Ok, here's my question:
See the picture below:
If column 1 is for loading the add-in in the current session and column 2 is for automatically loading the add-in in future sessions,
Then why is it that, for some add-ins (like Design Checker, apparently), you have to restart Solidworks to get it to load?
Don't get me wrong, I don't mind having to restart Solidworks, but if you truly DO have to restart Solidworks to get it to load,
then what is the left column check box for (for that particular add-in) at all? There is no point to even having a check box there. Just have the one on the right and be done with it.
I am guessing that I don't understand something (which is why I am asking the question).
SolidworksParts And Features
Agreed Dan. This is the first time I've ran across something not working cuz it was already loaded. That's the way that I understand it too, the rightmost column is to load every time automatically whereas the leftmost is only for the current session (and it wouldn't be loaded every session by default). I'm behind the times on SW2015 but hey, its solid and fine for now. I tried SW2016 a year or so ago and found issues with importing / saving / running Tekla .IFC files where stuff would be all over the place (nothing mated) upon reload. Although everything looked fine and saved up before I closed the file. Dassault acknowledged the problem on that build at the time. Don't know if it was fixed but it seems to me they rushed it out and broke something that works perfectly for me in the older version. For that reason, I have not updated.
Look ,
If SWX didn't introduce new bugs, they'd have nothing to fix...It's a jobs program, I don't understand how you can be so insensitive. /s
Actually, you don't have to close out of SWX. Once you load it from the Tools menu, it stays loaded until you uncheck the box in the Add-Ins box you posted. I just tested it and that works. However, the start-up doesn't seem to do anything, as you stated. Maybe someone from SWX can elaborate on the thinking about how the Add-In functions. There may be some reasons that it works the way it does, I just can't think of any. Who's the resident expert on DC on these forums?
Actually, I meant it the other way around from what you are stating:
As an example, Dave checked the left box and the right box. The left box loads the add-in immediately, while the right box loads the add-in next time you start Solidworks.
However, the add-in did not work until he restarted Solidworks. Meaning that the left box completely failed in its function.
I see what you mean...I haven't been using it enough. I just checked 2017 SP3 and when I tick the checkbox on the left, you are right, it doesn't appear to do anything. However, if I untick that checkbox Design Checker disappears from the flyout on the right, and I have to go back to Tools>Design Checker to activate it again. This is confusing functionality.
I'd add someone from SWX to this post if I knew who would be familiar with Design Checker, but a quick search only produced recent posts from users. Though, I did see a post from about a video series about Design Checker that doesn't appear to be active anymore (original post from 2013). I hate to bother , but maybe he knows who the SWX person is that can answer if this is a bug or intended functionality?
,
I did some more digging on this and it appears to be their intended functionality:
https://customerportal.solidworks.com/eservice_enu/start.swe?SWECmd=InvokeMethod&SWEMethod=GotoRecord&SWEService=SWGotoR…
S-046824
In SolidWorks, why is the Design Checker not shown in the drop down tabs when activated in the add-ins?
From SolidWorks 2010 onwards the user interface for the Design Checker has been fully integrated into toolbars and menus of the SolidWorks software. A Design Checker toolbar button is added to the Evaluate tab of the Command Manager.
When selecting a related command, the add-in loads dynamically, provided SolidWorks Professional or SolidWorks Premium is installed and running.
Click Tools > Design Checker. The Design Checker tab is added to the Task Pane.
So, maybe the checkboxes should be "Greyed" in the Add-Ins pane?
This is correct. Starting in SOLIDWORKS 2010, we added the UI for some of the add-ins that come with SOLIDWORKS Professional and Premium (Design Checker, FeatureWorks, SOLIDWORKS Utilities) so the UI is always present, regardless of whether the add-in is turned on or not. This has the benefit of making the functionality more discoverable without adding to the memory footprint of having the add-in actually loaded into memory; the add-in automatically loads when one of the commands is selected. The Design Checker UI is predominantly in the Tools, Design Checker menu and should be present whether you have the add-in turned on or not. If you run some of the Design Checker commands, the UI shows in the Task Pane and if you turn off the Design Checker in Tools, Add-ins that UI will go away because the add-in is being removed from memory. But, the commands should still be there under Tools, Design Checker to restart the command. So, you don't have to restart SOLIDWORKS to get the UI back.
, are you seeing something different than what I describe?
Thanks,
Jim
Hrmm, maybe not.
I was originally commenting on the issue that David Krum was having.
I was always wondering why there was a "Last Load Time" for the Design Checker even though I left it turned off!
So, with it turned off, you are saying that I should still have full functionality for the Design Checker.
So, I run Design Checker -> Build Checks
The look at my Tools --> Add ins and suddenly it is checked.
Interesting functionality.
I am curious then. Why is the Design Checker even listed in the add-ins section? Is it just to turn it off and remove it from memory once you are done with it?
Jim,
Thanks for clarifying that. I think Dan's confusion is the same as mine about am confused about the difference in behavior between those tools and say Simulation, where something happens when you check those boxes. I'm not saying it should be changed, just clarifying what I was confused about.
Regarding those check boxes, could you clarify how the "locking" works? I know if I load Simulation (we have 1 premium license) nobody else can load it until I deactivate it. Do those check boxes lock functionality? So in a scenario where there were 1 Standard and 1 Pro license, if 1 user checked those boxes would the other user be able to run DC, or would it show up as locked? I could see arguments for having the software work either way, maybe you could clarify that also?
Edit to Add: Dan was confused about something completely different...and he posted before I completed my post.
Yes, that and the fact that it is an add-in from an architectural standpoint. Theoretically we could probably do extra work to have it not show at all in the add-ins, but there are benefits for having it there for troubleshooting purposes, etc.
Thanks,
Jim
Yes, it is a bit confusing since it is inconsistent from a UI standpoint, but for the add-ins that have lots of UI (like Simulation, PhotoView360, etc.), we didn't want to have that UI visible to the user without the add-in loaded because the UI would get overly cluttered with things they might not use often. For those that we don't have the full UI visible when the add-in is not loaded, we put the option to turn them on/off in the SOLIDWORKS Add-Ins tab of the CommandManager to try to make them more discoverable than how they were prior to SOLIDWORKS 2010 (which was only in the Tools, Add-ins dialog, which is not discoverable at all). So there are a couple of levels of "discoverability" of add-ins that we added with SOLIDWORKS 2010:
If you are using network licenses and an add-in requires a certain license to run that add-in (i.e. a Professional license rather than a Standard license), then yes, the license will be locked when the add-in is loaded. So, the Startup option on an add-in from a higher level license does provide the ability for a user to lock the license when they startup the software. So, actually this does remind me of another reason that we decided to keep all of the add-ins visible in the add-in dialog, even if we show their full command access UI in the software even when the add-in is not loaded; so the user has access to that license locking functionality.
Thanks,
Jim
Thanks Jim,
I think I understand now.