Hi All (Sorry I rant a little here)
I'm currently using Desktop EDA which I love and works perfectly,but as I just had an upgrade to Premium I thought I might as wellgive Circuitworks a chance. Especially as Desktop EDA is moving toa yearly subs model. Hopefully it will do what I want.
So far I've setup my library (would be nice if I could use analready existing DB rather than maintaining two dbs though. Ialready have this info in my EDA DB) and imported a design intoSolidworks, that went fine. I am using the same fully modelledparts that I used with Desktop EDA, not auto extruded ones.
Now I changed the position of several components in my Ecad system,and exported a new IDF file. I opened the new IDF file incircuitworks but there is no update option, it seems you have toexport the design back from solidworks into circuitworks first.that wouldn't be so bad, except it insists you must have acomponent outline sketch set up first. That means I have to addthem in to all my components. grr. Anyway, I can live with that,but why does it need this anyway with fully modelled parts, when Ionly want to import changes to SW not export anything?
OK, so I add sketches to the parts and export the deign intoCircuitworks and hit the compare button. It correctly tells me someparts moved and I select update the assembly. The preview windowupdates correctly, but I can't see how to update the solidworksassembly ? The only thing I can see to do, is save a new IDF file,but not update the assembly with changes only. I think I must bebeing a little stupid here..... ;-)
Help appreciated.
RichSolidworksCircuitworks
I'm currently using Desktop EDA which I love and works perfectly,but as I just had an upgrade to Premium I thought I might as wellgive Circuitworks a chance. Especially as Desktop EDA is moving toa yearly subs model. Hopefully it will do what I want.
So far I've setup my library (would be nice if I could use analready existing DB rather than maintaining two dbs though. Ialready have this info in my EDA DB) and imported a design intoSolidworks, that went fine. I am using the same fully modelledparts that I used with Desktop EDA, not auto extruded ones.
Now I changed the position of several components in my Ecad system,and exported a new IDF file. I opened the new IDF file incircuitworks but there is no update option, it seems you have toexport the design back from solidworks into circuitworks first.that wouldn't be so bad, except it insists you must have acomponent outline sketch set up first. That means I have to addthem in to all my components. grr. Anyway, I can live with that,but why does it need this anyway with fully modelled parts, when Ionly want to import changes to SW not export anything?
OK, so I add sketches to the parts and export the deign intoCircuitworks and hit the compare button. It correctly tells me someparts moved and I select update the assembly. The preview windowupdates correctly, but I can't see how to update the solidworksassembly ? The only thing I can see to do, is save a new IDF file,but not update the assembly with changes only. I think I must bebeing a little stupid here..... ;-)
Help appreciated.
RichSolidworksCircuitworks

This forum needs some more action ;-)
I'm new to circuit board design and have not used Circuitworks(have used the lite version). I am looking into it although my usesfor it is going to be very simple. DOnt want to upgarde to premiumand wondering if the Desktop EDA has the same functionality. Mainuse for me is to view supplied circuit board and move components/revise board outlines and send back to the PCB engineer.
Any thoughts?
Thanks--
Joe
I used the full Solidworks modeller suite from Desktop EDA, not theIDF importer so can't comment on that one. The Full modeller worksslightly differently in that it plugs into the pcb program andpushes or pulls the changes across without the IDF middle step. Theinterface is a little clunky but it works fantastically well andthe company are great with support. I recommend it. The IDFimporter should do what you need very well, but I haven't tried it.Contact them for a demo.
Rich
Thanks for the reply. What is the full modeller suite called? Areyou saying you need to get software for the PCB program (PADS inthis case) as well as SW? I know there is a PADS ASCII modeleravailable--
I will ask around--
Are you currently using Circuitworks and dropped Desktop EDA?
Thanks--
Joe
>What is the full modeller suite called?
Look on the products page, top, I use 'Solidworks Modeller forAltium' Only works with Altium software.
>Are you saying you need to get software for the PCB program(PADS in this case) as well as SW?
No, if Pads has the IDF export option all you need is the 'SW IDFModdeller', if pads doesn't have the IDF export, it looks like youneed the 'SW IDF modeller' and the 'Pads Ascii option' for it.
>Are you currently using Circuitworks and dropped Desktop EDA?
No, I still use Desktop-EDA (Its great). I'm just testing thewaters with Circuitworks at the moment. I plan to switch over atsome point though.
Rich