Rebuild - Why doesn't SW do what I tell it to do?

I have a top-level assembly loaded. An error is detected in asub-assembly/part. I open the asm/part, correct the error andrebuild the asm/part. SW is now happy with the corrected asm/part(which is obviously resolved). I return (CTRL-TAB) to the upperassembly and click rebuild. Nothing. I click it again. Nothing. Theerror is still being highlighted. It's as if SW has decided that arebuild isn't warranted yet. I have to exit the assembly and reloadit to make the error go away.

BTW, I discovered a quirk/trick. If I have an error and it won'trebuild (although I have told it to do so) and I edit any mate -lo-and-behold the damn error goes away. A rebuild occurred.

In Conclusion:

When I click rebuild, I expect SW to rebuild.





SolidworksAssemblies
Comments 4
GD
GD 2008-03-08
Van -
The Rebuild icon is just a decoy - the real deal is CTRL-Q.Sometimes, you have to open (or edit) the errant component andCTRL-Q within its context in order to trigger the cascade of flagsthat signal the top level assembly to update.

The Rebuild icon tries to be responsive by rebuilding features thatit thinks have been recently changed. The underlying features areomitted. If you're in the context of a part without external links,the Rebuild Icon is useful.

In the same time saving spirit, the CTRL-Q does not traverse allpossible paths in an assembly to force rebuilds - there aresituations where that could take an indeterminable amount of time.

I too find this a mystifying level of functionality and agree withyour sentiment. Over the years, I've learned to model with onefinger on the escape key and my other elbow on CTRL-Q.
SF
SF 2008-03-09
I fully agree.... the Rebuilt function is not a "strong"process in SW... we reported many weackness of this process back in2005 and many of them remain the same in 2008... many people(including us) have problems with the "Rebuild" (icon andControl-Q) particularly people that work with very large Top-Downassemblies.

In our humble oppinion, SW should expend some time creatring abetter rebuild process, one capable of performing a total rebuildor large top-down assemblies, a "Super Control-Q" that can beexecuted on-demand. For now, some times we need to do a largemanual process (open parts do Control-Q, save parts and close themto return to the assembly and repeat the process with the next partand do this in the correct order.... something that takes for everon a top-down assembly with over 1000 parts, since after Rebuildinga Part and save it, when closing the part SW can take 3 or 4minutes to get back to the assembly (since it performs an"automatic rebuild" which is good for nothing but takes a lot oftime even on the most powerfull machine).

Perhaps SW should place some attention to this weakness beforedeveloping more "useless" functionality like the "layout sketches",or changing the way the toolbars work on a new version (We wherevery happy with the way they work before 2008).

One way to "rebuild" some assemblies is to open them... but this donot work all the times either....
SF
SF 2008-07-30
Me too!
It's taken me a couple of years to realise (with the help of theseforums), that it's not my crap assembly design, it's becauseSolidWorks' ctrl-Q is not total, just sort of random. The only wayis to open your top level assembly and any parts you want updatedand cycle through top level configs and random but plentifulctrl-tabs. Eventually, the model seems to settle into a workingstate!

Come on SW! Give us a TOTAL re-build? Please?
CC
CC 2008-07-30
Try SuperRebuild macro by Paul Kellner. You can find it athttp://sw.fcsuper.com/

I am actually trying to debug a problem with it that I found withmy install of SW, so if it doesn't work for you hold on a coupledays and I may have a solution. Some people are saying it worksfine for them (SW2008 SP4).