merge result checkbox missing in 1st extrude creates problem for linear pattern

Hi

It's a Friday and I should be dong other stuff but I've just run into this little frustration again.

I frequently want to produce rough cutlists that includes the waste material for machining on the end.

Here's a part that illustrates what I do, I use a linear pattern with the vary sketch option.  Here the length of the posts are 50mm above the construction line.  It simple and works fine, but only when I first extrude a dummy body somewhere which is later deleted.

If I don't do this (and I always forget!) I get this...

Its because there is no option to uncheck 'merge result' on the first extrude.

Just one of those annoying little things??

Anyway Happy Friday

SolidworksParts And Features
Comments 5
KL
KL 2015-11-13

I'm not understanding the problem. Can you post the example for review & testing?

AC
AC 2015-11-13

Try to pattern the body instead of the feature

GS
GS 2015-11-13

I'm pretty sure Alice is right.  If you're using SW2015 or 2016 you should be able to edit that feature and make the change.  If it's an earlier version you'll need to delete it and create a new one (see #21 at ).

RE
RE 2015-11-14

Im sorry I don't think I explained myself properly, Im using the vary sketch option so need to pattern a feature not a body.

Ive done a slghtly more complcated example where it follows a path to illustrate the behavour Im after

All I'm saying is I have to do an extrude and then delete it to get this to work, If someone can get this working without that I'd love to see it

RE
RE 2015-11-16

Hello again

I have come up with a more satisfying workflow for this situation that also has a few other benefits, so I'll leave it here in case anyone else would like to comment or build upon it

1st extrude the outline sketch in the reverse direction, this is akin to having a board that all the other features will stick to

next extrude the base feature taking care with constraints and ensuring there is a dimension that can be used to drive the linear pattern

Use the Linear Pattern, here my pattern is all driven by equations so I can easily adjust the number from a global variable

The significant advantage of this method is that mirror works well in the parametric environment too

Then I use the front plane to cut with surface to get the individual pieces for the cutlst

I can then do my machining operations on the overlength pieces, here these are oak coverlats that will pass through a spindle moulder

finally I can use the original sketch with flip side to cut to get my finished parts

I always find the and configurations a little bit confusing so I just make an additional configuration called to get the cutlist I need.

Anyway I hope this helps someone, I'm happy that I've come up with a workflow that is no longer idiosyncratic

The only bit that doesn't work so well is the 3d bounding box in the cutlst doesn't get automatically created when new bodies are added, but that's a frustraton for another day