Anybody out there investigate Spaceclaim 3D CAD software? Looking for comparisons and feedback (Good, bad and ugly) before I dive into this evaluation.
Any feedback is appreciated.
Thanks,
allanvis
SolidworksGeneral
Anybody out there investigate Spaceclaim 3D CAD software? Looking for comparisons and feedback (Good, bad and ugly) before I dive into this evaluation.
Any feedback is appreciated.
Thanks,
allanvis
SolidworksGeneral
When it first came out, one of their techs did a demonstration showing how it works. It appears to be a pretty capable modeler and it's got some documentation capabilities. It uses direct and inferred editing instead of features and history and it links to existing CAD file formats. It was pitched to me as a manager's concept tool, not a complete CAD system.
I haven't met anyone who uses it for production design-work.
John
I use SpaceClaim to augment what SolidWorks doesn't do very well. Unlike SolidWorks, SpaceClaim is ideal for working with dumb solid models. SpaceClaim is also ideal for designing fixtures where I know up front that many approaches will need to be tried. SpaceClaim has the best user interface of any CAD or CAM product I've ever used. It's a phenomenal piece of software that I can't say enough good about. One of the founders of SpaceClaim is very active on Twitter (Blake Courter) and he's very responsive and receptive to suggestions on how to improve SpaceClaim.
Here is a video that shows how valuable SpaceClaim can be in a machine shop:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFcRrlquEmA
Jon Banquer
San Diego, CA
http://cadcamtechnologyleaders.blogspot.com/
Allan, you're the first person I've met who uses it. Do you use it in conjunction with Solidworks for design work or do you use it by itself? I ask because I'm curious about how it fits into an engineering workflow.
John
Not using it yet - trying to do my homework on the software because management sees it as a cost cutting opportunity. Sounds like it from the pure CAD perspective, but seems like Spaceclaim in lacking in product data management, FEA, etc.
Jon, you're the first person I've met who uses it. Do you use it in conjunction with Solidworks for design work or do you use it by itself? I ask because I'm curious about how it fits into an engineering workflow.
John
John,
I use SpaceClaim in conjunction with SolidWorks. I use SpaceClaim to prep non native solid models I recieve for manufacture. A few quick examples would be using SpaceClaim to remove small fillets at the bottom of deep pockets and replacing them with larger ones and removing fillets where I want a sharp edge for a corner rounder. I find I can work with non-native solids much faster with SpaceClaim than I can with SolidWorks. I also greatly perfer SpaceClaim for fixing bad IGES surface models. I don't believe SolidWorks has the necessary direct modeling tools. Move Face takes too long and often on the models I get Feature Recognition fails. For years I asked SolidWorks Corp. for the kinds of direct modeling tools that SpaceClaim has and they ignored all my requests.
I also use SpaceClaim when I'm designing fixtures where I know that what I start with won't be anywhere close to what I end up with. I find SpaceClaim to be a much better tool when I expect constant major changes to occur.
Every machinist I've showed SpaceClaim to loves it. I wish CAM ran inside of SpaceClaim and that CAM companies would OEM it like sheet metal leader TRUMPF does.
Jon Banquer
San Diego, CA
http://cadcamtechnologyleaders.blogspot.com/
I don't know if I'd see it as a cost savings-not when you consider that CAD software as a percentage of labor costs is pretty low. 16 hundred per year per seat for subscription is about a week of designer pay with benefits. Assuming spaceclaim can create production-ready designs as well as Solidworks, it's still going to be a couple of years before you see a savings benefit. And judging by how Spaceclaim positions themselves in their marketing literature, I don't think they consider themselves a replacement for parametric CAD.
John
Thanks for that, Jon. That's good stuff. I agree with you about the move-face tool in Solidworks. I use it quite a bit, but it only works for one or two tricks. I think with Solidworks' major competitors all developing direct-editing tools, it's dangerous for them to be complacent about their capabilities in that regaurd. I remember seeing a video for Dassault's sculpting tool a couple of years ago and being impressed with how non-linear and natural it was. I wonder if their strategy is to tie that back into Solidworks in the near future.
John