Comparing SW 08 and Another CAD package

Hi All....

Now of course I use solidworks every time when do my job.Previously I am Auto*** user. I like solidworks because easy touse, very simple steps & great GUI.

I want to know about plus minus solidworks 2008 comparing toanother CAD package likes Pro*, U*, Invent***. Simple case, today Isaw on the internet that Auto*** 2007 already have instant 3D likein sw 08.

1. So...., what is the new technology / feature that onlysolidworks that have the features. I mean another cad package doesnot have those features.

2. Please give me some independent comments about comparing sw 08and another cad package.

Thank`s

Regards
-DD "I can`t far a way from solidworks"


SolidworksGeneral
Comments 2
ML
ML 2007-09-04
Personally, I would avoid the "this has this or that" sort ofcomparison. If you believe that AutoCAD 2007 has Instant3D andSolidWorks is just getting it in 2008, then there is somethingwrong. The fact is that Instant3D is really just functionality thathas been in SW for years (since 97 or 98) called Move/SizeFeatures. In 08 there are some enhancements to it, but most of itis either rehashed or reskinned to look different but workessentially the same.

Unless you actually use software, I think it is impossible to do ameaningful comparison, and even then you need someone who isknowledgable to guide you through it. Salesmen are salesmen, andmarketing materials lie. Determine what kinds of functionality youneed, and then use a bunch of packages to see which one has thebest total offering.

As long as you can get your work done with SW, I would stick withit but continue to evaluate. I know it's tough evaluating softwarewithout talking to sales people, but they will make an activeeffort to cloud your judgment. If you talk to other softwareexperts, you might want to also talk to SW experts to make sureyou're not missing something that already exists. Like Instant3D /Move/Size Features.
SF
SF 2007-09-05
Matt's right, I'd hold as suspect anyone who suggested usingAutoCAD 2007 to supplant Solidworks for MCAD. Even Autodeskwouldn't do that.
however, having worked with AutoCAD 2007, I will tell you that itnow has lofts, sweeps, 3D Otrack (which doesn't work on thesolidbody that you're editing) and some pretty cool presentationmodes. I can also say that the move, rotate and align commands veryclosely resemble the 'move with triad' tool in Solidworks. I alsoknow that AutoCAD's system spec required to run the new 3D tools isoutrageous. I would put it on par with Solidworks 2000, except thatit doesn't have editable features, driving dimensions,configurations, sheet metal, mates, assembly features, 3D splinetangency, sketch releations or incontext features.
Now, Inventor has made a point of staying very close to Solidworks'level of functionality and they've branched into some new territoryas far as libraries and catalogs are concerned. They still don'thave all of Solidworks' surfacing commands, but Inventor usersaren't jumping ship over that.