Advice/Suggestions on building a new PC.

I'm figuring on upgrading my PC at home to run SW and/orInventor. BTW I currently use SW08 at work but don't have it athome.

So I'm doing some research to decide what to do for hardware. I'mlooking to not spend 1k on any single component, more like 1k forall hardware.

I have a few questions.

Help me understand clearly as I think out loud here. Is the core i7basically an 8 core processor? Or is it 4 core with HT? So I'mwondering, for SW, it's not really any faster than a core 2 duo ofthe same bus speed? I know that drawings/fea/pw etc. utilize themulti cores, but just plain SW I mean.

As for a gpu, I currently have a pretty high end gaming card I planto use, EVGA GTX 260. Anybody running gaming cards for SW, successor failures?

How much of a PS do I need? I have a 600w currently and would liketo use it if I can get away with it.

I'm leaning towards right now the slowest core i7 with 6gb of 1600ram.

I'm liking the idea of windows 7, but I don't think I want to waitfor it. So leaning towards vista 64 ultimate.

I also hear that usb 3.0 will be coming out, but that should justbe a matter of adding a controller card when I want to pull thattrigger right?

Probably more questions to come. Thanks.
SolidworksAdministration
Answers 20
SF
SF 2009-02-02 Best Answer
As for your question on the core i7 let me just say onething. Not all processors cores of the same bus speed are createdequal. As far as I have heard the core i7 seem to be quite abitfaster then there core 2 counter parts.

here is a link to annas punch holder benchmark it should give yousome ideas
http://spreadsheets.google.com...z7wTpIkC7LA28ybEyxyTPw
JA
JA 2009-02-02
Also, any particular brands I should avoid or prefer for anyreason?
SF
SF 2009-02-02
Jay,

I have an EVGA 8800GT in my home computer (when my FX570 is notinstalled). In my experience, the 8800GT is OK for use for a fewhours, so long as I'm not working on assemblies with >100 partsor overly complex models. What I usually encounter is the graphicswindow will stop updating, for instance, when switching betweenpart files. The only way to get things working again is a completere-boot. YMMV.

The PSU is dependant upon how many other things you install in thesystem. I think there is a PSU calculator available on NewEgg'ssite. When I built my system, the PSU sizing was more important forthe gaming video card (amps on the 12V rail) than any of the othercomponents.

HTH.


Edit:
I should have noted that most of this experience was with SW2008. Idon't have much seat time with SW2009 and this setup.
JA
JA 2009-02-02
Bill,

So I get the impression that your only gaming card issues was notenough cooling?



On another note...the layout of the board.

If I decided to re-use my dell 8400 tower, should the newmotherboard drop right in? I'm thinking the atx form factor putsthe electronics in the same areas, but not sure. maybe even if I'mlucky the processor cooling/ducting can be reused. Though I mayjust buy another case. So still, I just have to make sure atx formfactor?

Can you tell it's been a long time since I built a machine. Justupgrades in the last ten years.
SF
SF 2009-02-02
I'm not sure that cooling was the issue, despite othermessages here relating black SW windows with heat. I use the EVGAsuite for controlling the video card parameters; the fan speed isset to 65%. The temperature of the card never exceeded 70C. Videocards are reportedly OK operating in the mid-90s C before heat isan issue, unlike CPUs.

As for the case, my last experience trying to re-use a Dell casewas not so good; about four years ago, don't remember the Dellmodel. The one I had used a proprietary connector for the casefront panel, meaning I couldn't plug in the power/reset buttons,HDD light, etc. from the Dell plug to the new motherboard. I endedup buying a cheap case, though I guess it would have been possibleto clip off the Dell connector and put on the proper two- andthree-pin molex connectors to make it work.

CC
CC 2009-02-02
I have had problems with gamer cards flaking out, so I wouldonly use a Quadro FX570 for a real Solidworks computer.

To answer your question though, Core i7 is 4 core withhyper-threading.
SF
SF 2009-02-03
Hi!

A normal ATX-mobo will not fit into a Dell-box, same applies to thePSU, that's for sure.

You will have to buy a new case.

A 600W-PSU is completely oversized for a pc like this, go for450-500W.

Core i7 is nice for Rendering and FEA, for normal "everyday"SW-use, a C2D is the way to go. If you do some renderings, go for aquad.

Mobo:
MSI P35 Neo2-F
PSU:
Corsair VX450/VX550
CPU:
C2D E8500 or C2Q Q9450
Memory:
4G DDR2-800 (2x2G)
GPU:
Quadro FX570 or a gaming card - i would go for the quadro
HDD:
There are so many of them... Choose one! Just make sure it hasS-ATA2, NCQ and a lot of cache (and stay away from the .11-seriesfrom Seagate!!)

Also stay away from SLI/Crossfire, same applies to RAID (unless youreally need it). Don't choose a mobo that's full of features youdon't need (Wifi eg).
Cooling isn't a big thing nowadays, the Intel boxed will do fine atan acceptable noise level.
Don't buy a case for 30 bucks, it will rattle and clank as hell
SF
SF 2009-02-03
What brand is your PS? All PS are not created equal, I wouldtake a lower wattage brand name PS over a higher wattage generic.Core 2 Duo and Core i7 CPU's do not draw a lot of power, your GPUdraws more power then the CPU. Nvidia recommends a minimun 500W PSfor the GTX 260.

At the same clock speed a Core i7 is faster then a Core 2 Duo. Youcan always build it with a 920 CPU now and swap it for a faster CPUnext year.

If you are going to do much SW work on the computer I would reallyconsider a Quadro FX570, the GTX 260 will probably be fine forlight work.

All Dell's that I have worked with use custom PS's andmotherboards, don't count on being able to reuse the case or PS.

Make sure you have fast harddrive(s). Western Digital 10,000RPM arenice, but expensive for their size. RAID has it's place, make sureyou understand the difference between RAID 0, 1 and 5. Most of mycomputers have RAID. A nice setup is a WD 10,000RPM boot drive and2 larger drives in RAID 1 for data.

IMHO Vista 64bit is the OS to use right now, that will probablychange when Windows 7 is released.
JA
JA 2009-02-03
Actually, my PS didn't come with my dell, and I did have todremel the case to get access to the power connector. I bought itwhen I bought the gpu. I don't know what brand it is, it was theonly one at staples and it was either that one or order one onlineand wait, so I bought the one on hand so I could play with my newgpu.

As for a hard drive, I am considering a 60gb SSM drive for the OSand primary sw. Not sure though, the speed seems to be extreme,though I get the impression they are not reliable, and shouldn't bedefragged, so still looking into it.

I should look into the raid configurations more, I'm really notvery familiar with that.
SF
SF 2009-02-03
SSD drives are fast. The disadvantage is they are expensiveand the memory has a finite number of writes before it goes bad andcan no longer be used. There is no point in defragging an SSDbecause there is very little difference where the info is placed onthe drive, and defragging uses up write cycles.

With a MTBF of >1000000 hours on SSD drives, how long do youwant a drive to last?
SF
SF 2009-02-03
The 3 most common RAID's are.

RAID 0 stripes your data across 2 or more drives. Read and writetimes are fast because the data is being split and each drive onlyneeds to read or write half the data (in a 2 drive array). Thedisadvantage is, if any drive fails your data is lost.

RAID 1 mirrors your data across 2 or more drives. Read times arefast because each drive only needs to read half of the data. Writetimes are no better then a single drive because each drive has allof the data on it. The disadvantage is half your drive space iswasted, the advantage is if one drive fails the other one has allthe information on it.

RAID 5 is basically a RAID 0 with a 3rd harddrive that contains aparity check so that if one drive fails the data can be rebuiltusing the other 2 drives.

This is a very simplified explaination. Look up RAID inwikipedia.
JA
JA 2009-02-03
Ah, interesting about the raids.

As for the SSD MTBF....if I understand correctly then the drive ifused constantly, odds are it would last over 114 years?? Hmmm,apparently I don't quite understand that number.

Anyway, sounds like a raid 1 across two SSD's would rock, andreliably, though be a bit pricey.
JA
JA 2009-02-03
As an example, it looks to me like this MB has a built inraid controller for up to 6 drives, correct?

http://www.newegg.com/Product/...x?Item=N82E16813138135
SF
SF 2009-02-04
This board is nice, no doubt about that - but it's way tooexpensive for what you need, unless you want to overclock your CPUinto possibly dangerous regions
KS
KS 2009-02-04

Charles Culp wrote:

 

I have had problems with gamer cards flaking out, so I wouldonly use a Quadro FX570 for a real Solidworks computer.

If Solidworks is in the thought pattern of thinking it's togood for "mere gaming cards" - I don't think that's the right wayto go. But, that's just my opinion here.

I'm not doubting what you're saying isn't valid because I'm sadlysure it is.
SF
SF 2009-02-04

Jay Andrews wrote:

 

As an example, it looks to me like this MB has a built in raidcontroller for up to 6 drives, correct?



http://www.newegg.com/Product/...x?Item=N82E16813138135

The MB has connectors for 6 SATA drives and supports RAID.You should go to Biostar's website and download the manual for theMB to see what drive configurations it supports and how to set itup. It looks like you can have 2 RAID arrays but one of them mustuse an ESATA port.
JA
JA 2009-02-04

Martin Wrann wrote:

 

This board is nice, no doubt about that - but it's way tooexpensive for what you need, unless you want to overclock your CPUinto possibly dangerous regions

Yeah, not interested in that board per se, just using it asan example for the raid question.
JA
JA 2009-02-04

Daniel Herr wrote:

 

The MB has connectors for 6 SATA drives and supports RAID. Youshould go to Biostar's website and download the manual for the MBto see what drive configurations it supports and how to set it up.It looks like you can have 2 RAID arrays but one of them must usean ESATA port.

Good idea. BTW, I did do some wiki reading about the raid andthe ssd while I was there. The raid info was very clear, while thessd info was lets say, abundant.

Now my biggest draw back is that the software is more expensivethan I thought. Couldn't find a price for SW though. Can someonetell me what to expect to pay for a seat of SW?
AW
AW 2009-02-04
$4K U.S. and up, plus maintanance, depending on what versionof SW you get.

Cheers,
JA
JA 2009-02-05
Thanks Anna,

Not too far from what I expected. I was hoping around 3 something.I almost choked when I found the price for inventor at 5300 ontheir site

I see that you just bought SW btw, congrats.