Welcome to the SolidWorks Costing Space!

Hello Everyone,

My name is Blake Reeves and I am a newer member of the SolidWorks Product Definition team. I wanted to simply introduce myself to you all, especially those of you interested in Costing since this is my primary focus at the moment. A little background information: as a recent Mechanical Engineering Design graduate from Worcester Polytechnic Institute in Worcester, MA, I have had a lot of exposure to machining and machine design along with some extracurricular work in biofuels and plant design. I have several years of experience with SolidWorks as a user, and I have background working with P&G/Gillette on advanced machine design projects as well as with Qteros, a biofuels exploration company, on their past processing plant endeavors.

Since joining SolidWorks, I have seen the potential of Costing and spoken to a lot of customers who see great things for the tool. I plan on working with you all in helping the Costing tool grow to your expectations and I look forward to you all being vocal about what you like, dislike, and would like to see from it in the future. I heard the call to create this space for Costing so I'm glad it is now available to us, but I acknowledge even within Costing there are many topics to discuss, so I would like to ask that we organize our discussions to their specific topics to avoid too much bleed-over. Some topics I've seen already mentioned and others that come to mind at the moment include:

Costing Templates

     Ease-of-Use

     Ethics of Sharing between Shops

     Level of detail

Costing Accuracy

     How to obtain Labor Costs

     Strategies to optimize pricing inputs

     Opinions on how things are calculated / how they should be calculated

General usability

     User Interface

     Discoverability of new features

     Interest in a more customizable approach

     Interest in a faster / easier approach

Future Enhancements you'd like to see...

Again this is simply a small list that just came to mind at the moment, you are not limited to any of these, I want to hear your experiences with Costing and any ideas on how to really bring out the great potential this tool has to offer. Feel free to send me an email if you would like to discuss anything as well, I'm reachable through Private Message or blake.reeves (at) 3ds.com . I will be sure to be as active on here as I can and I look forward to hearing all of your feedback and ideas.

Best Regards,

Blake Reeves

SolidworksCosting
Comments 15
TS
TS 2012-09-06

The editor is a disaster.  Copying to and pasting in from excel would be appreciated.  

Why is thickness in mm and everything else in inch?  Is it really expected of us to enter in every speed and feed, for every drill size, every type of tool, for every material we plan on using?  My small list of materials that I started with now has 2000 drill entries to check. 

Short answer: It ain't happening.

The data tables need to be broken up much more, so there's not an insane amount of data to enter that could be calcluated.  Why do I have to enter the cost per pound of steel on -every- row of the thickness table?  Why arent standard gauges of solidworks materials already provided? 

I have tried to get the manufacturing manager to help me on inputting some information into the template.  There's just too many possibilities and the data required grows exponentially for new materials and thicknesses.

So, we don't use it at all.

GD
GD 2012-09-07

Ditto to what Tom said.  Maintenance of the costing templates requires great patience.  Whatever happened to normalized databases?  In my little world, the price for 5052-H32 aluminum sheet fluctuates across all gauges at about the same time.  The price per square foot is a function of price per pound of billet, roll milled thickness, order quantity, audit requirements, and freight.  I have around 11 gauge thicknesses for each alloy that I process.  Right now, that's 3003-H14, 5052-H32, 3042B bare, 304#4 w/PVC, ColdRoll, HotRoll, copper, brass, polycarbonate, FR4. 

As an example of not-to-duplicate functionality, consider the Property Tab Builder UI.  As an XML editor it is bare bones and anti-user. It gets the job done but not with joy.  Nonetheless, use an XML editor to design the UI for updating the costing template and then let me have the ability to customize it to my needs.

Sometimes I need a template to select processes (waterjet for copper, CO2 laser for steel).  I need different templates to compare changing a part from 3003-H14 aluminum to 304 2B stainless.  I say I need a different template only because combining the two creates a matrix that is impractical to edit.

GD
GD 2012-09-07

Blake -

I have tried setting up a stroke based template for my CNC turrets.  Some of the results make sense, but I don't grok how it is calculating the perimeter cut.  Say I have 30" of perimeter and a 1" punch loaded in an indexing station.  How does the template know that I'm in need of 30 strokes, folks?

SF
SF 2012-09-17

Thanks for the feedback Tom, we definitely realize the amount of information-input necessary to build the templates is a daunting job, we'd love to hear ideas that you might have to streamlining this process though. As Gerald mentioned, one option is having an XML editor to allow a user to customize and automate the template-building process. Would people prefer to simplify the template process or eliminate it all-together?

May I suggest we start a template-based thread for this topic?

SF
SF 2012-09-17

I'll be sure to send you some info a bit later Gerald

SF
SF 2012-09-18

Gerald,

We don't necessarily have the ability to calculate stroke-based punches for turrets at the moment because it considers a stroke cut to be a single stroke, but there may be a way around this. As you know, we do allow a user to set up custom Length and Stroke-Cut Methods. Though a Stroke-cut method may be what you might lean towards for a turret operation, as you said, there is no real way to determine that you may need 30 strokes to nibble an edge for example. Nibbling and related operations are similar to a Length Cut Method and as a result, our recommended strategy would be to set up a turret machine under this method and give it a cost-per-inch. The number of strokes would not necessarily determined, but a user would be able to right-click a cut-path and assign the turret machine to it since it is technically just as much of a cost-per-length than it is a cost-per-punch.

This is more of a work-around than a proper approach, but would you see this as sufficient to your needs? or do you specifically need to know the number of strokes, etc?

Thanks

-Blake

GD
GD 2012-09-18

Blake -

What I want is a $.  What I have is a sheet metal part that has a perimeter. (smiley emoticon eschewed)

My template for laser is running fairly close to what Striker (CNC programming) is estimating for laser run time.  My limited experience with cutting method templates leads me to feel they work ok-ish.  I don't have my template dealing with peirce and the related time for switching assist gasses, edge condition codes, loader cycle times, &c.  However, for a simulation of what my modeled features represent in terms of cost, it might be relevant.

My template for the turret is not as happy.

To convert perimeter length into $ for a turret I need 1) distance to cut, 2) knockout/string tag plan, 3) slitting tool size, 4) slitting tool overlap.  From there I can get # of strokes.  Obviously, # of strokes is convertable to # of pennies.

My turret has a maximum hit rate for 1" moves as well as a nibbling rate.  For really fine grained estimating, hit rate is a function of positioning the work piece, rotating the turret, postioning the striker, pressing the punch through the work piece, and retracting the punch from the work piece.  In some instances, indexing the punch to change its orientation prior to striking is required.

My turret has an operator.  The operator has a switch that changes the hit rate.  Slower is sometimes better - slug pulls, sheet rattle, noise, boredom.  Sometimes I want to remove the switch from the operator.

My turret also has a work chute.  Sometimes we use the workchute to route scrap, to route finished parts, or not at all.  Work chutes are great for separating the good from the junk but take a lot of time.  However, for down stream processing the use of automated sorting saves time in the overall manufacturing process. 

Work chutes offer a competitive advantage for manufacturing some products.  An eagle eyed estimator will leverage that advantage when predicting costs.  On the other hand, a cost report based on an average hit rate will give an average advantage.  That's not much of an advantage, on the average.

SF
SF 2012-12-04

Never noticed this section before..........  A few months late to the game but I had a somewhat lengthy discussion w/ Craig T. about this - he should be able to fill you in (assuming he hasn't moved onto another area).

He should've gotten a bunch of feedback as well from a presentation I gave on Costing from Cadd Edge's user group back in Nov (right before I left).

Thanks,
Dave

SF
SF 2012-12-12

Hi David,

Yes, Craig and I are hard at work on the Costing tool at this very moment, your feedback has proven very helpful so far

Best Regards,

Blake

SF
SF 2013-01-31

We are looking at creating a sheet metal costing template in our company.  What is the best way to come up with the costing information when we purchase all of our sheet metal parts?  I have talked to our supplier and he said the cost varies so much on the size and complexity of the part it would be hard to put one cost on all bends.  What is the best way to handle this??

Thanks,

Scott

SF
SF 2013-02-12

I am very interested in seeing this space develop. Is there a good (detailed) tutorial for setting up costing?

SF
SF 2013-02-15

Hi Callye,

I mentioned this just recently in another thread, but currently the extent of tutorials we have for costing are the Sheet Metal and Machining Basic tutorials in the SW Help. There has been a lot more interest in more detailed tutorials recently so I will see what I can do about this. I gave a pretty good overview at SWW this year, I will see about getting that presentation or a summarized version of it available if possible. Are you interested in any specific Costing topics?

Thanks,

-Blake

SF
SF 2013-02-15

Hi Scott,

When it comes to filling out the templates, one strategy we found to be good is creating multi-tier templates for parts with varying levels of complexity. For example, if you have different costs for more complex bends, you can create a template dedicated to costing those complex bends, etc. As a result, you might have multiple sheet metal templates to more accurately calculate the cost of various styles of parts. Let me know if this would work for you or if you are looking for a different workflow.

Thanks,

-Blake

SF
SF 2013-02-15

I spent some time adjusting the sheet metal costing template. I think I have it fairly close. I would like to see how other people implement custom processes (welding is particularly interesting and complex). I really need a tutorial on the machining template. The default template gives me bizarre setup operations and pricing. The default template tooling is not very robust.

SF
SF 2020-04-11

Hello Blake

I new user solidworks costing and I'm designing a database for process planing our company .

Our company is a small company and Our needs will be met with a small database.

for this purpose I decided Up to database entries like operation and atc from solidworks cost .

For this action I need definition new rules and I thing template is sql database .

generally I went know how can definition new rules .

Thank you