We are currently looking at CIDEON and SAP to use for ourfile management, design history, and approvals. We are currentlyuse SAP for material management and may upgrade in the near future.Our question is what to use SAP to do. I would like to hear if youare using this system, and get an idea of how well it is workingfor you.
Thanks
Dwight
SolidworksGeneral
Thanks
Dwight
SolidworksGeneral

We will use SAP to read the SW parts properties, just the basicssuch as weight and materials, but what we are expecting to get themost advantage of is the potential to create Material Masters andBOMs from within Solidworks and concentrate our designers on theirdesigns.
Another benefit we expect, as we are just starting to deploy SW asthe official CAD tool, is the file management and authorizationcontrols that it promises to deliver. Our designer group is over 20people and we have fears over letting the control without a systemthat can oversee the files statuses and relationships. If you arestill interested let me now so we can exchange further info.
Humberto
humbertob@translead.com
- Anthony
we use an other SAP interface for SolidWorks since a long time andwe are somewhat happy with it. It is possible to hide SAP masks asmuch as possible from the users and to have the openess tostreamline our processes to fast and convinient interface fullyintegrated in SolidWorks.
Oh, the name is Porta~X developed byHCV data located in Germany.
I'm not a salesman, really!
Bye Ingo
Hello Anthony,
Would you mind sharing a little of your experience with the SAP PLM? Has it made your work easier?
I posted a few months ago, stating that we were about to implement the module, but as it turns out, we only got to the testing phase and for some reason the project got stucked along with our deployment of Solidworks.
For almost a year I've been arguing with my bosses that with the amount of files and users we have in our group, it is not possible to have file control without one of these systems, I have not been able to proof that I am right, but the few instances when we have ventured to work without the PLM, we have suffered greatly, and we see a lot of broken file links, or we end up affecting files we don't mean to affect, assemblies get messed up, etc. all this in detriment of other users in our group. In the demos and few tests that we have made, I can see great potential to solve all those issues.
Could you confirm if the mentioned problems get solved by the use of this PLM?
Thank you
Humberto
humbertob@translead.com
Hi All,
we just published a short AVI showing some key features and functions.
You can find it on the SolidWorks webpage:
http://www.solidworks.com/sw/products/details.htm?productid=2988
Regards, Rolf
Hello Humberto,
Integrating SolidWorks with SAP was not an easy task, but thankfully we were not be doing this alone. We get the continued support from ourlocal reseller, in our case CENIT (Schweiz) AG, and Cideon themselves who are willing to constantly listen to your needs and even adjust their product to suit.
I beleive that you would not be able to sucessfully use SAP as a DMS for 3D CAD data without the integration package. Admitedly, it is possible, but te amount of work you would need to do manually would cost more in time for your engineers than they would spend engineering the products.
For example, the Cideon product will :
There are lots of excellent functions and many more than i can list here, so I would advise that you contact Cideon to arrange a demonstration of the software.
I would think that if you are storing solidworks models/assemblies/drawings in SAP, that you would greatly benefit form the control that a PDM integration would give you. A PDM product could save you a great deal of time in all of your engineering processes!
Just for your information, we are a multi-site organisation with four main engineering design sites based throughout europe. Each of these sites have their SolidWorks systems integrated with SAP. We have a total of 50 SolidWorks users currently integrated, with more planned for the future.
Our engineering teams collaborate on several projects at the same time so we need the functionality of an effective PDM system along with an excellent IT infrastructure. It would be impossible for us to do this over the multisites without a PDM tool.
I hope that gives you a little more information, but please contact me if you have any further questions
Best wishes
Anthony