2009 sp2.0 welment profile stands alone

can not modify profile in SW2009.
Relocated profile will not go with weldment body. Sketch profile stays at the original position separated from relocated weldment.
See attachment. I rotated profile 90deg. Body have relocated. Profile stays at original location.
Any idea how to fix it?SolidworksWeldments
Comments 20
SF
SF 2009-02-04
Mark
I have it rotated as you can see in the attached file. The problem is that after rebuilt sketch did not rotate. It jumps back and stays separated from body it's belongs to.
What I need is to have sketch profile in line with the body. We use custom profiles and modify profile sketch dimentions in the model. Till now it worked smooth.

It's a bug.
SF
SF 2009-02-04
Worked in 2008. Log it as a problem.
The more people that log a problem the more chance of getting it put right.
SF
SF 2009-02-04
same thing, cannot modify Sketch profile or position of weldment member not drive directly from sketch
I have asked my reseller to raise an SPR for next service Pack nothing can be DONE AT THIS TIME the more users that raise it the more chance it has of getting fixed
SF
SF 2009-02-04
reconmend reverting back to sw 2008 if creating from scratch until problem in 2009 is fixed if working on existing model converted to 2009 version unlucky and best of luck
SF
SF 2009-02-04
Lana,

What do you mean by relocated?
Did you use the property manager to rotate your profile?or did you actually went into the profile sketch and modified the skectch?
SF
SF 2009-02-04

adrian velazquez wrote:

 

Lana,



What do you mean by relocated?

Did you use the property manager to rotate your profile?or did you actually went into the profile sketch and modified the skectch?

Adrian,
try. Insert weldment. It's uneaqual angle in attached screen shot. I need to rotate it 90 deg. Locate profile :90 deg. Rebuilt. Angle body will be rotated. Weldment Profile Sketch will not. It stays at original location.
SF
SF 2009-02-05
I received reply from support:

I was not able to reproduce the issue.
Hahaha
SF
SF 2009-02-05
Lana,
Use SolidWorks Rx to record a video of what you are doing and send that to your VAR. A picture is worth a thousand word, a movie is priceless.
SF
SF 2009-02-05
Wayne
I gave them description & jpeg.
Don't you think movie and zip of the model is too much for this issue?

SF
SF 2009-02-05
There's an SPR against this problem.
SF
SF 2009-02-06
Response I got from solidworks

The engineer at Solidworks suggests that this issue relates to the method that you are using to construct the weldment, and is not a fault.
He has created a sample file (which I have attached to this email) to demonstrate the required method. You could also take a look at the tutorial covering this subject, as this may help to clarify.

The reponse I gave them to their response

I appreciate what the solidworks expert is trying to suggest however for the past 4 or 5 years the way that the weldments operated was a very good tool in that you could adjust position of a sketch and suddenly they remove that function and then to say that it's not a problem with solidworks, well for me solidworks has lost some of it's functionality that it had previously, on the last 3 versions (2008 2007 2006 ) bit of copout answer if you ask me.
These guys are supposed to be the experts? No one in Steel fabrication industry measures from the centre of a box section so why are we now forced to work from the centres when creating designs and drawings very confusing and a bit Crazy ! If you go on any solidworks related forum and look up this issue the customers out there are not best pleased.

Also an awful lot of Hassle to get an SPR raised for very little professional feed back from solidworks I know if I blamed our clients for our tools not working the way they did when they brought them, we wouldn't be in business for much longer

Oh well if this is the way it's going to be there's not much I suppose we can do about it, except live with the loss of some more functionality of Solidworks for now.

Just to let you know what my solution is, I have reinstalled 2008 and, I'm now using this for weldment design only and getting on just fine and dimensioning from the edge.
SF
SF 2009-02-06
Daniel, I do not see the attachment and would like to know "HOW WE ARE SUPPOSED TO DO IT NOW".
SF
SF 2009-02-06
basically what they are telling us is you can not move or adjust the sketch profile anymore. you have to align the driving sketch ie the constuction line to exactly the point where you want the member to be. This means in most members you have to dimension the line the extrude follows to the centre of squre tube for instance, accounting for its size ie subtractng or adding the distance to the centre of the sketch profile if its 4" squre tube or box section you have to add or subtract 2" to allow for where the placement of the sketch is as the constuction line will now only ever work from the centre of the box section or any member in fact

its aload garbage hence my last post on this above

as to the attchment i'm unable to upload the document Sorry!
SF
SF 2009-02-06
FYI

This issue only occurs when using the downloaded profile from the solidworks content ansi iso bsi.......

it seams to be alright if using the weldment profiles which come with solidworks install ansi iso but theres not much to chosse from
SF
SF 2009-02-07
OK so now Lana is now going to have to have 8 different profiles for each unequal angle iron size since you cannot rotate the profile or mirror the profile any more.

If any of you are going to SolidWorks World, I suggest that you find the person in charge of weldments and talk to them.
NL
NL 2009-02-07
ok maybe I am missing something here but I dont see the issue aside from the sketch not showing as moved when highlighted in the FM.
Do you want to reuse the sketch or something?
I can relocate the profile pierce point as I please and rotate, mirror and change the dimensions in the sketch and the weldment builds as desired.
This is using the downloaded zip profiles...

The BOM lengths and angles are correct
SF
SF 2009-02-09
Myself, I skipped from SW2005 to SW2009 so weldments are new to me. After using it for a while, I thought that the weldment profile was meant to stay in the original position because that how all of them behaved once rotated. After reading this post I realized that when using "model items", they are dimensioning the profile and the profile is off to the side and hidden. This causes lots of confusion in the shop when the guys see dims not attached to model lines.

To me, it's a bug and it should get fixed!

NL
NL 2009-02-10
Weldments are actually in 05. I just checked up on this again myself and I see Lana's point now and yours - in 05 the sketch moves in 09 it doesnt.
It should be reported as a bug.
thanks for pointing out the issue
SF
SF 2009-02-10

Wayne Matus wrote:

 

OK so now Lana is now going to have to have 8 different profiles for each unequal angle iron size since you cannot rotate the profile or mirror the profile any more.


Wayne is right. I double click weldment body (angle in this example) to modify angle size. Dimensions in profile is automatically updated in Weldment cut list.


MD
MD 2009-11-20
You can edit the profile sketch and use Modify to rotate the profile.