Autodesk Vault Manufacturing vs. SW PDM solutions

We have an electrical group here that uses Autocad Electrical.  They are exploring the possibility of using a PDM system for their data, and I have attended a couple of presentataions of the Autodesk offering showing how it can interface with SW.  Are there any current or past Autodesk Vault users here who could elaborate the pros and cons of this system?

We have legacy SW data that goes back as far as SW98 and have had 3 or 4 different filing methods and custom property layouts in that time.  I'm trying to get a feel for how painful it will be to move all this legacy data into the vault and still reap the benefits of a PDM system.

Jim S.

SolidworksSolidworks Pdm enterprise Pdm
Answers 4
SF
SF 2009-08-07 Best Answer

Do you currently use SEPDM?  If so, why not just put their stuff in there?  That's what we do here.

  WT

JS
JS 2009-08-07

Currently we do not use a PDM system.  We have a fairly rigid process that keeps our mechanical group from having many of the problems that the PDM is meant to address.  But some of the PDM features have caught my eye and I'm trying to determine if the benefits outweight the headaches of using a competitor's product with SW.

Jim S.

SO
SO 2009-08-07

Jim - If you're primary tool is SolidWorks, then I would first look at what SolidWorks has to offer. Enterprise PDM is an easy to use tool and will do more than many need. It should also handle the AutoCAD Electrical datasets and libraries as well as MS Office documents. I haven't worked with the Autodesk Vault, but I've been around it and I've never been impressed.

Plus, most PDM systems will handle DWG data fine. It's the 3D CAD data that gets tricky. Using a competitor's PDM system to manage CAD data is just asking for problems later. What happens to upgrade cycles? If Autodesk Vault doesn't upgrade their integration with SolidWorks until late you are stuck on an old version and waiting. Don't let your PDM system hamper your modeling efforts.

AW
AW 2009-08-08

Nevermind....