Can't Start Motion Analysis with Blocks and Point-On-Curve Constraint

Hi all, I'm studying a variation of Archimedes' trammel with curves instead of straight lines along which the slider will slide.  For instance, the endpoints of the solid red line segment are constrained to be on the orange curves (the dashed lines have no role in the orange block aside from defining the tangents of the spline curves (they have lots of points, so curvature is not too sharp; I also tried removing most of the points, to no avail); the grey circle is also no longer relevant, although if the red trammel is instead constrained on the dashed lines, the red circle will roll without slipping on it).  The blue arm is constrained to be in-line with the midpoint of the red trammel and rotates about the center of the orange circle.  I can move the red trammel just fine by clicking and dragging, but when I try to start a motion analysis with either a motor or a torque actuating the blue arm, it simply does not start (no errors are displayed).  Is this because Motion Analysis simply does not support point-on-curve constraints, even though one can drag them?  I can "run" an animation, but nothing even moves, and I want Motion Analysis calculations!

Thanks,
Caleb

SolidworksMotion Studies
Answers 8
SF
SF 2013-09-04 Best Answer

hi caleb, your image didn't make it through. it might also help to post a simple version of your model for others to take a look at.

you may also want to check the solidworks KB to see if that is a known issue/limitation.

have you tried an edge instead of a sketch? or a path mate?

need your example or picture to futher visualize and check out what might be going on.

SF
SF 2013-09-04

Thanks Jared, sorry the screenshot didn't show up.  I'm using blocks, but I could make 3d parts out of them, and then perhaps the mates could be simulated in Motion.  Here's my model.

SF
SF 2013-09-04

hi caleb, what will be the driving motor/force in this analysis

i tried just dragging the blue unconstrained line and it "barely" works as a block on block motion. but maybe i'm moving the wrong thing.

SF
SF 2013-09-05

Hi Jared, yes, the blue arm is supposed to move.  I could have defined the orange curves a bit better, but it should have over 100deg of motion.  I tried a gravity study, torque on the arm, and motor actuation of arm, and none allowed the sim to start for even a second.  I also got no error message - not that the mechanism was locked, etc.

SF
SF 2013-09-05

So this means that, as far as you know, point-on-curve constraints aren't forbidden in SW Motion Analysis?

SF
SF 2013-09-19

haven't really had a chance to take a look at this, did you make any headway?

SF
SF 2013-09-19

It really seems like you can't use the constraint with spline-based blocks.  However, if you need such a constraint (i.e., modelling a cam without a contact), you can use a path mate - however, this doesn't work with blocks, so you have to make actual parts. 

SF
SF 2013-09-20

were you able to confirm that with your reseller and get an SPR/enhancement request written? this is a part of the software i haven't spent a lot of time with. (blocks/2d motion) i'm kind of surprised there is a limitation but at the same time, i know that part is a bit limited.