, why not incentivize the VARs (as Alin mentioned) to promote these in the context of existing Virtual and live classes? eCourses could be added to the SW subscription, for instance, as a way to further enhance that offering.
I don't see many sales folks getting too excited about selling MySOLIDWORKS Professional subscriptions. It's a nice add-on perhaps.
The 3DEXPERIENCE training on MySOLIDWORKS.com looks an awful lot like CATIA training – right down to the formatting - i.e. self-led, online modules. Does Dassault believe that eventually most people will want self-led training, so SW eCourses were developed as part of that strategy? If that is the case and as long as customers prefer/demand it that way, so be it. But that doesn't mean we have to give it away.
I am interested in knowing all the ways eCourses are being marketed by SW to customers in general. I don't want to appear to customers as if we don't have their best interests in mind. For example, since we believe that classes with a live instructor (whether in-person or online) is more beneficial and provides more value to customers, we would initially lead sales discussions in that direction. eCourses are not high on the priority list for discussion because they now imply that there is no value to them (which we know is not the case). If during this time (or even after), the customer were to discover eCourses via a SW marketing promotion or otherwise, they might feel like we were not looking out for their best interests if we did not initially put eCourses on the table.
As Amie commented, we are going to have to be proactive with the messaging and ensure that it is in line with other sources of information.
I think the eCourses are well done, have value and can help fill gaps where customers don’t want in-person or virtual training offerings.
However, I’m struggling with how to design that message since we are essentially giving it away.
My comments are not on pricing, but on elearning versus in-person. Making the elearning available for free can seem at first like a challenge to training sales, I agree. However, I've been in the training department 11 years now, and have yet to see a self-directed elearning product impact the sales of live training. While the manual content might be the same, it cannot replace the extremely valuable guidance from a live instructor and interaction with a classroom environment. If you have a customer that already loves your training, I am doubtful they would leave that experience in favour of of the eCourses. More importantly, you do have it in your control to position the eCourses as a compliment to the live training. An option is to take the pro-active approach and sell it as an add-on to the in-person experience, making it a well-rounded package. Also wondering, what is the volume of sales you have for My.Solidworks Professional? This would be a telling factor in the potential impact.
My take is, take control of the messaging, make it a positive approach for you, the customer, and the suite of training products. It would be a shame to see so much effort put into these products and see it go to waste, I'd like to see it a success, as a compliment to in-person training.
Regards, Amie