Cannot thicken surface

Hello,

I'm trying to thicken a surface that is derived from a lofted solid. However, I keep getting various errors, like "face which failed check", and so on. I checked my surface, and cannot find any gaps, intersections or anything that looks suspicious.

Please help. I'm attaching a part file. I'm trying Thicken command, it needs to be 0.5mm thick on the outside (I tried lower numbers also, didn't work).

SolidworksParts And Features
Answers 5
AV
AV 2013-09-06 Best Answer

J.R. if you are in a hurry, cap the volume, make it a solid and use the shell command.

See attached.

RF
RF 2013-09-06

J.R.,

Thicken is the last thing you want to do with these surfaces. You need to look at the base geometry because the transitions from face edge to face edge are not smooth at all. Most surfacing commands require smooth transitions for them to work. If you want a quick-and-dirty model for show, you can make this work any number of ways. If you want a manufacturable-quality model, you've got some work to do.

The best visual tool to troubleshoot your transitions is to right click on the surfaces and select Zebra Stripes from the in-context menu. You may have to expand the in-context menu at the bottom to see it. You can use the Zebra Stripes properties to tighten the stripes and get a better appreciation of the problem areas.

You want as-smooth-a-stripe line you can get from surface-to-surface. Delete the most 'jagged' and experiment with re-creating the faces using the end-cap profiles as guide. Shoot for curvature continuous conditions on each transition. Run the stripes again. Rinse and repeat until you get the smoothest result. Your .5mm thicken should work then.

JR
JR 2013-09-06

This can be quick and dirty. It is only for reference, it doesn't need to be very accurate, but I need it to be of constant thickness, because I'll need to calculate weight of this part. Also, quick-rebuilding way would be preferable, because whole assembly rebuilds slow already.

Alin, shell looks very close to what I need - only that I need that additional thickness to be on the outside of the surface. Can you show how to do that?

AV
AV 2013-09-06

The thickness is on the outside in the part I uploaded in my previous post.

comment imagecomment image
JR
JR 2013-09-06

Just found it, wanted to write back, but you were faster! Thank you very much. That did exactly what is needed.