Using WPDM enabled Revision Tables

I am currently working on setting up WPDM for my company and am working with a test vault on my local computer before setting up the network vault for all user. I have experience with it at my previous company but they did not utilize the WPDM revision table.

My question: After inserting my revision table, I add my revision and any corresponding revision symbols. Now I go to check and fill in the notes section (where the revision description comes from) and check-in my document, the software inserts a new revision line with the revision and description. Not a problem except now the revision line I previously added is still there and the symbols reference it and not the WPDM created revision line. Why doesn't it add the revision description to my existing line? What if i wanted to print my drawing prior to checking it in? The revision line would be missing. If I rely on the WPDM adding the revision line at check-in, I can't add my revision symbols. So now I have to check it back out, add the revision symbols, and check it back in? When I check it back in the second time, I don't want to bump the revision again, so I use read from file. Now if i dont fill in the revision description again, my revision line is missing its description.

Anybody know what to do to make this work easier? Or should I do the revision table manually and not rely on WPDM like we did at my previous company?

Thanks for any replies,

Matt Martens

SolidworksWorkgroup Pdm
Answers 4
JH
JH 2013-09-05 Best Answer

It is an awkward workflow but if you use WPDM to maintain the rev block, I'm afraid there's not much choice. Overall, I have found the benefits to outweigh the problems. I think what you outlined about "read from file" is about the best you can hope for - just be sure to enter the rev line info again prior to hitting "checkin".

MM
MM 2013-09-06

That's what I thought. I will have to weigh the pros and cons before deciding what to do for our system. The good news is I am pretty much the only significant user (about 98% me, 2% the other guy) at my company.

SF
SF 2013-09-11

Matt,

We tried using the WPDM revision method and very quickly gave up. It was universally agreed to be unusable and bass-ackwards. There are some people and companies, like Jeff's, that are willing to live with the pain. We weren't.

Jerry S.

MM
MM 2013-09-11

I have always worked in smaller companies (<4 designers) where it was policy to check in your documents every night and clean out your local drive. The WPDM revision table would be useful if I only had to check in documents when they were completed or done being worked on for the time being. For those of us that check-in documents frequently w/o changing the revision, the revision table makes it very difficult. You would have to re-insert the revision description on every check-in or else you lose it. That in and of itself is enough to warrant not using it in my mind.